Nonsuicidal Self-Injury and Substance Use Disorders: A Shared Language of Addiction

Salvatore Giorgi, McKenzie Himelein-Wachowiak, Daniel Habib, Lyle Ungar, Brenda Curtis2022 · DOI

Abstract

Nonsuicidal self-injury (NSSI) and substance use disorders (SUDs) share several clinical characteristics, including impulsivity and high comorbidity with other mental health conditions. This study investigates whether these similarities extend to the language used by these communities online. By analyzing discussions on Reddit, we demonstrate that NSSI users have adopted a "language of addiction"—using terms like "clean," "relapse," and "recovery" in ways nearly identical to those in SUD recovery. However, their broader online behavior diverges: while SUD users engage more with general-interest communities, NSSI users are deeply embedded in a wider network of mental health-related subreddits.

Introduction: The Addiction Framework of Self-Harm

A long-standing clinical debate centers on whether nonsuicidal self-injury (NSSI)—the deliberate harming of one's body without suicidal intent—should be classified as an addiction. Qualitative observations have often noted that individuals who self-injure use recovery-oriented language. This research quantifies that overlap by comparing the linguistic and behavioral patterns of NSSI and SUD communities on Reddit. Understanding these patterns is crucial for clinicians who may leverage addiction-based models for treating self-harm and for platforms providing online support.

Methodology

The study utilized a dataset of approximately 155,000 comments and 2 million posts from the 2019 Pushshift Reddit Dataset. To isolate the specific themes of these communities, the researchers employed Content Specific Latent Dirichlet Allocation (CSLDA). This model filters out general "noise" from common Reddit vocabulary (using r/AskReddit as a baseline) to focus on domain-specific topics.

The researchers matched 2,470 users from each group based on activity levels. The NSSI cohort was drawn from r/selfharm, while the SUD cohort included users from recovery-focused subreddits such as r/stopdrinking and r/addiction.

Linguistic Overlap: A Shared Vocabulary of Recovery

The topic modeling revealed a significant thematic overlap between the two groups. Out of 50 generated topics, 9 were identified as being explicitly related to addiction or recovery.

Average topic usage across NSSI and SUD communities, highlighting shared recovery-oriented language.

As shown in Figure 1, topics involving "clean" time, "relapse," and "recovery" showed nearly equivalent usage rates. For NSSI users, tracking "days clean" from self-harm has become a central part of their community identity, mirroring the sobriety milestones celebrated in SUD recovery. This suggests that the "addiction" framework is not merely metaphorical but a dominant conceptual lens through which NSSI users view their behavior.

Behavioral Divergence: Mental Health Generalists vs. Specialists

While their language overlaps, the groups' posting habits across the rest of Reddit reveal a stark contrast in their digital footprints. NSSI users function as "mental health generalists," frequently participating in subreddits dedicated to depression, anxiety, and suicide ideation.

Comparison of top subreddits frequented by NSSI and SUD users, demonstrating different patterns of community engagement.

According to the data in Figure 2, 37.8% of NSSI users also posted in r/depression and 33.9% in r/SuicideWatch. In contrast, SUD users showed much lower engagement with these specific mental health forums, instead favoring general interest subreddits like r/pics (21.9%) and r/funny (21.8%). This suggests that while self-injury is framed as an addiction, it is more deeply intertwined with a broader spectrum of psychiatric distress than typical SUD recovery.

Clinical Implications and Future Directions

The adoption of SUD language by NSSI communities may provide a "buffering" effect, helping individuals frame their struggle as a manageable condition with clear, achievable milestones. However, the high degree of cross-posting in other mental health forums highlights the complexity of NSSI.

Future research should investigate whether adopting this addiction identity leads to better long-term outcomes or if it inadvertently reinforces a chronic self-perception. Additionally, understanding why SUD users appear less engaged with broader mental health communities online could help improve holistic support for addiction recovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nonsuicidal self-injury (NSSI), or the deliberate injuring of one's body without intending to die, has been shown to exhibit many similarities to substance use disorders (SUDs), including population-level characteristics, impulsivity traits, and comorbidity with other mental disorders. Research has further shown that people who self-injure adopt language common in SUD recovery communities (e.g., "clean", "relapse", "addiction," and celebratory language about sobriety milestones). In this study, we investigate the shared language of NSSI and SUD by comparing discussions on public Reddit forums related to self-injury and drug addiction. To this end, we build a set of LDA topics across both NSSI and SUD Reddit users and show that shared language across the two domains includes SUD recovery language in addition to other themes common to support forums (e.g., requests for help and gratitude). Next, we examine Reddit-wide posting activity and note that users posting in r/selfharm also post in many mental healthrelated subreddits, while users of drug addiction related subreddits do not, despite high comorbidity between NSSI and SUDs. These results show that while people who self-injure may contextualize their disorder as an addiction, their posting habits demonstrate comorbidities with other mental disorders more so than their counterparts in recovery from SUDs. These observations have clinical implications for people who self-injure and seek support by sharing their experiences online. pain, brain, addiction, body, physical i've, that's, haven't, done, since things, thoughts, these, feelings, emotions best, luck, wish, friend, love ve, re, don, ll, through clean, relapse, again, months, recovery better, than, easier, gets, worse here, post, sub, support, advice thanks, thank, :), i'll, ll same, thing, way, did, yeah started, myself, did, got, stop you're, yourself, that's, you've, you'll could, maybe, might, something, may don, ve, didn, did, anything yourself, take, care, love, please am, very, yes, thankful, grateful going, keep, back, through, right right, step, part, proud, important hope, better, sorry, well, hear stay, strong, safe, please, friend thank, thanks, words, kind, appreciate myself, feeling, pain, sometimes, makes coping, find, stop, cutting, sh yeah, yes, sometimes, though, kinda helps, exercise, helped,
BibTeX
@misc{giorgi2022nonsuicidal,
  author = {Salvatore Giorgi and McKenzie Himelein-Wachowiak and Daniel Habib and Lyle Ungar and Brenda Curtis},
  title = {{Nonsuicidal Self-Injury and Substance Use Disorders: A Shared Language of Addiction}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.18653/v1/2022.clpsych-1.15},
}
Figure