New Wing Stroke and Wing Pitch Approaches for Milligram-scale Aerial Devices

Palak Bhushan, Claire J. TomlinarXiv 2019 · arXiv

Introduction

Building flapping-wing micro-aerial vehicles (MAVs) at the milligram scale—comparable to the size of a common fly—presents significant engineering challenges. Traditional designs typically rely on complex mechanical linkages to amplify the small displacements of piezoelectric actuators into large wing strokes. This "mechanical advantage" approach suffers from two primary drawbacks: extreme manufacturing complexity requiring 3D assembly of multiple materials, and the "coupling problem," where wing pitch is passively driven by aerodynamic forces, making it difficult to tune wing shape and hinge stiffness independently.

Researchers from UC Berkeley have introduced a streamlined mechanical transmission that addresses these issues. By transitioning to a single-material resonant design, they have simplified the fabrication process and decoupled the wing's aerodynamic performance from its mechanical stiffness.

Proposed Mechanical Transmission

The proposed system utilizes two key mechanical innovations: a resonant stroke transmission and a centripetal pitch mechanism.

Resonant Stroke Transmission

Instead of intricate linkages, the design employs a linearly driven torsional pendulum. A linear actuator vibrates the base of a wing mounted on a planar spring. When driven at the system's natural frequency, the wing achieves wide strokes (up to $\pm 60^\circ$) with minimal input energy. This mechanism is entirely planar and can be laser-cut from a single sheet of stainless steel, eliminating the need for complex multi-material assembly.

Centripetal Pitch Mechanism

To decouple wing pitch from aerodynamics, the authors added a "resonant mass" (a small magnet) to the wing assembly. As the wing sweeps, centripetal force acting on this mass induces a twisting motion (pitch). Because this force is inertial rather than aerodynamic, the wing's pitch becomes largely independent of fluid dynamics, allowing for easier design iterations and post-fabrication tuning.

Figure 1: Physical prototype of the milligram-scale wing mechanism (left) alongside its schematic model (right), highlighting the resonant mass and torsion spring.

Experimental Validation and Results

The design was validated through MATLAB ODE simulations and experimental bench tests using a 100mg mockup. The device was tested at frequencies ranging from 70Hz to 200Hz, successfully achieving a $\pm 60^\circ$ wing stroke and a $\pm 45^\circ$ wing pitch.

A critical aspect of the design is stress management. Using finite element analysis (FEA), the researchers confirmed that the internal stresses within the stainless steel pivots remain well below the material's fatigue limits, even at maximum rotation.

Figure 2: Finite element analysis (FEA) showing von Mises stress distribution across the planar, single-material transmission during operation.

Key Insights

  • Universal Design: The reliance on resonance means the desired wing sweep can be achieved regardless of the specific actuator's displacement, provided the driving frequency matches the system's resonance.
  • Decoupled Physics: Using inertial forces to drive pitch allows researchers to swap wing shapes without redesigning the entire flexure joint.
  • Material Durability: The use of stainless steel provides superior fatigue strength compared to traditional polymers, which is essential for high-frequency flapping.

Conclusion and Future Work

This new approach significantly simplifies the design and fabrication of milligram-scale robots. While current testing has been limited to bench-top mockups, the results demonstrate a robust and tunable platform for future autonomous flyers. Future research may explore the performance of these mechanisms in different fluid environments, such as water, to investigate the potential for micro-underwater vehicles where inertial loading remains dominant.

Summary updated

Abstract

Here we report the construction of the simplest transmission mechanism ever designed capable of converting linear motions of any actuator to $\pm$60$^\circ$ rotary wing stroke motion. It is planar, compliant, can be fabricated in a single step and requires no assembly. Further, its design is universal in nature, that is, it can be used with any linear actuator capable of delivering sufficient power, irrespective of the magnitude of actuator displacements. We also report a novel passive wing pitch mechanism whose motion has little dependence on the aerodynamic loading on the wing. This exponentially simplifies the job of the designer by decoupling the as of yet highly coupled wing morphology, wing kinematics and flexure stiffness parameters. Like the contemporary flexure-based methods it is an add-on to a given wing stroke mechanism. Moreover, the intended wing pitch amplitude could easily be changed post-fabrication by tuning the resonance mass in the mechanism.
BibTeX
@misc{bhushan2019new,
  author = {Palak Bhushan and Claire J. Tomlin},
  title = {{New Wing Stroke and Wing Pitch Approaches for Milligram-scale Aerial Devices}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1908.03422},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1908.03422},
}
Figure