Non-destructive testing of interfacial stiffness based on spring model for diffusion bonding interface of titanium alloy components with complex surface

Gongpeng Yang, Zhenggan Zhou, Tengfei Ma, Lichen Teng, Jun Wang, Yuxuan Zhou, Yang Li, Wenbin ZhouScientific 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a more sensitive way to inspect the "invisible" joints in high-performance aerospace components. By modeling the diffusion bonding interface as a series of microscopic springs and measuring "interfacial stiffness" rather than just echo strength, they can detect tiny defects on complex, curved titanium surfaces that traditional ultrasonic testing often misses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diffusion bonding is a "solid-state" welding technique used to join titanium alloys in critical aerospace parts, like aero-engine blades. It creates a near-seamless joint, but if the process isn't perfect, it leaves behind microscopic pores or "lack of bonding" areas.

Detecting these defects is a nightmare for two reasons. First, the defects are often smaller than the wavelength of the ultrasound used to find them, leading to incredibly weak signals. Second, these parts often have complex, curved surfaces. When an ultrasonic wave hits a curved or tilted surface, the signal scatters and distorts, making it nearly impossible to distinguish a real defect from geometric noise.

Methods

The authors moved beyond standard ultrasonic C-scans (which look at the amplitude of reflected sound) and instead focused on the phase of the signal to calculate interfacial stiffness ($\kappa$).

  1. The Spring Model: They treated the bonding interface as a thin elastic layer represented by discrete springs. By measuring the "true phase" of the ultrasonic echo, they could calculate the stiffness of these "springs." A high stiffness indicates a healthy bond; low stiffness indicates defects.
  2. Finite Element (FE) Modeling: Using COMSOL, the team simulated how ultrasonic waves interact with micron-scale pores. This allowed them to optimize the testing frequency—finding that 15 MHz provides the best balance between sensitivity to tiny voids and immunity to "grain noise" from the titanium itself.
  3. Robotic Laser Profiling: To handle complex geometries, they integrated a linear laser profile scanner onto a six-axis robot arm. The laser maps the surface first, allowing the robot to precisely orient the ultrasonic transducer perpendicular to the curved surface during the scan.

Datasets

The study evaluated the method using three primary targets:

  • Specimen #1: A titanium plate with "large" artificial defects (flat-bottom holes, 1–4 mm diameter).
  • Specimen #2: A titanium plate with "micro-voids" created via femtosecond laser ablation (simulating defects just 3–5 $\mu$m in size).
  • Complex Component: A real-world titanium alloy component with a non-linear surface to test the robotic scanning and phase-calculation limits.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phase over Amplitude: Traditional testing relies on how "loud" the echo is. This paper shows that the timing (phase) of the echo is a much more reliable indicator of bond quality when defects are smaller than the ultrasonic wavelength.
  • The 15 MHz "Sweet Spot": While higher frequencies (20–25 MHz) are theoretically more sensitive, they are easily drowned out by noise from the metal's grain structure. 15 MHz was identified as the optimal frequency for reliable phase calculation in titanium.
  • Geometric Limits: The researchers quantified exactly how much "tilt" the system can handle. They found the phase-based stiffness calculation remains accurate as long as the interface inclination angle is less than 14°.

Key Results

  • Higher Sensitivity: The interfacial stiffness maps ($\kappa$ C-scans) clearly identified micro-defects in Specimen #2 that were nearly invisible or highly ambiguous in standard amplitude-based scans.
  • Validation: Microscopic metallography (cutting the samples open) confirmed that the "suspected" defects found by the ultrasound were indeed real voids measuring only 3–5 $\mu$m.
  • Robustness: The system successfully mapped defects on a complex-surface component, proving that integrating laser profiling with the spring model can overcome the geometric challenges of aerospace NDT.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary drawback of this high-sensitivity approach is its vulnerability to noise. Because the calculation depends on precise phase measurements, electrical interference or extreme grain noise can cause "false detections" or distort the perceived size of a defect.

The authors note that future work should focus on advanced denoising algorithms to clean up the signals before the stiffness calculation. Additionally, while the 14° limit is a significant step forward, expanding the method to handle even steeper angles would be necessary for more extreme component geometries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ultrasonic testing is an important non-destructive testing method, which is sensitive to the defects in the diffusion bonding interface. Ultrasonic testing of diffusion bonding interfaces in complex-surface components is a challenge due to the geometry and the weak echo signal of the diffusion bonding defects. This paper proposes an interfacial stiffness characterization method based on the spring model for the ultrasonic testing of the diffusion bonding interface of titanium alloy complex-surface component. Finite element models for ultrasonic field are established to analyze the diffusion bonding defects response, the effect of complex surface, and the inconsistency of the bonding interface depth in ultrasonic testing of the titanium alloy complex-surface component. 15 MHz is recommended as the testing frequency of the diffusion bonding interface. Ultrasonic C-scan experiments are conducted using specimens with embedded artificial defects and a titanium alloy complex-surface component. The simulation and experimental results show that the novel interfacial stiffness characterization method can be applied to ultrasonic testing of the diffusion bonding interface (inclination angle less than 14°) in complex-surface components, and the ability to test defects at the diffusion bonding interface can be improved.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2023non,
  author = {Gongpeng Yang and Zhenggan Zhou and Tengfei Ma and Lichen Teng and Jun Wang and Yuxuan Zhou and Yang Li and Wenbin Zhou},
  title = {{Non-destructive testing of interfacial stiffness based on spring model for diffusion bonding interface of titanium alloy components with complex surface}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-42887-4},
}
Figure