Noise modulation in retinoic acid signaling sharpens segmental boundaries of gene expression in the embryonic zebrafish hindbrain

Julian Sosnik, Likun Zheng, Christopher Rackauckas, Michelle A. Digman, Enrico Gratton, Qing Nie, Thomas F. SchillingeLife 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that retinoic acid (RA) signaling in developing zebrafish embryos is inherently noisy, and cells actively use binding proteins to control this noise. By modulating RA noise, cells can sharpen the boundaries of gene expression, which is crucial for proper hindbrain development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing embryos rely on morphogen gradients – signaling molecules that form concentration gradients – to tell cells where they are and what to become. These gradients are supposed to create sharply defined boundaries of gene expression, leading to distinct cell types and tissues. However, biological systems are inherently noisy, with random fluctuations in molecule production, movement, and detection. The big question this paper tackles is: how do cells interpret these noisy morphogen signals to establish precise boundaries, and can this noise actually play a functional role? Specifically, the authors focus on retinoic acid (RA) in the developing zebrafish hindbrain, a region that gives rise to different segments (rhombomeres) critical for brain development. While RA is known to be a key morphogen, its noisy nature and how cells manage it for precise patterning remained unclear.

Methods

The core innovation here is the use of fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) combined with phasor analysis to directly measure endogenous RA in vivo in zebrafish embryos.

  • FLIM: Instead of just measuring how bright a molecule is (intensity), FLIM measures how long it takes for a fluorescent molecule to emit light after being excited. This "lifetime" is a unique fingerprint for a molecule.
  • Phasor Analysis: This technique analyzes the FLIM data in a "phasor plot," where each fluorescent species occupies a specific location. Mixtures of molecules create signatures along lines connecting these locations, allowing for the quantification of relative abundances. This method is powerful because it's less susceptible to noise than intensity-based measurements and can directly measure the endogenous molecule without needing fluorescent reporters that might interfere with the system.
  • Perturbation Experiments: The researchers manipulated the levels of key RA-related proteins, specifically Crabp2a (a binding protein) and Cyp26a1 (an RA-degrading enzyme), using morpholino oligonucleotides (to reduce their levels) or mRNA injection (to increase them). They then measured the impact on RA noise and the expression of a downstream target gene, krox20.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: Hybridization Chain Reaction (HCR) was used to visualize and quantify the spatial expression of krox20 in the developing hindbrain.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on in vivo measurements from zebrafish embryos.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RA signaling is inherently noisy: The study provides direct evidence that RA levels fluctuate significantly both spatially (between neighboring cells) and temporally (within the same cell over time). This noise is biological, not an artifact of the measurement.
  • Cells actively control RA noise: The key finding is that intracellular RA-binding proteins, particularly Crabp2a, play a crucial role in modulating this noise. Depleting Crabp2a increases RA noise, while overexpressing it decreases noise, without significantly altering the average RA concentration. This suggests a sophisticated cellular mechanism for noise management.
  • Noise modulation is critical for patterning: Disrupting Crabp2a or Cyp26a1 leads to increased noise in the expression of the downstream target gene krox20 and, importantly, blurs the sharp boundaries of krox20 expression in the hindbrain segments. This directly links RA noise control to the precise establishment of developmental boundaries.
  • Crabp2a's unique role: While Cyp26a1 affects the overall RA gradient (mean concentration), Crabp2a appears to be the primary player in controlling the variability (noise) of RA levels.

Key Results

  • RA Gradient Measurement: The study successfully visualized an anteriorly declining RA gradient in zebrafish embryos using phasor-FLIM, consistent with previous indirect measurements.
  • Noise Quantification: Spatial noise in RA levels was found to be as high as 45% of the gradient magnitude, and temporal noise was also significant.
  • Crabp2a and Noise: Knockdown of Crabp2a led to a significant increase in temporal RA noise, while overexpression reduced it. Cyp26a1 manipulation affected mean RA levels but not noise.
  • Krox20 Expression: Perturbations in Crabp2a and Cyp26a1 led to increased variance in krox20 expression and a significant decrease in the sharpness of rhombomere boundaries (r3/r4 and r4/r5).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The authors acknowledge that while their findings are critical for understanding hindbrain development, future work should explore if similar RA gradient and noise control mechanisms are present in other signaling systems and tissues, and if they play roles in adult physiology and disease.
  • Biphasic Response: The study suggests that both Crabp2a and Cyp26a1 might have a biphasic effect on downstream targets, being beneficial within an optimal range but detrimental outside of it. Further investigation into this complex interplay is warranted.
  • Mechanism of Noise Propagation: While the study shows noise in RA influences downstream gene expression, the precise mechanisms by which this noise propagates through the transcriptional network require further elucidation.
  • Role of Noise: The paper hints that noise might not just be something to be suppressed but could potentially have positive roles in development, a concept that warrants deeper exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Morphogen gradients induce sharply defined domains of gene expression in a concentration-dependent manner, yet how cells interpret these signals in the face of spatial and temporal noise remains unclear. Using fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM) and phasor analysis to measure endogenous retinoic acid (RA) directly in vivo, we have investigated the amplitude of noise in RA signaling, and how modulation of this noise affects patterning of hindbrain segments (rhombomeres) in the zebrafish embryo. We demonstrate that RA forms a noisy gradient during critical stages of hindbrain patterning and that cells use distinct intracellular binding proteins to attenuate noise in RA levels. Increasing noise disrupts sharpening of rhombomere boundaries and proper patterning of the hindbrain. These findings reveal novel cellular mechanisms of noise regulation, which are likely to play important roles in other aspects of physiology and disease.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sosnik2016noise,
  author = {Julian Sosnik and Likun Zheng and Christopher Rackauckas and Michelle A. Digman and Enrico Gratton and Qing Nie and Thomas F. Schilling},
  title = {{Noise modulation in retinoic acid signaling sharpens segmental boundaries of gene expression in the embryonic zebrafish hindbrain}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.14034},
}
Figure