Abstract
New predictions regarding the role of color flow in high energy Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) processes have emerged in the last decade. In particular, the role of color flow is now being explored through many different observables; one such observable is nearly back-to-back hadron correlations in proton-proton collisions which are predicted to be sensitive to states that are entangled via their QCD color charge. The PHENIX detector at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider is well suited to study potential effects from color flow. Angular correlations between nearly back-to-back hadrons or a direct photon-hadron are measured to study the prediction of color entanglement or factorization breaking. The correlations can be treated in a transverse-momentum-dependent framework where sensitivity to non-Abelian effects from color are predicted. These measurements are the first ever to search for experimental evidence of these entangled states and will help establish color flow in hadronic interactions as a new area of focus within QCD research. Results are presented for proton-proton collisions at center-of-mass energies of 200 and 510 GeV and proton-nucleus collisions at nucleon-nucleon center-of-mass energies of 200 GeV. World measurements of processes where factorization is predicted to hold are also compiled and analyzed to compare to the new experimental results presented here. The measured results do not indicate any obvious qualitative differences from observables where factorization is predicted to hold. This indicates that quantitative comparisons with phenomenological calculations will be necessary to identify the magnitude of effects from color entanglement. As QCD is the only non-Abelian quantum field theory known to exist in nature that admits bound states, it will be essential to continue exploring unique QCD phenomena due to color interactions in controlled ways in the coming years.
Introduction: The Challenge of Factorization
In the study of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the principle of factorization serves as a fundamental mathematical framework. It allows physicists to separate high-energy "hard" scattering processes from the "soft" nonperturbative physics of how partons (quarks and gluons) are bound within hadrons. However, theoretical advancements suggest that in collisions involving multiple hadrons, this separation may fail due to "color entanglement."
Because gluons carry color charge, they can be exchanged between scattered partons and the remnants of the parent protons both before and after the primary collision. This exchange can link the particles in a way that standard factorization cannot describe. This research presents the first experimental search for evidence of this phenomenon using the PHENIX detector at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC).
Methodology and Observables
The study utilizes two-particle angular correlations to probe the transverse-momentum-dependent (TMD) dynamics of the collision. Two specific channels are compared:
- Dihadron correlations: Pairs of hadrons produced nearly back-to-back. These are predicted to be sensitive to factorization breaking.
- Direct photon-hadron correlations: A photon and a hadron produced back-to-back. Since photons do not carry color charge, they provide a control group where factorization is expected to hold more robustly.
The key observable is $p_{out}$, the out-of-plane momentum component. By measuring the width of $p_{out}$ distributions across different energy scales, the research tests for deviations from Collins-Soper-Sterman (CSS) evolution, which predicts how these widths should grow with the hard scale of the interaction.
Analysis of $p+p$ and $p+A$ Collisions
The Fragmentation Effect
Initial measurements at 510 GeV showed an unexpected trend: momentum widths appeared to decrease as the energy scale increased. The author identified this as a "fragmentation trap"—a kinematic illusion. As the trigger particle's energy increases, the relative momentum fraction ($z$) of the observed hadron often decreases. By binning the data using $x_E$ (a proxy for $z$), the study demonstrated that the widths actually increase with energy, aligning qualitatively with standard CSS evolution.
Nuclear Broadening
In proton-nucleus ($p+A$) collisions, the research observed a statistically significant broadening of the away-side widths compared to proton-proton ($p+p$) data. This broadening scales with the number of binary collisions ($N_{coll}$), suggesting the nuclear medium provides an additional "kick" to the partons. Crucially, no broadening was observed on the near-side (particles traveling in the same direction), which rules out final-state fragmentation effects and points toward initial-state interactions or complex color flow.
Conclusions
The research provides the first-ever measurements of nonperturbative momentum widths in processes predicted to break factorization. While the results do not show an "obvious" qualitative signature of color entanglement—as $p+p$ widths for dihadrons and photon-hadrons remain consistent when scaled—they establish a vital experimental baseline.
Future work with the sPHENIX detector and the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) will be necessary to achieve the statistical precision required to distinguish subtle color entanglement effects from standard QCD evolution. These findings mark the beginning of a new era in exploring the non-Abelian nature of the strong force in complex hadronic environments.
Summary updated