Noninvasive hemoglobin sensing and imaging: optical tools for disease diagnosis

Michaela Taylor-Williams, Graham Spicer, Gemma Bale, Sarah E. BohndiekJournal of Biomedical Optics 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This review provides a comprehensive overview of noninvasive optical techniques for measuring hemoglobin oxygenation, a crucial biomarker for disease diagnosis. It highlights the diverse range of existing and emerging technologies, their strengths, limitations, and potential for clinical translation, aiming to guide researchers and clinicians in selecting appropriate tools.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diagnosing and monitoring diseases often relies on understanding how well the body's tissues are supplied with oxygen. Hemoglobin, the protein in red blood cells responsible for oxygen transport, is a key indicator of this oxygenation status. While various optical methods exist to measure hemoglobin concentration and oxygen saturation, the field is characterized by a wide variation in imaging depth, resolution, sensitivity, and cost. This makes it challenging for end-users to choose the right tool for their specific application and to understand the inherent limitations of each technique. This paper aims to systematically review and compare these methods to clarify their current capabilities and future potential.

Methods

The paper reviews a spectrum of optical techniques, broadly categorized by their operational modes:

  • Point Sensing: Primarily pulse oximetry, a widely used, low-cost method that measures arterial hemoglobin oxygen saturation at a single point. It relies on the differential absorption of light by oxygenated (HbO2) and deoxygenated (Hb) hemoglobin at specific wavelengths.
  • Superficial Imaging (up to 1-2 mm depth):
    • Spectral Reflectance Imaging (MSI and HSI): These techniques capture images at multiple wavelengths to create spectral information. They can provide spatial resolution from micrometers to millimeters and are useful for imaging superficial structures like nailfold capillaries or skin.
  • Photoacoustic Imaging (PAI): This modality uses pulsed light to generate ultrasound waves from light-absorbing chromophores like hemoglobin. It offers depth-resolved imaging and has shown promise in applications like breast cancer detection.
  • Deep Tissue Imaging (beyond 1 cm):
    • Diffuse Optical Imaging (DOI) and Spectroscopy (DOS/NIRS): These methods use near-infrared light to probe deeper tissues, often employed for brain monitoring (fNIRS) or detecting cancer. They rely on the principles of light scattering and absorption within tissue.
  • Spectroscopic Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT): While primarily known for structural imaging, OCT can be adapted for oximetry by analyzing the spectral content of backscattered light. It offers high resolution but is limited in penetration depth.

The paper also discusses the underlying principles of light-tissue interaction, including absorption and scattering, and the specific optical properties of hemoglobin and its derivatives.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in the paper. The review focuses on the methodologies and their applications rather than specific datasets used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hemoglobin as a Versatile Biomarker: The paper underscores the broad utility of hemoglobin-derived biomarkers (total hemoglobin and oxygen saturation) across a wide range of diseases, from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease to cancer and neurological disorders.
  • Trade-offs are Inherent: There's no single "best" optical technique. The choice always involves trade-offs between spatial/temporal resolution, imaging depth, signal-to-noise ratio, cost, and complexity.
  • Depth vs. Resolution: Superficial imaging techniques often achieve higher spatial resolution, while deep-tissue methods like PAI and DOI sacrifice some resolution for penetration depth.
  • The Challenge of Scattering: Light scattering in biological tissues is a fundamental challenge that limits imaging depth and can confound measurements, especially for superficial techniques.
  • Clinical Translation is Key: While many promising technologies exist in research settings, their successful integration into clinical practice requires rigorous validation, standardization, and addressing factors like cost, ease of use, and regulatory approval.
  • Emerging Trends: Miniaturization, development of wearable devices, and the integration of advanced computational methods like machine learning are paving the way for more accessible and powerful hemoglobin sensing and imaging tools.

Key Results

The paper provides a comparative overview of various techniques, highlighting their typical spatial resolutions, imaging depths, and clinical applications. For instance:

  • Pulse Oximetry: Single-point measurement, widely used in healthcare settings, but known to suffer from racial bias.
  • Spectral Reflectance Imaging: Can achieve high spatial resolution (micrometers) for superficial imaging, with applications in endoscopy and skin imaging.
  • Photoacoustic Imaging (PAI): Capable of depth-resolved imaging (up to several centimeters) and has shown success in clinical trials for breast cancer detection.
  • Diffuse Optical Imaging (DOI): Offers deeper penetration (up to several centimeters) and is being explored for brain and breast imaging.
  • Spectroscopic OCT: Provides high resolution but is limited to shallow depths (1-2 mm).

The paper emphasizes that while many techniques are established for specific applications (e.g., pulse oximetry, structural OCT), others are still in earlier stages of development or clinical trials.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations across the discussed techniques:

  • Depth Limitation: Many techniques, particularly reflectance-based methods and OCT, are limited to superficial imaging.
  • Scattering and Attenuation: Light scattering and absorption within tissues limit imaging depth and can introduce artifacts.
  • Quantification Challenges: Accurate quantification of hemoglobin biomarkers can be affected by tissue heterogeneity, instrument calibration, and the presence of other chromophores.
  • Motion Artifacts: Techniques relying on scanning can be susceptible to motion artifacts, impacting image quality and data reliability.
  • Cost and Complexity: Advanced imaging systems can be expensive and require specialized training for operation and data interpretation.
  • Clinical Evidence: For some emerging techniques, there is a need for larger-scale clinical trials to establish their sensitivity, specificity, and diagnostic power.

Future work is suggested in several areas:

  • Advancing Depth-Resolved Imaging: Further development of PAI, DOI, and OCT to improve penetration depth and resolution.
  • Improving Accuracy and Reducing Bias: Addressing limitations like racial bias in pulse oximetry and developing more robust calibration methods.
  • Integration and Miniaturization: Developing more compact, user-friendly, and cost-effective devices, including wearable technologies for home monitoring.
  • Multimodal Approaches: Combining different optical techniques or integrating them with other imaging modalities (e.g., MRI, ultrasound) to leverage complementary strengths.
  • Machine Learning and AI: Utilizing advanced computational tools for more accurate data analysis, interpretation, and real-time processing.
  • Standardization and Validation: Establishing standardized protocols for data acquisition, processing, and clinical validation to facilitate widespread adoption.

Summary updated

Abstract

We highlight key limitations in the current state-of-the-art and make suggestions for routes to advance the clinical use and interpretation of hemoglobin oxygenation information.
BibTeX
@article{taylorwilliams2022noninvasive,
  author = {Michaela Taylor-Williams and Graham Spicer and Gemma Bale and Sarah E. Bohndiek},
  title = {{Noninvasive hemoglobin sensing and imaging: optical tools for disease diagnosis}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomedical Optics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jbo.27.8.080901},
}
Figure