NNLL resummation for stop pair-production at the LHC

W. Beenakker, Christoph Borschensky, Raphael Heger, Michael Krämer, Anna Kulesza, Eric LaenenJournal of High Energy Physics 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a more precise theoretical prediction for the production of "stop" particles (superpartners of the top quark) at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). By incorporating advanced calculations (NNLL resummation), the authors significantly improve the accuracy of these predictions, which is crucial for the ongoing search for supersymmetry and for understanding the fundamental properties of these hypothetical particles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is a powerful tool for searching for new physics beyond the Standard Model, with supersymmetry (SUSY) being a leading candidate. SUSY predicts that every known particle has a "superpartner." Among these, "stops" (superpartners of the top quark) are particularly interesting because their masses are expected to be within the LHC's reach, and their production at the LHC is a key signature for discovering supersymmetry.

However, accurately predicting the rate at which these stops are produced is a complex theoretical challenge. This is especially true when the stops are produced with low kinetic energy, close to their production threshold. In this regime, "soft-gluon resummation" is necessary to account for the collective effects of many low-energy gluons that are emitted. Previous calculations had achieved next-to-leading logarithmic (NLL) accuracy, but this paper aims to push the precision further to next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic (NNLL) accuracy, incorporating additional theoretical corrections to provide a more robust prediction.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in applying advanced theoretical techniques to calculate the production cross-section of stop-antistop pairs. The primary method is NNLL resummation in Mellin-space. This involves:

  • Soft-Gluon Resummation: This technique accounts for the dominant logarithmic corrections that arise from the emission of soft gluons, particularly important near the production threshold. The paper extends previous NLL calculations to NNLL accuracy.
  • Mellin-Space Approach: This is a mathematical framework that simplifies the resummation process by transforming the problem into a different space where the calculations become more manageable.
  • Hard-Matching Coefficients: The paper includes one-loop corrections to the "hard-matching coefficient," which describes the short-distance physics of the interaction.
  • Coulomb Contributions: Two-loop corrections related to the "Coulomb interaction" between the produced stop-antistop pair are also incorporated. These are significant near the threshold.
  • Matching to Fixed-Order Calculations: The resummed results are then "matched" to higher-order fixed-order calculations (specifically, an approximated NNLO) to provide a comprehensive prediction across different kinematic regimes.

The authors explicitly mention using the QCD-Pegasus code for PDF evolution and comparing their results to existing calculations, including those from SCET (Soft-Collinear Effective Theory).

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it relies on:

  • Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs): The calculations use the MSTW2008 parton distributions at both NLO and NNLO accuracy.
  • Standard Model Parameters: The top quark mass is taken from the Review of Particle Physics (PDG).
  • SUSY Parameters: The calculations are performed for specific benchmark points, notably benchmark point 40.2.5 from a previous SUSY study [52]. The paper also uses parameter values from a related study [42] for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NNLL is Crucial for Precision: The NNLL corrections significantly enhance the predicted cross-section compared to NLL, highlighting the importance of going beyond NLL for accurate predictions, especially at higher stop masses.
  • Threshold Effects Dominate: The calculations strongly emphasize the impact of threshold physics. The Coulomb contributions, in particular, play a vital role in improving the accuracy near the production threshold.
  • Stop Mixing Matters: The paper observes a slightly increased dependence of the NNLL predictions on additional SUSY parameters, such as the stop mixing parameter and the gluino mass. This suggests that precise measurements of stop production could provide valuable constraints on these parameters.
  • Scale Dependence Reduction: While the NNLL corrections lead to an upward slope in scale dependence, the overall dependence is still reduced compared to lower-order calculations, indicating the robustness of the NNLL approach.
  • Comparison with SCET: The agreement with results obtained using the SCET formalism, despite different methodologies, provides strong validation for the NNLL resummation approach.

Key Results

  • The NNLOApprox+NNLL cross-section for stop-antistop production is found to be significantly larger than NLO+NLL predictions across all stop masses and LHC energies (8 and 13 TeV).
  • For 8 TeV and a stop mass of 2.5 TeV, the NNLOApprox+NNLL results show an increase of roughly 40% compared to NLO+NLL. For 13 TeV and a stop mass of 3 TeV, the increase is about 10%.
  • The scale uncertainty is reduced with the inclusion of NNLL corrections, though it shows a slight upward slope at higher scales.
  • The dependence on additional SUSY parameters (like gluino mass and mixing angle) is found to be modest, with variations of at most a few percent for most parameters, except for the gluino mass which can lead to several percent changes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • p-wave Channels: The paper notes that for certain "p-wave" color channels (where stops are produced with non-zero angular momentum), the full NNLL resummation is not yet theoretically proven. For these channels, calculations are performed up to NLO+NLL accuracy. The authors state that the impact of these p-wave contributions on the total cross-section is small (a few permille).
  • Parameter Dependence: While the dependence on most additional SUSY parameters is small, the paper highlights that the choice of a specific SUSY model and benchmark point can have a noticeable effect on the stop production cross-sections, particularly at high stop masses.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to publish these NNLL results for stop production along with those for other squark and gluino processes. They also intend to make this publicly available as a code similar to NLL-fast, to be used in experimental studies for Run II of the LHC. They also mention a forthcoming phenomenological study on the effects of different PDF sets.

Summary updated

Abstract

The production of supersymmetric stop-antistop pairs at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is studied including corrections from soft-gluon resummation up to next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic (NNLL) accuracy in the Mellin-space approach. Additionally, corrections to the hard-matching coefficient at one-loop and Coulomb contributions at two-loop order are considered. The NNLL corrections enhance the cross section for all stop masses at centre-of-mass energies of 8 and 13 TeV compared to the previously calculated predictions at next-to-leading logarithmic (NLL) accuracy. Furthermore, a slight increase in the dependence on the additional stop-mixing parameters is observed.
BibTeX
@article{beenakker2016nnll,
  author = {W. Beenakker and Christoph Borschensky and Raphael Heger and Michael Krämer and Anna Kulesza and Eric Laenen},
  title = {{NNLL resummation for stop pair-production at the LHC}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep05(2016)153},
}
Figure