NFC-Enabled Dual-Channel Flexible Printed Sensor Tag

Jonghyun Choi, Ian Visagie, Yi Chen, Robert Abbel, Kate ParkerSensors 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, flexible, and printed sensor tag that uses Near-Field Communication (NFC) to simultaneously monitor both temperature and ethylene gas. This dual-sensing capability is achieved through a unique integration of printed resistive and capacitive sensors onto a single flexible substrate, paving the way for more sophisticated smart packaging solutions for fresh produce.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Monitoring the quality and safety of fresh produce during storage and transport is crucial to minimize food waste. Key factors affecting spoilage include temperature and the presence of ethylene gas, a ripening hormone. While individual wireless sensors exist for these parameters, there's a need for integrated, flexible, and low-cost solutions that can be easily incorporated into packaging. Existing NFC-enabled sensors often focus on single-parameter detection, and integrating multiple sensing elements onto a flexible platform with NFC connectivity has been a significant challenge. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a dual-channel NFC sensor tag capable of simultaneously tracking both temperature and ethylene.

Methods

The researchers designed and fabricated a flexible printed circuit board (PCB) module (13 mm x 13 mm) integrated with a square NFC antenna printed on a flexible poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) substrate.

  • Dual-Channel Sensing: The core innovation lies in the dual-channel sensing approach.
  • Temperature Sensing: A resistive temperature sensor was created using a screen-printable positive temperature coefficient (PTC) ink mixed with a clear epoxy ink. This mixture was printed onto interdigitated electrodes (IDEs) on the PET substrate.
  • Ethylene Sensing: A capacitive ethylene sensor was fabricated using a multi-layer structure. This involved screen-printing a silver bottom electrode, followed by a solution-cast cellulose acetate layer, a spray-coated tin oxide (SnO2) nanoparticle layer (acting as the sensing material), and finally, a grid-shaped silver top electrode. This forms a chemicapacitive structure.
  • NFC Integration: The fabricated sensors and antenna were connected to an NXP® NHS3152 NFC integrated circuit (IC) using electrically conductive silver epoxy adhesive. This IC handles data acquisition for both resistance and capacitance channels and provides NFC connectivity.
  • Fabrication Techniques: Screen printing was primarily used for depositing the silver electrodes, PTC ink, and the top silver electrode. Spray coating was employed for the SnO2 nanoparticle layer, and solution casting was used for the cellulose acetate layer.
  • Characterization: Field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM) was used to examine the surface and cross-sectional morphologies of the printed layers to ensure uniformity and adhesion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the development and experimental validation of the sensor tag itself, rather than training on large datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Dual-Sensing on Flexible Substrate: The successful integration of both resistive (temperature) and capacitive (ethylene) sensors onto a single flexible PET substrate, coupled with NFC, is a significant advancement. This moves beyond single-parameter sensing and offers a more comprehensive monitoring solution.
  • Printable Electronics for Sensing: The use of screen printing and spray coating for fabricating the sensor elements demonstrates the potential of low-cost, large-area printable electronics for creating functional sensor tags.
  • Material Optimization for Sensing Range: The paper highlights the importance of material selection and formulation. For instance, mixing the PTC ink with epoxy was crucial to achieve a resistance range compatible with the NFC IC for temperature sensing. Similarly, optimizing the thickness of the cellulose acetate and SnO2 layers was critical for the capacitive ethylene sensor to achieve a balance between capacitance, short-circuit prevention, and sensitivity.
  • NFC as a Powerless Communication Interface: The reliance on NFC allows the sensor tag to be battery-free, powered by the NFC reader, making it ideal for disposable or long-term deployment in packaging.

Key Results

  • Temperature Sensing: The mixed PTC ink formulation exhibited a linear resistance change from 4 to 6 kΩ between 30 and 50 °C, within the operating range of the NFC IC.
  • Ethylene Sensing: The capacitive ethylene sensor demonstrated a response to ethylene gas. Peak capacitances of 128.3 nF and 127.8 nF were observed at 500 ppm and 250 ppm ethylene concentrations, respectively, with a baseline of 127.2 ± 0.1 nF. The sensor detected a minimum concentration of 250 ppm.
  • Flexibility: The fabricated tag demonstrated good flexibility, as shown in photographic evidence.
  • Simultaneous Monitoring: The dual-channel design allows for simultaneous operation and monitoring of both temperature and ethylene.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sensitivity and Range of Ethylene Sensor: The authors acknowledge that the demonstrated ethylene sensitivity was not high, with a minimum detection limit of 250 ppm. They suggest that further improvement in the active material (SnO2 nanoparticles) through catalytic doping could enhance sensitivity.
  • Signal Resolution: The current signal resolution for capacitance is 0.1 nF, which could be improved by modifying the capacitance signal processing circuit of the PCB.
  • Cross-Talk: Cross-talk between the temperature and ethylene sensors is a potential issue that needs to be addressed in future work. While the authors expect temperature to influence capacitance, they anticipate negligible influence of ethylene on the temperature sensor's conductivity. Calibration of the temperature sensor for its temperature dependence is suggested to correct ethylene sensor readings.
  • Reducing Cellulose Acetate Thickness: Reducing the thickness of the cellulose acetate layer is proposed as a way to increase sensing performance, provided that electrical short circuits can be prevented.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{choi2023nfc,
  author = {Jonghyun Choi and Ian Visagie and Yi Chen and Robert Abbel and Kate Parker},
  title = {{NFC-Enabled Dual-Channel Flexible Printed Sensor Tag}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=zh4PORlVI3},
}
Figure