Non-Destructive Testing of Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Plastics (CFRPs) Using a Resonant Eddy Current Sensor

Ming Ma, Shiyu Liu, Ronghua Zhang, Qiong Zhang, Yi Wu, Bailiang Chen2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel resonant eddy current sensor based on an LC resonator and an inductance-to-digital converter (LDC) for non-destructive testing (NDT) of Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Plastics (CFRPs). The proposed sensor offers improved signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), enhanced detection sensitivity, and better anti-interference capabilities compared to traditional eddy current probes, making it suitable for detecting defects in CFRPs even in the presence of highly conductive materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Non-destructive testing (NDT) of Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Plastics (CFRPs) is crucial for ensuring the structural integrity of components in industries like aerospace and automotive. Traditional eddy current testing (ECT) methods, while effective for metallic materials, face challenges when applied to CFRPs due to their significantly lower conductivity and anisotropic nature. Increasing operating frequencies or modifying coil structures are common approaches to enhance CFRP testing, but these can lead to complex circuitry and miniaturization issues. Furthermore, existing ECT techniques often rely on expensive impedance analyzers, hindering the development of portable and cost-effective solutions. This paper aims to address these limitations by proposing a miniaturized, high-sensitivity, and robust resonant eddy current sensor specifically designed for CFRP defect detection.

Methods

The core of the proposed sensor is an LC resonator, formed by an inductor and a capacitor, coupled with an inductance-to-digital converter (LDC). The LDC is used to easily detect the resonant frequency shift of the LC resonator, which is indicative of changes in the material under test. This approach allows for operation at a frequency significantly lower than the coil's self-resonant frequency (SRF), minimizing background noise and improving stability.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • LC Resonator Design: A double-layer planar coil with a spacer was designed to achieve a higher SRF and better performance at higher operating frequencies compared to conventional hollow coils. This design also enhances mechanical stability and reduces the need for external wiring.
  • Inductance-to-Digital Converter (LDC): The LDC1612 from Texas Instruments was employed for its low cost, low power consumption, and reliable frequency signal measurement capabilities.
  • Experimental Setup: A multi-axis mobile platform was used to precisely control the probe's position relative to the specimen. The system comprises the LC resonator working board, the platform, a personal computer (PC) for control and data acquisition, and the CFRP and aluminum specimens.
  • Comparative Analysis: The performance of the proposed LC resonator was compared against conventional concentric and side-by-side transmit-receive (T-R) probes. This comparison involved linear scanning experiments on aluminum plates with defects under various scanning angles.
  • CFRP Defect Detection: Experiments were conducted on CFRP samples with artificially created defects, both with and without the interference of underlying aluminum plates, to evaluate the sensor's anti-interference capabilities and defect detection performance.
  • Simulation: Finite element method (FEM) simulations were used to validate the coil design and to investigate the sensor's response to defects of varying depths.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention the use of pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it focuses on experimental data collected from manufactured specimens.

  • Aluminum Specimens: An aluminum plate with a rectangular defect was used for comparative studies with traditional probes.
  • CFRP Specimens: Two types of CFRP samples (CFRP1 and CFRP2) with artificially created defects were used to evaluate the sensor's performance in detecting defects and its anti-interference capabilities, especially when placed over aluminum plates of varying thicknesses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LC Resonator for CFRP NDT: The fundamental insight is that an LC resonator, when coupled with an LDC, can effectively serve as a sensitive and miniaturized sensor for detecting defects in CFRPs, overcoming some limitations of traditional ECT.
  • Lower Operating Frequency Advantage: Operating the LC resonator at a frequency significantly lower than the coil's SRF is crucial for minimizing background noise and achieving stable measurements, especially in the presence of interference.
  • Double-Layer Planar Coil Design: This specific coil geometry offers a higher SRF and improved performance compared to traditional coils, enabling higher operating frequencies and better detection sensitivity.
  • Anti-Interference Capability: The sensor demonstrates remarkable resilience to interference from highly conductive materials like aluminum plates, allowing for defect detection in CFRPs even when they are placed on top of aluminum. This suggests the magnetic field can penetrate effectively.
  • Independence from Scanning Angle: Unlike some traditional probes, the LC resonator's performance (specifically SNR) is largely unaffected by the scanning angle, simplifying its application in real-world scenarios.

Key Results

  • Improved SNR: The LC resonator consistently achieved a higher SNR (exceeding 15 dB) compared to conventional concentric and side-by-side T-R probes across all scanning angles on aluminum defects.
  • Accurate Defect Width Estimation: The sensor demonstrated the ability to accurately estimate defect width, with the Full-Width Half-Maximum (FWHM) measurement closely matching the actual defect width for the LC resonator, particularly at a 90° scanning angle.
  • Defect Detection in CFRP: The LC resonator successfully detected defects in CFRP samples, even at a lift-off spacing of 7 mm, and in the presence of aluminum plates.
  • Influence of Aluminum Interference: When aluminum is placed beneath CFRP, the resonance frequency of the LC resonator increases. This effect diminishes as the aluminum thickness increases, and for CFRP2, the reduction in signal difference due to aluminum interference was less pronounced than for CFRP1, attributed to CFRP's anisotropic conductivity.
  • Lift-off Sensitivity: The resonant frequency increases with lift-off spacing and then becomes relatively insensitive. For lift-off less than 3 mm, the sensor becomes more sensitive to interference from other conductive materials.
  • Depth Sensitivity: Simulations indicated that the inductance of the coil increases with defect depth, while the resonant frequency decreases, suggesting potential for depth estimation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lift-off Sensitivity at Short Distances: The paper notes that at lift-off heights less than 3 mm, the LC resonator becomes highly sensitive to interference from other conductive materials. This suggests a trade-off between sensitivity and anti-interference at very close proximity.
  • CFRP Anisotropy: The anisotropic nature of CFRP leads to variations in local conductivity, which can affect the uniformity of scanning signals and make defect characterization more complex.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the proposed method can be used to detect defects of any thickness due to the probe's energy penetration capabilities. Further research could focus on optimizing the sensor for more precise depth measurement and exploring its application in more complex CFRP structures and under more challenging environmental conditions. The potential for further miniaturization and integration into portable NDT devices is also implied.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{ma2024non,
  author = {Ming Ma and Shiyu Liu and Ronghua Zhang and Qiong Zhang and Yi Wu and Bailiang Chen},
  title = {{Non-Destructive Testing of Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Plastics (CFRPs) Using a Resonant Eddy Current Sensor}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24113449},
}

Loading related content...

Figure