Next Generation Robotics

Henrik I. Christensen, Allison M. Okamura, Maja J. Mataric, Vijay Kumar, Gregory D. Hager, Howie ChosetarXiv 2016 · OpenReview

Abstract

The National Robotics Initiative (NRI) was launched in 2011 and is about to celebrate its five-year anniversary. In parallel with the NRI, the robotics community, with support from the Computing Community Consortium (CCC), engaged in a series of road-mapping exercises. The first version of the roadmap appeared in September 2009; a second updated version appeared in 2013. While not directly aligned with the NRI, these road-mapping documents have provided both a useful charting of the robotics research space, as well as a metric by which to measure progress. This report sets forth a perspective of progress in robotics over the past five years and provides a set of recommendations for the future. The NRI has in its formulation a strong emphasis on co-robots—robots that work directly with people. To assess main trends and promising directions, a CCC-sponsored study conducted workshops in Washington, D.C., and San Francisco in 2016. This paper summarizes the discussions regarding the transition from isolated automation to collaborative systems.

Introduction: The "Henry Ford" Era of Robotics

The current state of robotics is often compared to the early 20th-century automotive industry. We have moved past the initial invention phase and have entered the "Henry Ford" era: we possess the first viable, scalable platforms, but the massive societal integration and supporting infrastructure are still in their infancy. While robotics has seen explosive growth, many current successes remain "demos" that function only under tightly constrained conditions. The transition from structured factory floors to the messy, unpredictable environments of everyday life—homes, hospitals, and disaster zones—remains the primary frontier for the next decade.

The Challenge: The Science of Autonomy

The core technical challenge identified by the community is the "Science of Autonomy." This involves moving beyond robots that simply follow pre-programmed scripts to "co-robots" capable of perceiving human intent and adapting to new tasks through life-long learning. Autonomy is a property (the ability to achieve goals independently), while collaboration is the objective. True co-robots require high levels of autonomy to be useful partners rather than cognitive or physical burdens on their human counterparts.

Methodology and Trend Analysis

As a strategic assessment commissioned by the CCC, this report synthesizes findings from two major 2016 workshops featuring leading researchers. The field was evaluated through metric analysis—tracking record-breaking attendance at conferences like ICRA (3,000+ attendees in 2015)—and trend mapping. Researchers utilized hardware performance charts to correlate the surge in computational power with algorithmic breakthroughs in computer vision and motion planning.

Comparison of GPU and CPU performance trends (GFLOP/s) from 2000 to 2014, illustrating the hardware surge supporting robotics breakthroughs.

Key Insights and Economic Factors

Economic viability remains a significant hurdle for widespread adoption. In modern manufacturing, the physical robot typically accounts for only 30% of the total cost, while software integration accounts for 50%. There is a critical need for "automated software generation" to make robotics affordable for small-scale, "one-off" manufacturing. Furthermore, the report emphasizes "Soft Robotics" as a safety requirement; moving away from rigid metal frames toward materials like foams and gels is essential for robots intended to operate in close proximity to humans.

Progress and Market Impact

Since 2011, the NRI has sponsored over 200 proposals totaling more than $150M across agencies including the NSF, NASA, USDA, and NIH. This investment has catalyzed significant market shifts. Collaborative robots are now the fastest-growing segment of the industry, with a 50% annual growth rate, vastly outperforming the 16% growth seen in traditional industrial systems. In the medical field, the da Vinci Surgical System now performs over 600,000 minimally invasive procedures annually, demonstrating the maturity of specialized co-robotic platforms.

Competitive intensity and data capture potential across various industry sectors, identifying key areas for robotic application and value creation.

Limitations and Future Recommendations

Despite these successes, a significant "Toddler Gap" persists. While neural networks can defeat world champions at complex games like Go, they cannot yet match the physical dexterity of a three-year-old with Lego blocks or the social intuition of a five-year-old. Current autonomous vehicles still rely heavily on high-definition maps and struggle with complex social cues and adverse weather.

To bridge these gaps, the report recommends:

  • Life-Long Learning: Developing systems that accumulate experience over years of operation rather than hours of training.
  • Shared Infrastructure: Creating national testbeds for autonomous driving and medical robotics to allow academic researchers to compete with private industry "robot farms."
  • Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) Datasets: Addressing the critical lack of large-scale, accessible datasets for physical manipulation and social interaction.

Conclusion

The first five years of the NRI have successfully shifted the national conversation toward co-robotics. However, the journey from laboratory demos to robust, everyday utility requires a sustained focus on the fundamental science of autonomy and the democratization of robotics infrastructure. The next decade will be defined by how well robots can learn to navigate the complexities of the human world.

Summary updated

Abstract

The National Robotics Initiative (NRI) was launched 2011 and is about to celebrate its 5 year anniversary. In parallel with the NRI, the robotics community, with support from the Computing Community Consortium, engaged in a series of road mapping exercises. The first version of the roadmap appeared in September 2009; a second updated version appeared in 2013. While not directly aligned with the NRI, these road-mapping documents have provided both a useful charting of the robotics research space, as well as a metric by which to measure progress. This report sets forth a perspective of progress in robotics over the past five years, and provides a set of recommendations for the future. The NRI has in its formulation a strong emphasis on co-robot, i.e., robots that work directly with people. An obvious question is if this should continue to be the focus going forward? To try to assess what are the main trends, what has happened the last 5 years and what may be promising directions for the future a small CCC sponsored study was launched to have two workshops, one in Washington DC (March 5th, 2016) and another in San Francisco, CA (March 11th, 2016). In this report we brief summarize some of the main discussions and observations from those workshops. We will present a variety of background information in Section 2, and outline various issues related to progress over the last 5 years in Section 3. In Section 4 we will outline a number of opportunities for moving forward. Finally, we will summarize the main points in Section 5.
BibTeX
@misc{christensen2016next,
  author = {Henrik I. Christensen and Allison M. Okamura and Maja J. Mataric and Vijay Kumar and Gregory D. Hager and Howie Choset},
  title = {{Next Generation Robotics}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1606.09205},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.09205},
}
Figure