Nicking mechanism underlying the DNA phosphorothioate-sensing antiphage defense by SspE

Haiyan Gao, Xinqi Gong, Jinchuan Zhou, Yubing Zhang, Jinsong Duan, Yue Wei, Liuqing Chen, Zixin Deng, Jiawei Wang, Shi Chen, Geng Wu, Lianrong WangNature Communications 2022 · DOI

Abstract

DNA phosphorothioate (PT) modification, with a nonbridging phosphate oxygen substituted by sulfur, represents a widespread epigenetic marker in prokaryotes and provides protection against genetic parasites. In the PT-based defense system Ssp, SspABCD confers a single-stranded PT modification of host DNA in the 5'-C<sub>PS</sub>CA-3' motif and SspE impedes phage propagation. SspE relies on PT modification in host DNA to exert antiphage activity. Here, structural and biochemical analyses reveal that SspE is preferentially recruited to PT sites mediated by the joint action of its N-terminal domain (NTD) hydrophobic cavity and C-terminal domain (CTD) DNA binding region. PT recognition enlarges the GTP-binding pocket, thereby increasing GTP hydrolysis activity, which subsequently triggers a conformational switch of SspE from a closed to an open state. The closed-to-open transition promotes the dissociation of SspE from self PT-DNA and turns on the DNA nicking nuclease activity of CTD, enabling SspE to accomplish self-nonself discrimination and limit phage predation, even when only a small fraction of modifiable consensus sequences is PT-protected in a bacterial genome.

Introduction

Bacteria and phages are engaged in a continuous evolutionary arms race, leading to the development of diverse bacterial "innate immune systems" to distinguish self from non-self DNA. One such epigenetic strategy involves phosphorothioate (PT) modification, where a sulfur atom replaces a non-bridging oxygen in the DNA backbone. In the Ssp system, SspABCD performs host DNA modification, while SspE provides the defense. A long-standing paradox has been how SspE utilizes a "self" marker (PT) to trigger an attack on phage DNA that lacks this modification. This study elucidates the structural and biochemical "sensing" mechanism that enables SspE to achieve this self-nonself discrimination.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach to map SspE’s function. X-ray crystallography was used to determine the structures of full-length SspE (3.4 Å) and its domains (PDB accessions 7DRI, 7DRS, 7DRR). Biochemical assays, including EMSA, Microscale Thermophoresis, and GTPase activity measurements, characterized DNA binding and enzymatic function. Real-time conformational changes were monitored via Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET). In vivo validation was performed using plaque assays and bacterial growth curves in Streptomyces lividans challenged with phage JXY1.

Results and Mechanistic Insights

SspE functions as a GTP-powered molecular switch. It features a specialized hydrophobic cavity in its N-terminal domain (NTD) that specifically "reads" the hydrophobic PT modifications on host DNA. This recognition event physically enlarges the GTP-binding pocket, stimulating GTPase activity by approximately 2.3-fold.

GTP hydrolysis drives a transition from a "closed" to an "open" state. In the closed state, SspE is bound to host PT-DNA. Upon activation, the protein dissociates from the host DNA and activates a "nicking" nuclease activity in its C-terminal domain (CTD), which contains an HNH-like motif. This allows the activated SspE to patrol the cell and selectively target unmodified phage DNA.

Figure 1: Structural and biochemical characterization of SspE. (a-b) Structural analysis of SspE and its HNH motif. (c-d) DNA nicking assays showing the activity of SspE and various mutants (e.g., R100A), and the dependence on divalent metal ions. (e) Plaque assays demonstrating the in vivo antiphage activity of SspE and the loss of protection in the N676A mutant.

Key biochemical data revealed that SspE binds PT-modified DNA with higher affinity ($K_d$ = 8.5 μM) compared to unmodified DNA ($K_d$ = 18.4 μM). Mutational analysis confirmed the importance of specific residues: mutations in the sensing pocket (Y30A, Q31A) or the GTPase motif (R100A) completely abolished the protein's ability to protect the bacteria against phages. The nuclease activity, characterized as single-strand nicking, is essential for limiting phage propagation. Growth curve analysis further confirmed that these mutations did not adversely affect host fitness in the absence of phage.

Figure 2: Growth curves of S. lividans expressing SspABCD and various SspE mutants. The overlapping curves indicate that the expression of the defense system and its various functional mutants does not impose a significant fitness cost on the host under standard growth conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

Several questions remain regarding the SspE mechanism. It is currently unclear how SspE resets from the active "open" state back to the "closed" surveillance state once the threat is neutralized. Additionally, while SspE can nick PT-DNA in vitro in the absence of GTP, host DNA remains unharmed in vivo, suggesting additional regulatory layers or protective factors in the cellular environment. Finally, the broad specificity against various phages contrasted with the lack of interference with plasmid transformation suggests further nuances in how SspE targets specific types of foreign DNA.

Summary updated

Abstract

DNA phosphorothioate (PT) modification, with a nonbridging phosphate oxygen substituted by sulfur, represents a widespread epigenetic marker in prokaryotes and provides protection against genetic parasites. In the PT-based defense system Ssp, SspABCD confers a single-stranded PT modification of host DNA in the 5'-C<sub>PS</sub>CA-3' motif and SspE impedes phage propagation. SspE relies on PT modification in host DNA to exert antiphage activity. Here, structural and biochemical analyses reveal that SspE is preferentially recruited to PT sites mediated by the joint action of its N-terminal domain (NTD) hydrophobic cavity and C-terminal domain (CTD) DNA binding region. PT recognition enlarges the GTP-binding pocket, thereby increasing GTP hydrolysis activity, which subsequently triggers a conformational switch of SspE from a closed to an open state. The closed-to-open transition promotes the dissociation of SspE from self PT-DNA and turns on the DNA nicking nuclease activity of CTD, enabling SspE to accomplish self-nonself discrimination and limit phage predation, even when only a small fraction of modifiable consensus sequences is PT-protected in a bacterial genome.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2022nicking,
  author = {Haiyan Gao and Xinqi Gong and Jinchuan Zhou and Yubing Zhang and Jinsong Duan and Yue Wei and Liuqing Chen and Zixin Deng and Jiawei Wang and Shi Chen and Geng Wu and Lianrong Wang},
  title = {{Nicking mechanism underlying the DNA phosphorothioate-sensing antiphage defense by SspE}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-34505-0},
}
Figure