Non-Canonical Odor Coding in the Mosquito

Meg A. Younger, Margaret Herre, Olivia V. Goldman, Tzu‐Chiao Lu, Gabriela Caballero-Vidal, Yanyan Qi, Zachary N. Gilbert, Zhongyan Gong, Takeshi Morita, Saher Rahiel, Majid Ghaninia, Rickard Ignell, Benjamin J. Matthews, Hongjie Li, Leslie B. VosshallbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Mosquitoes, particularly the disease-carrying Aedes aegypti, are remarkably adept at finding humans, despite genetic disruptions to their olfactory systems. This paper reveals that mosquitoes don't follow the "one receptor, one neuron" rule like many other animals. Instead, individual mosquito olfactory neurons co-express multiple odorant receptors, creating a highly redundant and robust system for detecting human scent.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the prevailing model for olfactory coding in insects, including mosquitoes, has been the "one receptor, one neuron, one glomerulus" principle. This means a single olfactory sensory neuron expresses a single type of odorant receptor, and its axon projects to a specific glomerulus (a spherical structure in the antennal lobe of the brain). This setup allows for a combinatorial code where different combinations of activated glomeruli signal different odors. However, this model has been challenged by observations in mosquitoes like Aedes aegypti. Despite having a large number of odorant receptor genes, they have a relatively small number of antennal lobe glomeruli. Furthermore, genetic mutations that disrupt specific olfactory receptors have surprisingly modest effects on a mosquito's ability to find humans, suggesting significant redundancy or an alternative coding strategy. This paper investigates this discrepancy, aiming to understand the true organizational principle of the mosquito olfactory system and how it achieves its impressive host-seeking ability.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • CRISPR-Cas9 Gene Editing: They used this powerful tool to create knock-in mosquito strains. This allowed them to specifically label neurons expressing certain co-receptors (like Orco, Ir25a, Ir8a, Ir76b, and Gr3) with fluorescent reporters (GFP or dTomato).
  • Immunostaining: Antibodies were used to visualize the presence and location of specific proteins (like endogenous Orco and Ir25a) within the mosquito's olfactory organs and brain.
  • RNA in situ Hybridization: This technique allowed them to visualize the expression patterns of specific chemosensory receptor genes within the antennae.
  • Single Nucleus RNA Sequencing (snRNA-seq): This cutting-edge technique enabled them to profile the gene expression of individual nuclei from antennae and maxillary palps, providing a high-resolution view of receptor co-expression at the single-cell level.
  • In vivo Electrophysiology: Single sensillum recordings were performed on maxillary palp neurons to measure their responses to various odorants and to test the functional consequences of receptor co-expression and mutations.
  • Confocal Microscopy: High-resolution imaging was used to visualize the fluorescently labeled neurons and their projections in the antennal lobe and other brain regions.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available genomic and transcriptomic data for Aedes aegypti. Specifically, they referenced the Aedes aegypti L5 genome and previously published transcriptome data for expression estimates. The snRNA-seq data generated in this study, from both antennae and maxillary palps, represents a new dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond the "One-to-One" Rule: The most significant insight is that Aedes aegypti olfactory sensory neurons frequently co-express multiple chemosensory receptor genes, not just from the same family (ORs, IRs, GRs), but also across different families. This directly challenges the long-held "one receptor, one neuron" paradigm.
  • Redundancy as Robustness: This co-expression creates a highly redundant system. A single neuron can respond to a broader range of odorants, and if one receptor is lost or its ligand is absent, others can compensate. This likely explains the mosquito's persistent ability to find humans even with genetic disruptions.
  • Maxillary Palp Complexity: The maxillary palp, previously thought to have a simpler organization, also exhibits surprising complexity in receptor co-expression, suggesting it plays a more sophisticated role in odor detection than previously understood.
  • Functional Implications: Electrophysiology confirmed that this co-expression is not just genetic but functional, allowing neurons to respond to diverse odorants and demonstrating that both OR and IR pathways are required within the same neuron for certain odor detections.

Key Results

  • Widespread Co-expression: Nearly half of antennal lobe glomeruli receive input from neurons co-expressing Orco and Ir25a. snRNA-seq revealed extensive co-expression of multiple OR and IR genes within individual antennal neurons.
  • Mismatch Explained: The mismatch between the large number of chemosensory receptor genes and the limited number of antennal lobe glomeruli is largely resolved by this widespread co-expression.
  • Functional Co-dependence: In maxillary palp neurons, mutating either the OR co-receptor (Orco) or the IR co-receptor (Ir25a) impaired responses to certain odorants, indicating that both receptor families are necessary for detecting specific ligands within the same neuron.
  • Maxillary Palp Neuron Subtypes: snRNA-seq data revealed that maxillary palp neurons, previously thought to be simple A, B, and C cells, are far more diverse, with many co-expressing multiple receptor subunits.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Functional Significance of Combinations: While co-expression is demonstrated, the precise functional significance of every receptor combination and how these combinations contribute to specific odor perception and behavioral decisions requires further investigation.
  • Co-convergence: The study primarily focused on co-expression within neurons. The possibility of co-convergence (multiple neurons projecting to the same glomerulus) was not definitively ruled out and remains an area for future research.
  • Regulatory Mechanisms: The molecular mechanisms governing this extensive co-expression are not fully understood and represent a significant area for future study, potentially involving complex transcriptional regulation.
  • Behavioral Validation: While electrophysiology provides functional insights, directly linking these complex olfactory codes to specific behaviors in response to human odor cues would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

SUMMARY Female Aedes aegypti mosquitoes are a persistent human foe, transmitting arboviruses including dengue and yellow fever when they bite us to obtain a blood meal. Mosquitoes are intensely attracted to human-emitted body odor, heat, and carbon dioxide, which they detect using three different large multi-gene families encoding odor-gated ion channels. Genetic mutations that cause profound disruptions to the olfactory system have modest effects on human attraction, suggesting significant redundancy in odor coding. The canonical view is that olfactory sensory neurons each express a single chemosensory receptor that defines its ligand selectivity. Using immunostaining, RNA in situ hybridization, and single nucleus RNA sequencing, we discovered that Aedes aegypti uses an entirely different organizational principle, with many neurons co-expressing multiple chemosensory receptor genes. In vivo electrophysiology demonstrates that the broad ligand-sensitivity of mosquito olfactory neurons is due to this non-canonical co-expression. The redundancy afforded by an olfactory system in which many neurons co-express multiple receptors with different chemical sensitivity may greatly increase the robustness of the mosquito olfactory system and explain our longstanding inability to engineer new compounds that disrupt the detection of human body odor by mosquitoes.
BibTeX
@misc{younger2020non,
  author = {Meg A. Younger and Margaret Herre and Olivia V. Goldman and Tzu‐Chiao Lu and Gabriela Caballero-Vidal and Yanyan Qi and Zachary N. Gilbert and Zhongyan Gong and Takeshi Morita and Saher Rahiel and Majid Ghaninia and Rickard Ignell and Benjamin J. Matthews and Hongjie Li and Leslie B. Vosshall},
  title = {{Non-Canonical Odor Coding in the Mosquito}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.11.07.368720},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure