Newtonian flow inside carbon nanotube with permeable boundary taking into account van der Waals forces

Yue Chan, Shern‐Long Lee, Wenjian Chen, Zheng Lian, Yong Shi, Yong RenScientific 2019 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates water flow within large-radius, semi-infinite carbon nanotubes (CNTs) by integrating molecular interactions into a continuum fluid mechanics framework. By accounting for van der Waals forces, slip boundary conditions, and wall permeability, the authors derive analytical solutions for radial and axial velocities. A key finding is the identification of "suck-in" forces at the tube entry, which enhance axial flux by an order of magnitude, potentially explaining the anomalously high flow rates observed in experimental nanotechnology.

Introduction: The Permeability Paradox

Carbon nanotubes have emerged as a revolutionary material for water purification and desalination. However, a persistent challenge in the field is the "mysteriously high" water permeability observed in these nano-channels. Experimental flow rates often exceed the predictions of classical continuum fluid mechanics, such as Poiseuille flow, by several orders of magnitude. While molecular dynamics (MD) simulations can replicate these phenomena, they are computationally intensive and often lack the generalizable insights provided by analytical models. This research addresses this gap by developing a mathematical framework that bridges macroscopic Navier-Stokes equations with microscopic molecular forces.

Methodology

The researchers model water as an incompressible Newtonian fluid. To capture the unique physics of the nanoscale environment, two primary modifications are introduced to the standard Navier-Stokes equations:

  1. Molecular Body Forces: Van der Waals interactions between water molecules and the nanotube wall are treated as radial body forces using a continuum approximation.
  2. Entrance "Suck-in" Forces: The impulse experienced by water molecules upon entering the tube—caused by the asymmetric potential at the opening—is modeled using the Langevin equation and Monte-Carlo simulations.

To solve these equations, a stream function approach is employed alongside a change of variables ($\xi = a^2 - r^2$) to handle radial terms. Analytical solutions for radial ($u$) and axial ($v$) velocities are then derived via an asymptotic expansion technique.

Schematic of the mathematical model for flow inside a carbon nanotube, illustrating radial (u) and axial (v) velocity components.

Key Insights and Results

The analytical model yields several transformative insights into nanofluidic behavior:

The "Suck-in" Effect

The most significant result is the impact of entry forces. These axial molecular forces act as sharp impulses at the tube's mouth, effectively pulling water into the channel. The model demonstrates that including these forces increases the average axial flux from approximately $200 \text{ kg m}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$ to $3021 \text{ kg m}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$—a ten-fold enhancement that aligns more closely with experimental data.

Total axial molecular forces ($F^{tot}$) for water molecules entering nanotubes of various radii ($a$), showing the impulse effect at the entry ($R=0$).

Inverted Velocity Profiles

Unlike classical pipe flow, where velocity is highest at the center, the axial velocity in this model peaks near the tube wall. This inversion occurs because radial van der Waals forces push water into a "habitable" zone near the inner wall where molecular interactions are most favorable.

Permeability and Penetration

For nanotubes with permeable walls (simulating defects), the model predicts a decline in axial velocity as water leaks out. This allows engineers to calculate a "maximum penetration length," which is vital for the design of efficient ultra-filtration membranes.

Conclusion

By incorporating molecular-scale forces into a classical fluid dynamics framework, this study provides a robust analytical explanation for the high permeability of carbon nanotubes. The findings regarding entry impulses and inverted velocity profiles offer a new perspective on nanofluidic transport. This mathematical framework can be extended to other porous nanomaterials, facilitating the development of next-generation technologies for environmental protection and water treatment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Here, water flow inside large radii semi-infinite carbon nanotubes is investigated. Permeable wall taking into account the molecular interactions between water and a nanotube, and the slip boundary condition will be considered. Furthermore, interactions among molecules are approximated by the continuum approximation. Incompressible and Newtonian fluid is assumed, and the Navier-Stokes equations, after certain assumptions, transformations and derivations, can be reduced into two first integral equations. In conjunction with the asymptotic expansion technique, we are able to derive the radial and axial velocities analytically, capturing the effect of the water leakage, where both mild and exceptionally large leakages will be considered. The radial velocity obeys the prescribed boundary condition at the (im)permeable wall. Through the mean of the radial forces, the sufficiently large leakages will enhance the radial velocity at the center of the tube. On the other hand, unlike the classical laminar flow, the axial velocity attains its maximum at the wall due to the coupling effect with the radial forces as water is being pushed into the proximity of the inner wall. In addition, the axial velocity and the flux with the consideration of the suck-in forces, induced by the tubes' entry turn out to be one order higher than that without the suck-in forces. All the aforementioned considerations might partially resolve the mysteriously high water penetration through nanotubes. Axial velocity also drops with the tube's length when the water leakage is permitted and the suck-in forces will ease the decline rate of the axial velocity. The present mathematical framework can be directly employed into the water flow inside other porous nano-materials, where large water leakage is permitted and therefore are of huge practical impact on ultra-filtration and environmental protection.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chan2019newtonian,
  author = {Yue Chan and Shern‐Long Lee and Wenjian Chen and Zheng Lian and Yong Shi and Yong Ren},
  title = {{Newtonian flow inside carbon nanotube with permeable boundary taking into account van der Waals forces}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-48614-2},
}
Figure