Nonparametric Estimation of the Fisher Information and Its Applications

Wei Cao, Alex Dytso, Michael Fauß, H. Vincent Poor, Gang FengarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Introduction

Fisher information (FI) is a fundamental metric in statistical theory, serving as a cornerstone for the Cramér-Rao bound and the analysis of complex communication systems. Despite its theoretical importance, a practical challenge remains: how can we accurately estimate the Fisher information of a distribution when the underlying probability density function (PDF) is unknown and only a finite set of samples ($n$) is available?

The Challenge of Nonparametric Estimation

The standard approach to this problem is the Bhattacharya estimator, a "plug-in" method that utilizes Kernel Density Estimation (KDE). In this framework, one estimates the density $f$ and its derivative $f'$ from the samples, then computes the Fisher information using the integral:

$$I(f) = \int \frac{(f'(t))^2}{f(t)} dt$$

However, this method is notoriously unstable. Because the formula involves dividing by the density $f(t)$, the estimator becomes highly sensitive in the "tails" of the distribution where the density is near zero. For common distributions, such as the Gaussian, this instability results in an agonizingly slow convergence rate—specifically, the error decreases only logarithmically ($O(1/\sqrt{\log n})$) relative to the number of samples. In practical terms, achieving high precision with this method might require an unfeasibly large dataset.

The "Clipped" Estimator: A Polynomial Leap

To address the instability of the Bhattacharya estimator, this research introduces a "clipped" estimator. The core innovation lies in stabilizing the score function, defined as $\rho(t) = f'(t)/f(t)$.

In many physical systems or known noise models, it is reasonable to assume that the true score function is bounded by some known function $\bar{ ho}$. The proposed estimator leverages this by "clipping" the KDE-based score function:

  • Standard KDE: Uses $f'_n / f_n$ directly.
  • Clipped Estimator: Uses $\min(|f'_n / f_n|, |\bar{ ho}|)$.

By preventing the score function estimate from exploding in regions where the density estimate $f_n$ is small, the entire integral is stabilized. This modification transforms the convergence rate from logarithmic to polynomial ($O(n^{-u})$). This shift represents an exponential improvement in data efficiency; for example, a target error bound that might require $10^{20}$ samples for a traditional estimator can be achieved with $10^4$ to $10^5$ samples using the clipped approach.

Applications and MMSE Estimation

The utility of this improved FI estimation extends to Minimum Mean Squared Error (MMSE) estimation. By leveraging Brown’s identity, which relates Fisher information to MMSE in the presence of Gaussian noise, the authors demonstrate that their clipped FI estimator can be transformed into a consistent and efficient MMSE estimator. This has significant implications for signal processing and communication engineering, where precise MMSE values are critical for system optimization.

Validation and Results

The authors validated their theoretical findings using synthetic benchmarks, including standard Gaussian inputs and binary inputs contaminated by Gaussian noise. These benchmarks confirmed several key insights:

  1. Sample Complexity: The clipped estimator significantly reduces the sample size required to reach specific confidence intervals compared to the Bhattacharya method.
  2. Consistency: The MMSE estimators derived from the FI estimates maintained the same improved convergence patterns.
  3. Bias-Variance Trade-off: The research provides a rigorous analysis of how bandwidth parameters ($a$) and truncation parameters ($k_n$) influence the balance between precision and confidence.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the clipped estimator offers a substantial performance boost, it requires prior knowledge of an upper bound ($\bar{ ho}$) for the score function. While often available in noise-characterized systems, this bound may be difficult to determine for "black box" distributions.

Additionally, the current work focuses on scalar (1D) cases. Extending these stabilized estimators to high-dimensional multivariate distributions remains a primary challenge for future research. Furthermore, refining the theoretical bounds related to the number of zeros in the derivative of the density estimate ($d_{f_n}$) could lead to even tighter performance guarantees in the future.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper considers the problem of estimation of the Fisher information for location from a random sample of size $n$. First, an estimator proposed by Bhattacharya is revisited and improved convergence rates are derived. Second, a new estimator, termed a clipped estimator, is proposed. Superior upper bounds on the rates of convergence can be shown for the new estimator compared to the Bhattacharya estimator, albeit with different regularity conditions. Third, both of the estimators are evaluated for the practically relevant case of a random variable contaminated by Gaussian noise. Moreover, using Brown's identity, which relates the Fisher information and the minimum mean squared error (MMSE) in Gaussian noise, two corresponding consistent estimators for the MMSE are proposed. Simulation examples for the Bhattacharya estimator and the clipped estimator as well as the MMSE estimators are presented. The examples demonstrate that the clipped estimator can significantly reduce the required sample size to guarantee a specific confidence interval compared to the Bhattacharya estimator.
BibTeX
@misc{cao2020nonparametric,
  author = {Wei Cao and Alex Dytso and Michael Fauß and H. Vincent Poor and Gang Feng},
  title = {{Nonparametric Estimation of the Fisher Information and Its Applications}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2005.03622},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.03622},
}
Figure