Noisy $\ell^{0}$-Sparse Subspace Clustering on Dimensionality Reduced Data

Yingzhen Yang, Ping LiUAI 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces "noisy $\ell^0$-SSC," a novel approach to subspace clustering that provides theoretical guarantees for handling noisy data, a significant limitation of previous $\ell^0$-norm based methods. To address computational cost, they also propose "Noisy-DR-$\ell^0$-SSC," which uses dimensionality reduction via random projection, demonstrating improved efficiency and effectiveness in experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-dimensional data, like images or gene expression data, often lies in low-dimensional subspaces. Subspace clustering aims to group data points based on these underlying subspace structures. While $\ell^0$-norm based sparse subspace clustering ($\ell^0$-SSC) has shown superior performance over $\ell^1$-norm based methods (like standard SSC) by encouraging sparser representations, its theoretical guarantees have been limited to clean data that perfectly lie within these subspaces. Real-world data, however, is almost always corrupted by noise, meaning data points might be close to, but not exactly on, the subspaces. This paper tackles the crucial problem of extending the theoretical understanding and practical application of $\ell^0$-SSC to noisy data, ensuring its robustness and correctness in realistic scenarios.

Methods

The core contribution is the theoretical analysis of noisy $\ell^0$-SSC. The authors prove that under both deterministic and semi-random models, an optimal solution to the noisy $\ell^0$-SSC optimization problem achieves the Subspace Detection Property (SDP). SDP is a critical property that ensures data points from different subspaces are correctly separated in the learned similarity matrix. This theoretical guarantee on noisy data is a significant advancement.

To improve computational efficiency, they introduce Noisy-DR-$\ell^0$-SSC. This method first reduces the dimensionality of the data using random projection (specifically, randomized low-rank approximation and count-sketch projections) and then applies the noisy $\ell^0$-SSC algorithm to the compressed data. This approach aims to preserve the essential subspace structure while significantly speeding up computation.

Datasets

The paper evaluates the proposed methods on several standard datasets:

  • COIL-20
  • COIL-100
  • Yale-B
  • MPIE S1, S2, S3, S4
  • MNIST

The experiments also involve artificially adding Gaussian noise to the extended Yale-B dataset to test the robustness of the methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Theoretical Guarantee for Noisy Data: The most significant insight is providing the first theoretical guarantee for $\ell^0$-SSC on noisy data, specifically through the Subspace Detection Property (SDP). This bridges a critical gap between theoretical models and real-world applicability.
  • Advantage of $\ell^0$-Norm: The analysis reveals that noisy $\ell^0$-SSC requires less restrictive conditions on subspace affinity compared to $\ell^1$-based methods, especially when dealing with overlapping subspaces or when subspace dimensions are large. This highlights the inherent advantage of $\ell^0$-norm for subspace clustering.
  • Dimensionality Reduction for Efficiency: The proposal of Noisy-DR-$\ell^0$-SSC demonstrates that dimensionality reduction via random projection can be effectively combined with $\ell^0$-SSC without sacrificing theoretical guarantees, leading to substantial speedups.
  • Role of Regularization Parameter ($\lambda$): Empirical results suggest that a larger regularization parameter $\lambda$ in the $\ell^0$-SSC objective function helps ensure the subspace detection property, aligning with theoretical findings.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides theoretical guarantees for the correctness of noisy $\ell^0$-SSC under both deterministic and semi-random models, establishing SDP for noisy data.
  • Improved Subspace Affinity Conditions: Noisy $\ell^0$-SSC allows for less restrictive conditions on subspace affinity compared to $\ell^1$-SSC, making it more robust to overlapping or closely related subspaces.
  • Efficiency Gains: Noisy-DR-$\ell^0$-SSC achieves significant speedups. The LR-based projection is 8.7 times faster than noisy $\ell^0$-SSC, and the CSP projection is 9.6 times faster.
  • Competitive Performance: Experimental results show that Noisy-DR-$\ell^0$-SSC-LR and Noisy-DR-$\ell^0$-SSC-CSP achieve competitive or superior clustering performance (measured by Accuracy and NMI) compared to other state-of-the-art methods across various datasets, often outperforming noisy SSC variants.
  • Robustness to Noise: Experiments demonstrate that increasing the regularization parameter $\lambda$ effectively reduces SDP violation in the presence of noise, confirming the theoretical predictions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity of Noisy $\ell^0$-SSC: While Noisy-DR-$\ell^0$-SSC addresses efficiency, the original noisy $\ell^0$-SSC can still be computationally intensive for very high-dimensional data.
  • Choice of Projection: The paper explores two types of random projections (randomized low-rank and count-sketch). Further investigation into optimal projection strategies for different data characteristics could be beneficial.
  • Deterministic Noise Model: The theoretical analysis primarily relies on deterministic or semi-random models for noise and data distribution. Extending these guarantees to more complex noise models or data distributions could be a future direction.
  • Parameter Tuning: While the paper highlights the importance of $\lambda$, finding the optimal $\lambda$ for different datasets and noise levels might still require careful tuning.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sparse subspace clustering methods with sparsity induced by $\ell^{0}$-norm, such as $\ell^{0}$-Sparse Subspace Clustering ($\ell^{0}$-SSC)~\citep{YangFJYH16-L0SSC-ijcv}, are demonstrated to be more effective than its $\ell^{1}$ counterpart such as Sparse Subspace Clustering (SSC)~\citep{ElhamifarV13}. However, the theoretical analysis of $\ell^{0}$-SSC is restricted to clean data that lie exactly in subspaces. Real data often suffer from noise and they may lie close to subspaces. In this paper, we show that an optimal solution to the optimization problem of noisy $\ell^{0}$-SSC achieves subspace detection property (SDP), a key element with which data from different subspaces are separated, under deterministic and semi-random model. Our results provide theoretical guarantee on the correctness of noisy $\ell^{0}$-SSC in terms of SDP on noisy data for the first time, which reveals the advantage of noisy $\ell^{0}$-SSC in terms of much less restrictive condition on subspace affinity. In order to improve the efficiency of noisy $\ell^{0}$-SSC, we propose Noisy-DR-$\ell^{0}$-SSC which provably recovers the subspaces on dimensionality reduced data. Noisy-DR-$\ell^{0}$-SSC first projects the data onto a lower dimensional space by random projection, then performs noisy $\ell^{0}$-SSC on the projected data for improved efficiency. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of Noisy-DR-$\ell^{0}$-SSC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2022noisy,
  author = {Yingzhen Yang and Ping Li},
  title = {{Noisy $\textbackslash\{\}ell^\{0\}$-Sparse Subspace Clustering on Dimensionality Reduced Data}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=BnzMjDLs5e9},
}
Figure