Abstract
Understanding the biasing between the clustering properties of halos and the underlying dark matter distribution is critical for extracting cosmological information from ongoing and upcoming galaxy surveys. While on sufficiently large scales the halo overdensity is a local function of the mass density fluctuations, on smaller scales the gravitational evolution generates nonlocal terms in the halo density field. We characterize the magnitude of these contributions at third order in perturbation theory by identifying the coefficients of the nonlocal invariant operators and extend our calculation to include nonlocal (Lagrangian) terms induced by a peak constraint. We apply our results to describe the scale dependence of halo bias in cosmologies with massive neutrinos. The inclusion of gravity-induced nonlocal terms and, especially, a Lagrangian $k^2$ contribution is essential to reproduce the numerical data accurately. We use the peak-background split to derive the numerical values of the various bias coefficients from the excursion set peak mass function. For neutrino masses in the range $0 \le \sum m_{\nu} \le 0.6$ eV, we are able to fit the data with a precision of a few percent up to $k=0.3 h \text{ Mpc}^{-1}$ without any free parameters.
Introduction
In modern cosmology, galaxies and the dark matter halos they inhabit serve as the primary tracers for mapping the large-scale structure of the universe. However, these tracers are "biased"; they do not perfectly mirror the underlying dark matter distribution. Traditional models often rely on a "local bias" assumption, where the halo density at a specific point is determined solely by the matter density at that same location.
As surveys push toward smaller scales and higher precision, the local bias approximation fails. Physical processes such as gravitational evolution and the specific conditions of halo formation—which occurs at local maxima or "peaks" of the initial density field—introduce nonlocal effects. Furthermore, the presence of massive neutrinos introduces scale-dependent signatures that can be easily confused with bias effects. This paper presents a rigorous theoretical framework to account for these nonlocalities, ensuring that neutrino mass measurements remain robust and untainted by modeling inaccuracies.
Theoretical Framework
Third-Order Perturbation Theory
The authors extend the standard treatment of halo bias by solving the fluid equations for dark matter and halos up to third order. This approach identifies specific nonlocal invariant operators—mathematical terms that describe how the surrounding tidal environment and the gravitational history of a region influence the formation of halos. By moving beyond linear and quadratic terms, the model captures the complex interplay of forces that shape the cosmic web.
Peak-Background Split and Peak Theory
A central innovation of this work is the use of the Peak-Background Split (PBS) framework to derive bias coefficients. Rather than treating these coefficients as free parameters to be fitted to data, the authors derive them analytically from the mass function (the number density of halos of a given mass).
Crucially, the model incorporates a $k^2$ term in Fourier space derived from peak theory. This term accounts for the fact that halos form at local density peaks, which naturally introduces a scale-dependence in the initial (Lagrangian) conditions. This "peak constraint" is shown to be a dominant contributor to the nonlocal bias at the scales relevant for upcoming cosmological surveys.
Incorporating Massive Neutrinos
Massive neutrinos act as a distinct cosmic component that suppresses the growth of structures on small scales. The authors model this by treating neutrinos as a separate linear component while applying the nonlocal bias framework to the combined cold dark matter (CDM) and baryon field. This allows for a clear separation between the effects of neutrino physics and the effects of gravitational halo bias.
Validation against N-body Simulations
The theoretical model was tested against large-scale N-body simulations with neutrino sums ranging from $0$ to $0.6$ eV. These simulations provide a rigorous benchmark, as they explicitly track the clustering behavior of neutrinos as distinct particles.
Key findings from the comparison include:
- High Precision: The model successfully fits the halo-matter cross-power spectrum with an accuracy of $3-5\%$ up to a wavenumber of $k = 0.3 h \text{ Mpc}^{-1}$.
- Zero Free Parameters: Because the bias coefficients are derived from the Excursion Set Peak (ESP) mass function, the model achieves this fit without any "tuning" or free parameters, representing a significant victory for predictive theoretical cosmology.
- Necessity of Non-locality: The results confirm that local bias models fail at scales smaller than approximately $60$ Megaparsecs ($k \gtrsim 0.1 h \text{ Mpc}^{-1}$), where gravity-induced nonlocal terms become mandatory for an accurate description.
Discussion and Future Directions
One of the most significant implications of this work is the ability to break degeneracies between halo bias and neutrino mass. Because nonlocal bias effects exhibit a "steeper" scale dependence than the suppression caused by neutrinos, a precise theoretical model allows astronomers to distinguish between the two signals.
While the current framework is highly successful, the authors identify areas for further refinement. There is a known tension regarding how the velocity bias of halos evolves over time, which the current model treats as constant. Additionally, while the $k^2$ peak correction is effective, it may overlap with other higher-order Lagrangian terms not yet fully captured. Future research will likely extend this analysis to the three-point correlation function (bispectrum) to further validate the derived nonlocal coefficients and refine the evolution of velocity bias.
Summary updated