NNLL resummation for squark and gluino production at the LHC

W. Beenakker, Christoph Borschensky, Michael Krämer, Anna Kulesza, Eric Laenen, Vincent Theeuwes, Silja ThewesJournal of High Energy Physics 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a significant theoretical advancement in predicting the production of hypothetical supersymmetric particles (squarks and gluinos) at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). By employing a sophisticated resummation technique called NNLL (next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic) accuracy, the authors provide more precise predictions for these processes, which are crucial for interpreting experimental data and searching for new physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics, while incredibly successful, doesn't explain phenomena like dark matter or the hierarchy problem. Supersymmetry (SUSY) is a leading theoretical extension that proposes a symmetry between bosons and fermions, predicting partner particles for each known particle. Among these, squarks and gluinos are particularly interesting because they are colored particles, meaning they interact strongly with gluons and are thus produced more copiously at the LHC.

Accurately predicting the production rates (cross-sections) of these hypothetical particles is vital for two main reasons:

  1. Exclusion Limits: If experiments like ATLAS and CMS don't observe these particles within a certain mass range, these precise predictions help set exclusion limits, ruling out certain SUSY models.
  2. Discovery and Characterization: If these particles are discovered, precise theoretical predictions are essential for understanding their properties (masses, interactions) and comparing them with theoretical models.

Previous theoretical calculations had achieved NLO (next-to-leading order) and NLL (next-to-leading logarithmic) accuracy. However, at the high energies and masses relevant for current and future LHC runs, contributions from soft-gluon emissions become significant and need to be accounted for to higher orders to achieve reliable predictions. This paper addresses the need for NNLL accuracy, incorporating more subtle theoretical effects.

Methods

The core of this work is the application of NNLL resummation in the Mellin-moment space formalism. Here's a breakdown:

  • Resummation: This technique is used to sum up large logarithmic contributions that arise from specific kinematic regions, particularly near the "threshold" where the energy available is just enough to produce the particles. These large logarithms, if not resummed, can spoil the convergence of fixed-order perturbative calculations.
  • NNLL Accuracy: This refers to resumming terms up to the next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic order. This involves not only the leading logarithms (LL) and next-to-leading logarithms (NLL) but also the next-to-next-to-leading logarithms (NNLL).
  • Mellin-Moment Space: This is a mathematical technique where the cross-section is transformed into a different space (N-space) where the large logarithms of the threshold variable become simple powers of N. Resummation is performed in this space, and then the result is transformed back to the original space.
  • Hard Matching Coefficients and Coulomb Corrections: Beyond the soft-gluon resummation, the authors also include:
  • One-loop hard matching coefficients: These account for the non-logarithmic contributions from the hard scattering process at one-loop level.
  • Second-order Coulomb corrections: These arise from the attractive/repulsive interactions between the produced heavy colored particles (squarks and gluinos) via gluon exchange. These are particularly important near threshold.

The paper details the calculation of these components and their combination to achieve the NNLL matched cross-section.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical calculations and predictions, not on experimental data fitting or training.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Significant Enhancements: The NNLL resummation leads to a substantial increase in the predicted cross-sections for all four squark and gluino pair-production processes compared to NLO+NLL predictions. This highlights the importance of higher-order corrections.
  • Reduced Scale Dependence (Mostly): For most processes, the NNLL resummation significantly reduces the theoretical uncertainty arising from the choice of renormalization and factorization scales. This indicates a more stable and reliable prediction.
  • Gluino-Pair Production Anomaly: Interestingly, gluino-pair production shows a moderate enhancement in scale dependence at NNLL compared to NLL. The authors attribute this to the interplay of Coulomb corrections and scale-dependent terms in the resummed exponentials, possibly exacerbated by the incompleteness of two-loop matching coefficients.
  • Dominance of Logarithmic Terms for Gluinos: The logarithmic terms of soft origin are found to be more important for gluino-pair production due to the larger color factors involved in gluon-gluon initial states.
  • PDF Impact: The authors note that the increase in the uncertainty from NNLO PDFs (compared to NLO PDFs) contributes to a larger overall uncertainty in the NNLL matched predictions, especially at higher masses.

Key Results

  • NNLL Matched Predictions: The paper provides NNLL matched cross-section predictions for squark-squark, squark-antisquark, squark-gluino, and gluino-gluino pair production at the LHC for a center-of-mass energy of 8 TeV and squark/gluino masses up to 2.5 TeV.
  • K-Factors: The K-factor (ratio of NNLL matched to NLO+NLL) shows significant enhancements, reaching up to ~3 for gluino-pair production at high masses. For squark-squark production, the enhancement can be up to ~80% over NLO at average mass scales.
  • Scale Uncertainty Reduction: Scale uncertainties are generally reduced at NNLL, except for gluino-pair production.
  • PDF and αs Uncertainties: These uncertainties become dominant at NNLL, particularly for larger masses.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incomplete Two-Loop Matching Coefficients: The authors acknowledge that the calculation of the complete two-loop hard matching coefficient is not yet available and was set to zero in their calculation. This might affect the results, especially for gluino-pair production.
  • Coulomb Correction Resummation: The resummation of Coulomb corrections themselves is a topic for future investigation, which could further refine the predictions.
  • Comparison with EFT: The paper notes a ~10% difference in NNLL K-factors for gluino-pair production compared to results obtained using effective field theory (EFT) methods. Resolving this discrepancy is a future task.
  • Future Plans: The authors plan to upgrade their NLL resummation code (NLL-FAST) to NNLL level and extend predictions to LHC energies of 13 TeV.

Summary updated

Abstract

We perform the resummation of soft-gluon emissions for squark and gluino production at next-to-next-to-leading logarithmic (NNLL) accuracy. We include also the one-loop hard matching coefficients as well as Coulomb corrections to second order, using Mellin-moment methods. We study the characteristics of this resummation in detail for a centre-of-mass (CM) energy of 8 TeV at the LHC, and for squark and gluino masses up to 2.5 TeV. We find significant enhancing effects for all four processes of squark- and gluinopair production. Scale dependence is generally reduced compared to NLL resummation, except for gluino-pair production where we find a moderate enhancement.
BibTeX
@article{beenakker2014nnll,
  author = {W. Beenakker and Christoph Borschensky and Michael Krämer and Anna Kulesza and Eric Laenen and Vincent Theeuwes and Silja Thewes},
  title = {{NNLL resummation for squark and gluino production at the LHC}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep12(2014)023},
}
Figure