TL;DR
Researchers have performed a rigorous next-to-leading-order (NLO) calculation of the "color singlet" mechanism for producing pairs of $J/\psi$ mesons at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). While the theory aligns well with data from the LHCb experiment, it fails spectacularly to account for the high-momentum pairs seen by CMS and ATLAS, suggesting that "color octet" processes or double-parton scattering are the missing links in our understanding of heavy quarkonium.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The production of heavy quarkonia—particles made of a heavy quark and its antiquark, like the $J/\psi$ meson—remains one of the most stubborn puzzles in Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). Despite decades of study, physicists still struggle to model exactly how these "atoms" of the strong force bind together during high-energy collisions.
Producing a pair of $J/\psi$ mesons (double prompt hadroproduction) is even more complex and serves as a high-stakes stress test for theoretical frameworks like Nonrelativistic QCD (NRQCD). Specifically, there is an ongoing debate about two competing mechanisms:
- Color Singlet (CS): The $c\bar{c}$ pair is produced in a color-neutral state from the start.
- Color Octet (CO): The pair starts with a "color charge" and must radiate gluons to become neutral.
Furthermore, these pairs can come from a single pair of colliding partons (Single Parton Scattering, SPS) or two independent pairs (Double Parton Scattering, DPS). This paper aims to provide a definitive NLO calculation for the CS contribution to see if it can explain recent LHC data on its own.
Methods
The authors employed the NRQCD factorization framework to calculate the cross-sections at Next-to-Leading Order (NLO) in the strong coupling constant ($\alpha_s$). This involves calculating both "virtual" corrections (loop diagrams) and "real" corrections (where an extra gluon or quark is emitted).
To handle the daunting mathematics of NLO QCD, they used a sophisticated computational pipeline:
- QGRAF & FORM: For generating Feynman diagrams and handling complex algebra.
- Reduze 2 & FIRE6: For reducing massive one-loop integrals into a manageable set of "master integrals."
- Two-cutoff phase space slicing: A technique used to isolate and cancel out infrared divergences (mathematical infinities that arise from low-energy gluon emissions).
- Cuba library: For performing the final high-dimensional numerical integrations.
Datasets
As a theoretical study, the paper evaluates its predictions against experimental results from the CERN Large Hadron Collider:
- LHCb: Data at center-of-mass energies of 7 TeV and 13 TeV (focusing on forward-rapidity regions).
- CMS: Data at 7 TeV (covering central-rapidity and higher transverse momentum).
- ATLAS: Data at 8 TeV (central and forward regions with high momentum cuts).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "K-factor" varies wildly: The K-factor (the ratio of NLO to Leading Order results) isn't a simple constant. For total cross-sections, it’s around 2 to 3, but for specific kinematic distributions, NLO corrections can change the result by orders of magnitude.
- LHCb is the "Sweet Spot": The CS model at NLO describes the LHCb data surprisingly well. This suggests that in the specific kinematic range of LHCb (lower momentum, forward angles), the color singlet mechanism is the dominant player.
- The CMS/ATLAS "Gap": In the high-momentum regions explored by CMS and ATLAS, the CS model undershoots the experimental data by factors of 10 to 40. This is a massive discrepancy that NLO corrections alone cannot fix.
- The Role of Gluon Radiation: The authors found that at very low transverse momentum for the $J/\psi$ pair, the fixed-order calculation breaks down because it doesn't account for the "resummation" of multiple soft gluon emissions.
Key Results
- LHCb 13 TeV: The predicted SPS cross-section is $11.4^{+5.8}_{-3.2}$ nb, which is consistent with the experimental measurement of $7.9 \pm 1.2 \pm 1.1$ nb within the theoretical uncertainties.
- CMS 7 TeV: The theory predicts 0.147 nb, while the experiment measured 1.49 nb—a tenfold difference.
- ATLAS 8 TeV: The discrepancy is even larger, with the theory being roughly 28 to 40 times smaller than the experimental observations in certain regions.
- Shape Changes: NLO corrections significantly improved the "shape" of the transverse momentum ($p_T$) distributions compared to Leading Order, even if the absolute normalization remained off for CMS/ATLAS.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors are transparent about what their model doesn't include:
- Color Octet (CO) Contributions: The massive gap in CMS/ATLAS data strongly suggests that CO processes (where the quarks start with color) are essential at high energies.
- Relativistic Corrections: Near the production threshold (where the two $J/\psi$ mesons have very little relative energy), relativistic effects become important and were not included here.
- Double Parton Scattering (DPS): While this paper focused on SPS, a full picture of the LHC data likely requires a better understanding of how two separate parton collisions contribute to the same event.
The conclusion is clear: while NLO CS is a vital piece of the puzzle, double $J/\psi$ production is "far from being well understood" and requires a multi-pronged theoretical approach to solve.
Summary updated