Nonlinear Functional Network Connectivity in Resting Fmri Data

Sara Motlaghian, Ayşenil Belger, Juan Bustillo, Judith M. Ford, Kelvin O. Lim, Daniel H. Mathalon, Bryon A. Mueller, Daniel S. OʼLeary, Godfrey D. Pearlson, Steven G. Potkin, Adrian Preda, T.g. van Erp, Vince D. CalhounbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method using normalized mutual information (MI) to quantify nonlinear relationships in brain functional networks from resting-state fMRI data. By accounting for these often-overlooked nonlinear connections, the study reveals distinct patterns of brain connectivity in schizophrenia patients compared to healthy controls, particularly in visual processing areas.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional functional connectivity (FC) analyses in neuroimaging primarily rely on linear correlation coefficients (like Pearson's r) to measure the statistical dependence between brain regions' activity over time. While useful, this approach can miss or underestimate complex, nonlinear relationships that might also be crucial for understanding brain function and dysfunction. This is analogous to trying to understand a complex system by only looking at its average behavior, ignoring the intricate, non-linear dynamics that drive it. The paper aims to fill this gap by developing and validating a method to explicitly capture these nonlinear dependencies, which could offer a more comprehensive view of brain network organization and its alterations in neurological and psychiatric conditions.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodological contribution is the use of normalized mutual information (MI) to quantify nonlinear relationships. Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Linear Dependency Removal: To isolate nonlinear effects, they first regress out the linear correlation between pairs of brain region time courses. This is done by fitting a linear model and then calculating the MI on the residuals of this model. This ensures that the MI specifically captures the dependency that remains after the linear component has been accounted for.
  • Mutual Information (MI): MI is an information-theoretic measure that quantifies the statistical dependence between two random variables. It can capture both linear and nonlinear relationships. By applying it to the residual time courses, they are specifically measuring the nonlinear component of dependence.
  • Group Independent Component Analysis (ICA): Before applying their MI-based method, the fMRI data was preprocessed and decomposed into intrinsic connectivity networks (ICNs) using group ICA. This is a standard technique for identifying spatially independent networks of brain activity. They identified 47 such networks.
  • "Boosted" Approach: In addition to focusing solely on nonlinearities, they propose a "boosted" approach that combines linear (Pearson correlation) and nonlinear (MI on residuals) information. This method aims to leverage both types of dependencies to potentially increase sensitivity to group differences, though it sacrifices the ability to disentangle linear and nonlinear effects.

Datasets

The study utilizes a publicly available resting-state fMRI dataset from the fBIRN (Function Biomedical Informatics Research Network). This dataset includes:

  • 151 individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia.
  • 163 age- and gender-matched healthy controls.

The data was collected across 7 sites in the United States. This dataset has been previously analyzed in other studies (e.g., Damaraju et al., 2014), making it a valuable benchmark for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nonlinearities are Meaningful: The study strongly suggests that nonlinear functional connectivity is not just noise but represents meaningful, modular aspects of brain organization, distinct from linear relationships.
  • Visual Cortex is Key: Nonlinear dependencies were particularly prominent in the sensory and visual cortex, and group differences in these nonlinearities were most pronounced in this region.
  • Schizophrenia and Nonlinearity: Schizophrenia patients showed altered nonlinear dependencies, especially in the visual cortex, where healthy controls generally exhibited more nonlinearity. This points to a specific disruption in how visual information is integrated nonlinearly within the brain in schizophrenia.
  • Complementary Information: Linear and nonlinear modularity patterns are different, suggesting that each provides complementary information about brain network organization. Relying solely on linear correlation misses a significant piece of the puzzle.
  • "Boosted" Approach Potential: The proposed "boosted" method shows promise in increasing sensitivity to group differences, potentially offering a more powerful tool for detecting subtle alterations in brain connectivity.

Key Results

  • Simulated Data Validation: The method successfully distinguished between purely linear, purely nonlinear, and combined linear/nonlinear relationships in simulated data, demonstrating its ability to isolate nonlinear effects.
  • Modular Nonlinearity: Analysis of the fMRI data revealed modular nonlinear relationships, particularly between visual (VIS) and somatomotor (SM) domains, and within cognitive control (CC) and default-mode (DM) domains.
  • Group Differences: Significant differences in nonlinear dependencies were observed between schizophrenia patients and healthy controls. Controls generally showed higher nonlinearity, especially in visual networks.
  • Boosted Approach Sensitivity: The boosted approach identified a substantially larger number of significant group differences (537 pairs) compared to linear correlation alone (530 pairs) and nonlinear MI alone (17 pairs), suggesting it captures a broader range of connectivity alterations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sources of Nonlinearity: The authors acknowledge that the exact sources of these nonlinearities are complex and could stem from various factors, including nonlinear hemodynamic responses, differences in blood flow/oxygenation, and even subject motion. While they curated data to minimize motion, it remains a potential confound.
  • "Boosted" Approach Trade-off: The boosted approach, while increasing sensitivity, does not allow for the separation of linear and nonlinear effects.
  • Future Directions:
    • Further investigation into the specific physiological sources of nonlinearities (e.g., using quantitative fMRI to isolate blood oxygenation, volume, and flow).
  • Exploring high-field fMRI to examine nonlinearities at different cortical layers.
  • Investigating the contribution of other physiological variables (respiration, heart rate, etc.).
  • Applying the methods to faster fMRI acquisitions and multimodal imaging (e.g., concurrent EEG).
  • Replicating findings in independent datasets.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT In this work, we focus on explicitly nonlinear relationships in functional networks. We introduce a technique using normalized mutual information (MI), that calculates the nonlinear correlation between different brain regions. We demonstrate our proposed approach using simulated data, then apply it to a dataset previously studied in (Damaraju et al., 2014). This resting-state fMRI data included 151 schizophrenia patients and 163 age- and gender-matched healthy controls. We first decomposed these data using group independent component analysis (ICA) and yielded 47 functionally relevant intrinsic connectivity networks. Our analysis showed a modularized nonlinear relationship among brain functional networks that was particularly noticeable in the sensory and visual cortex. Interestingly, the modularity appears both meaningful and distinct from that revealed by the linear approach. Group analysis identified significant differences in nonlinear dependencies between schizophrenia patients and healthy controls particularly in visual cortex, with controls showing more nonlinearity in most cases. Certain domains, including cognitive control, and default mode, appeared much less nonlinear, whereas links between the visual and other domains showed evidence of substantial nonlinear and modular properties. Overall, these results suggest that quantifying nonlinear dependencies of functional connectivity may provide a complementary and potentially important tool for studying brain function by exposing relevant variation that is typically ignored. Further, we propose a method that captures both linear and nonlinear effects in a ‘boosted’ approach. This method increases the sensitivity to group differences in comparison to the standard linear approach, at the cost of being unable to separate linear and nonlinear effects.
BibTeX
@misc{motlaghian2021nonlinear,
  author = {Sara Motlaghian and Ayşenil Belger and Juan Bustillo and Judith M. Ford and Kelvin O. Lim and Daniel H. Mathalon and Bryon A. Mueller and Daniel S. OʼLeary and Godfrey D. Pearlson and Steven G. Potkin and Adrian Preda and T.G. van Erp and Vince D. Calhoun},
  title = {{Nonlinear Functional Network Connectivity in Resting Fmri Data}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.07.20.452982},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure