Nondestructive Evaluation of Historic Hakka Rammed Earth Structures

Ruifeng Liang, Gangarao Hota, Lei Ying, Yanhao Li, Daniel Stanislawski, Jiang Yong-qiangSustainability 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the structural integrity and thermal performance of historic Hakka rammed earth buildings (Tulou) in China using nondestructive evaluation (NDE) techniques. The findings demonstrate the structural soundness of these ancient structures and highlight their remarkable thermal comfort, achieved through the inherent properties of rammed earth, offering valuable insights for sustainable modern construction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Historic rammed earth structures, like the Hakka Tulou, are recognized for their cultural and artistic significance, but their engineering values, particularly concerning sustainability, durability, and comfortable living with low energy consumption, are often underestimated. While these structures have stood for centuries, a comprehensive understanding of their material and structural performance under various loads and environmental conditions is needed. This paper aims to address this gap by employing nondestructive evaluation (NDE) methods to assess the integrity of the rammed earth walls and internal wooden structures, and to analyze their thermal comfort properties.

Methods

The research employed a multi-faceted approach combining field NDE, laboratory testing, and finite element modeling.

  • Nondestructive Evaluation (NDE):
    • Ultrasonic Testing: Used to assess the strength and detect defects in the rammed earth walls by measuring wave velocity and amplitude.
  • Rebound Hammer Method: Employed to quantitatively evaluate the strength of the rammed earth walls, using two types of hammers (HT-75 for brick-like materials and HT-20 for mortar-like materials).
  • Infrared Thermography (IRT) Scanning: Utilized to detect subsurface delaminations and debonding, and to investigate the presence of wall ribs and their bonding with the earth.
  • Full-Scale Load Testing:
    • Floor System Testing: Involved applying loads to floor beams and measuring strain using strain gages to understand load distribution.
  • Roof Truss System Testing: Similar to floor testing, strain was measured on roof truss members under applied loads.
  • Laboratory Testing: Field-collected samples were tested (though detailed results are presented in a companion paper).
  • Finite Element (FE) Modeling: Used to simulate structural responses and compare with experimental data.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from five in-service Hakka Tulou buildings in Fujian Province, China. Specific data points included:

  • Temperature and humidity readings from various locations within and outside the Chengqi Tulou.
  • Strain data from load tests on floor and roof truss systems.
  • NDE measurements (ultrasonic velocity/amplitude, rebound hammer readings) from multiple Tulou structures.
  • Radiocarbon dating of a wooden sample from Chengqi Tulou to verify its age.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing structures served as the experimental platform.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structural Resilience of Ancient Design: The Hakka Tulou, despite their age (some over 1,200 years old), exhibit remarkable structural soundness in their floor and roof truss systems, as evidenced by the load testing. The jointed nature of the wooden members contributes to a significant load-sharing effect, acting similarly to a fixed beam.
  • Effective Thermal Mass Utilization: The rammed earth walls provide excellent thermal mass, naturally regulating interior temperatures and humidity. This allows for comfortable living conditions year-round without the need for mechanical heating or cooling, demonstrating a highly sustainable approach to building design.
  • NDE Suitability for Rammed Earth: While NDE techniques like ultrasonic testing and rebound hammers show promise for assessing rammed earth structures, their effectiveness can vary. The study suggests that the HT-75 rebound hammer is more suitable for rammed earth due to its brick-like nature. Infrared thermography, however, was found to be less sensitive for detecting subtle features like wall ribs embedded deep within thick walls.
  • Understanding of Structural Principles: The design of the roof truss, with intermittent vertical members intercepting horizontal ones, demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of force distribution by the Hakka people, akin to modern truss designs.

Key Results

  • Structural Soundness: Load tests on the floor and roof truss systems showed small strains, indicating that these components are structurally sound, even in buildings over 300 years old. The maximum strain observed in the floor test was 32 microstrains, and in the roof test was 70 microstrains, under a 250 kg load.
  • Thermal Performance: The rammed earth walls demonstrated a thermal resistivity of 1.0986 m.K/W, resulting in an R-value of 1.96 m².K/W for the 1.8m thick walls. This is significantly higher than reported average values for rammed earth and contributes to stable interior temperatures. For example, on a hot summer day, the outer wall reached 112°F, while the interior room remained around 79.5°F. Humidity inside the rooms remained consistently around 79%, despite external fluctuations.
  • NDE Correlations: Ultrasonic testing indicated that Zhencheng earth walls were stronger than Wuyun, which agreed with laboratory compression tests. Rebound hammer results showed that the HT-75 readings correlated better with compression strength than HT-20.
  • IRT Limitations: Infrared thermography was not sensitive enough to detect wall ribs or the bond between earth and ribs due to the thickness of the walls and the thermal equilibrium of the materials.

Limitations and Future Work

  • NDE Calibration: The authors acknowledge that a specific calibration chart for ultrasonic devices and rebound hammers for rammed earth walls needs to be developed to derive more precise strength values from NDE tests.
  • IRT Sensitivity: The limited sensitivity of IRT for detecting subsurface features in thick rammed earth walls was a significant limitation. Future work could explore more advanced IRT techniques or complementary methods for such applications.
  • Data Interpretation: While NDE provided trends, direct comparison with experimentally determined strength data is crucial for further refinement.
  • Companion Paper: This paper focuses on NDE and structural testing. A second paper delves into material characterization and earthquake response analysis using finite element modeling, providing a more complete picture.
  • Modern Application: The study suggests that modern construction can learn from Hakka building techniques, making rammed earth a viable material option for the future, emphasizing its sustainability and thermal comfort benefits.

Summary updated

Abstract

The in-service Hakka rammed earth buildings, in the Fujian Province of China, are unique in design and performance. Their UNESCO’s inscription as World Heritage sites recognizes their artistic, cultural, social and historic significance. Sponsored by the National Science Foundation of the United States, the authors have examined the engineering values of these buildings in terms of comfortable living at low energy consumption, sustainability and durability. The objective of this study was to better understand the thermo-mechanical and aging responses of Hakka earth buildings under thermal and earthquake loads through nondestructive field evaluation, including full-scale roof truss and floor testing, laboratory testing of field samples and finite element modeling. This paper presents our observations and findings from the field nondestructive evaluations with emphasis on the integrity of the rammed earth outer walls and inner wood structures, as well as the thermal comfort of living in these buildings, while a second paper presents the results from the material characterization of field samples and the structural responses of a representative building under earthquake induced loads through finite element analysis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liang2013nondestructive,
  author = {Ruifeng Liang and Gangarao Hota and Lei Ying and Yanhao Li and Daniel Stanislawski and Jiang Yong-qiang},
  title = {{Nondestructive Evaluation of Historic Hakka Rammed Earth Structures}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3390/su5010298},
}
Figure