Nonclassical growth of immiscible high-entropy materials

Zhaosheng Li, Yuanming Zhang, Yang Li, Xiaoming Xu, Yong Chen, Zhonghua Li, Xuexi Yan, Zhigang Zou, Cheng‐Wei Qiu, Ghim Wei HoResearch Square 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have pioneered a "nonclassical" growth strategy that uses metastable, high-surface-energy substrates to force "immiscible" metals to mix into stable high-entropy materials. By leveraging active learning and "thermosensitive superstructures," they produced high-entropy single atoms and 2D metallenes that remain stable at temperatures exceeding 1200 K.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-entropy alloys (HEAs) are prized for their unique properties, but they are notoriously difficult to synthesize when the constituent elements are "immiscible"—meaning they naturally prefer to stay separated rather than blend. Traditionally, creating these materials requires extreme temperatures to overcome high enthalpy barriers.

Classic growth models dictate strict rules: for a solid solution to form, the atomic radius difference should be less than 6.6% and the mixing enthalpy should be below 3.2 kJ/mol. When you try to mix elements like Zinc (Zn) and Tungsten (W), which have a mixing enthalpy of ~15 kJ/mol, they simply won't cooperate under standard conditions. This paper tackles the "miscibility obstacle," seeking a way to achieve controlled, atomic-level mixing of diverse elements under milder conditions.

Methods

The authors developed a nonclassical growth route that shifts the focus from direct 3D stacking to in-plane atomic attachment.

  1. Thermosensitive Superstructure (TSS) Substrates: The team used metastable substrates (like $\beta$-Fe$_2$O$_3$ or $C_3N_4$) characterized by high surface energy and "short-range order." These substrates act as a confined template that "atomizes" metal precursors.
  2. Active Learning Networks (ALN): To navigate the massive number of possible element combinations, the researchers used ALNs to uncover scaling relationships between electronegativity and mixing enthalpy.
  3. Advanced Characterization: They employed aberration-corrected HAADF-STEM to visualize individual atoms and X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS) to confirm that the metals were truly dispersed at the atomic level rather than forming clusters.
  4. Simulations: Ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) and Density Functional Theory (DFT) were used to model the structural distortions and energy barriers that enable this unique growth process.

Datasets

  • Meta-analysis Dataset: A comprehensive dataset of 28 metallic elements from the s-, d-, ds-, and p-blocks was used to establish scaling relations.
  • Isomeric Material Survey: The researchers screened 52 different isomeric materials (including oxides like $TiO_2$ and $MoS_2$) to identify the best candidates for TSS substrates based on their formation energy and space groups.
  • Active Learning Calculations: Thousands of scale-active learning calculations were performed to confirm adsorbate-substrate interactions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Reverse Volcano" Trend: The ALN revealed a previously unrecognized reverse volcanic relationship between electronegativity difference ($\Delta\chi_{AB}$) and mixing enthalpy ($\Delta H_{mix}$). This insight helps predict which element combinations can be successfully "forced" into a high-entropy state.
  • Metastable is Key: Unlike stable crystalline substrates, metastable TSS substrates have "unsaturated bonds" and high surface energy. This suppresses classical nucleation (which leads to clumping) and instead promotes spinodal decomposition—a process where the solution spontaneously separates into distinct phases at the atomic scale, leading to ordered in-plane attachment.
  • Oscillatory Growth: The growth doesn't happen in a straight line; it follows an oscillatory pattern, evolving from short-range to medium-range order. This reduces the binding energy of surface atoms, preventing them from collapsing into a disordered state.

Key Results

  • Ultra-High Stability: They synthesized High-Entropy Single Atoms (HESA) with an anti-sintering temperature exceeding 1200 K, a remarkable feat for single-atom catalysts which usually clump together (sinter) at much lower temperatures.
  • High Metal Loading: The TSS substrates achieved metal contents above 20 wt%, significantly higher than many existing single-atom dispersion reports.
  • High-Entropy Metallenes (HEMs): The team successfully created substrate-free 2D "metallenes" containing extremely immiscible elements.
  • Performance: The resulting materials showed exceptional performance in the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) across both acidic and alkaline media.

Limitations and Future Work

While the paper demonstrates a "general" route, the authors note that the selection of the appropriate TSS substrate is imperative and complex. There is a strong demand for even more "intelligent and easily transferable" functional substrates to scale this process.

Future work will likely focus on expanding the library of High-Entropy Metallenes (HEMs) and exploring their specific electronic properties for use in flexible electronics, 3D printing, and advanced nanodevices. The authors anticipate that this "nonclassical" framework will open a new frontier in materials science, allowing researchers to design materials with element combinations previously thought impossible.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> The thermodynamic instability of phase separation in multi-metal crystal growth has been a long-standing challenge. Therefore, overcoming miscibility obstacle due to high lattice symmetry without extremely high temperatures has been elusive. Here, we developed a general nonclassical growth route to address metal miscibility under mild conditions, which was ascribed to in-plane atomic attachment due to the supersaturated confinement effect of the thermosensitive superstructure (TSS) substrate, a metastable intermediate. The structure exhibits an oscillatory growth pattern and evolves from short-range order to medium-range order, allowing significant reduction in the binding energy of surface heteroatoms. This prevents individual atoms from collapsing into a disordered state under the heat generated upon binding. We confirmed adsorbate-substrate interactions via an inverted volcano trend scaling relationship from 28 metals based on thousands of scale active learning calculations. As a proof of principle, we synthesized both high-entropy single atoms with anti-sintering temperatures exceeding 1200 K and highly-conductive high-entropy metallenes sheathing extremely immiscible elements. These revelations forge a new frontier for high-entropy materials, holding profound implications for interdisciplinary scientific progresses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025nonclassical,
  author = {Zhaosheng Li and Yuanming Zhang and Yang Li and Xiaoming Xu and Yong Chen and Zhonghua Li and Xuexi Yan and Zhigang Zou and Cheng‐Wei Qiu and Ghim Wei Ho},
  title = {{Nonclassical growth of immiscible high-entropy materials}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4581938/v1},
}
Figure