Nonparametric identification in panels using quantiles

Whitney K. Newey, Iván Fernández‐Val, Stefan Hoderlein, Victor ChernozhukovJournal of Econometrics 2013

TL;DR

This paper develops a new nonparametric framework for identifying and estimating causal effects in panel data models, even when the relationship between variables is complex and non-linear. By leveraging time homogeneity and quantile analysis, the authors provide a robust method to understand how changes in one variable affect another over time, offering a more flexible alternative to traditional approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Economists and social scientists often want to understand the causal impact of a variable (say, education) on an outcome (like income) using panel data, which tracks the same individuals over time. A key challenge is that individual-specific unobserved factors (like innate ability or preferences) can be correlated with both the "treatment" variable (education) and the outcome (income), leading to biased estimates. Traditional methods often struggle with non-linear relationships and unobserved heterogeneity. This paper tackles the problem of identifying and estimating these causal effects in a nonparametric setting, meaning they don't assume a specific functional form for the relationship between variables. They focus on "ceteris paribus" effects, which isolate the impact of one variable while holding others constant, and do so using quantile effects, which reveal how the impact varies across the distribution of outcomes.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in developing nonparametric identification and estimation strategies for panel data models. The key assumptions are:

  • Time Homogeneity: The underlying structural model is assumed to be the same across time periods, possibly with time-specific location and scale effects. This is a crucial assumption that allows changes over time in observed variables to reveal causal effects.
  • Quantile Analysis: Instead of just looking at average effects, the paper focuses on quantile effects. This allows for a richer understanding of how the impact of a variable varies across different levels of the outcome.
  • Series Estimation: For estimation, the authors propose nonparametric series methods. This involves approximating unknown functions with a series expansion (like polynomials or splines), which is a standard technique in nonparametric econometrics.
  • Weighted Bootstrap: To make inferences (e.g., construct confidence intervals), they employ a weighted bootstrap procedure. This is a resampling technique that helps to approximate the sampling distribution of the estimators, allowing for robust inference.

The paper extends previous work by allowing for more general nonseparable models and by providing identification results for quantile effects, which are often more informative than average effects.

Datasets

The authors use data from the 2007 and 2009 waves of the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID) for their empirical application. This dataset is commonly used for studying household expenditure patterns.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quantiles Offer Richer Insights: Focusing on quantile effects, rather than just average effects, reveals how the impact of expenditure on consumption varies across different levels of spending. This is crucial for understanding heterogeneous responses.
  • Time Homogeneity as a Key Identifier: The assumption of time homogeneity, even with time-varying location and scale effects, is powerful. It allows researchers to identify causal effects by comparing how variables change over time for individuals whose characteristics remain stable.
  • "Stayers" are Crucial: The identification of effects relies heavily on "stayers" – individuals whose regressor values are the same in two time periods. This subpopulation provides a clean comparison point for isolating causal impacts.
  • Time Effects Add Realism: Allowing for additive location and multiplicative scale time effects makes the model more realistic, as it accounts for shifts in the overall level and variability of outcomes over time, which are common in economic data.

Key Results

The paper provides theoretical results for the identification of both conditional mean effects and conditional quantile effects under various assumptions, including time homogeneity and time effects.

  • Identification of Average and Quantile Effects: The authors establish conditions under which ceteris paribus effects (both average and quantile) are identified. For instance, they show that conditional mean effects can be identified from derivatives of conditional expectations of differences in outcomes.
  • Empirical Application to Engel Curves: The application to Engel curves demonstrates the practical utility of their methods. They find evidence of time effects and endogeneity for leisure expenditure, suggesting that preferences and relative prices influence how households allocate spending on leisure over time. For food at home, the Engel curve relationship appears more stable.
  • Confidence Bands: The paper outlines how to construct uniform confidence bands for quantile effects, which are essential for making reliable statistical inferences.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Strong Assumptions: The time homogeneity assumption, while useful, can be strong and may not hold in all applications. The paper acknowledges this and proposes ways to relax it by allowing for time effects.
  • Data Requirements: The methods rely on panel data, requiring observations on the same individuals over multiple time periods.
  • Computational Complexity: Nonparametric estimation and inference can be computationally intensive, especially with high-dimensional data.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more general forms of time effects and investigating how to weaken independence assumptions when more than two time periods are available. They also point to the potential for using differences of quantiles and quantiles of differences for causal inference.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper considers identification and estimation of ceteris paribus effects of continuous regressors in nonseparable panel models with time homogeneity. The effects of interest are derivatives of the average and quantile structural functions of the model. We find that these derivatives are identified with two time periods for "stayers", i.e. for individuals with the same regressor values in two time periods. We show that the identification results carry over to models that allow location and scale time effects. We propose nonparametric series methods and a weighted bootstrap scheme to estimate and make inference on the identified effects. The bootstrap proposed allows inference for function-valued parameters such as quantile effects uniformly over a region of quantile indices and/or regressor values. An empirical application to Engel curve estimation with panel data illustrates the results.
BibTeX
@article{newey2013nonparametric,
  author = {Whitney K. Newey and Iván Fernández‐Val and Stefan Hoderlein and Victor Chernozhukov},
  title = {{Nonparametric identification in panels using quantiles}},
  journal = {Journal of Econometrics},
  year = {2013},
}
Figure