New practices bring new challenges: the psychological experiences and needs of anesthesiologists transitioning to work in the AICU

Jian-Guo Chu, Gao Lin, Lei Xie, Hanqi Zhang, Lei Wang, Yixuan Chen, Kang DengResearch Square 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

As China’s aging population drives a surge in critical care demand, anesthesiologists are increasingly transitioning from the operating room to long-term management in Anesthesia Intensive Care Units (AICUs). This qualitative study reveals that while this shift fosters professional growth and a deeper sense of duty, it also triggers significant "transition shock" characterized by skill gaps, clinical anxiety, and a pressing need for specialized training and equitable compensation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditionally, anesthesiologists operate in a high-intensity but short-term window: the perioperative period. Their expertise is focused on intraoperative stability and immediate post-op recovery. However, to alleviate pressure on general ICUs, many hospitals are establishing AICUs where anesthesiologists must manage critically ill patients over days or weeks.

This shift represents a fundamental change in the scope, target, and mode of work. The authors tackle the "human factor" of this transition: How do these specialists cope with the move from a controlled OR environment to the unpredictable, long-term nature of the ICU? The paper identifies a "competence gap" where traditional anesthesia training falls short in areas like long-term antibiotic use, nutritional support, and complex doctor-patient communication.

Methods

The researchers employed a phenomenological qualitative approach, which focuses on describing the "lived experiences" of a specific group.

  • Participants: 15 anesthesiologists at a tertiary medical center in Zhejiang Province, China, all of whom had recently transitioned to AICU work.
  • Data Collection: Semi-structured, one-on-one interviews lasting 45–60 minutes.
  • Analysis: The team used Colaizzi’s seven-step phenomenological method, a rigorous framework for extracting meaningful themes from raw transcript data. They utilized Nvivo software to manage and code the qualitative data, ensuring that "data saturation" (the point where no new insights emerge) was reached.

Datasets

As a qualitative study, the "dataset" consists of the original interview transcripts from the 15 participants.

  • Participant Characteristics: The cohort included a mix of Resident, Attending, and Associate Chief Physicians, providing a cross-section of experience levels (detailed in Table 1 of the paper).
  • Benchmarks: While there are no "standard benchmarks" in the way a machine learning paper might have, the study references Transition Shock Theory as a theoretical framework to evaluate the psychological responses of the medical staff.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Behind the Scenes" Identity Crisis: Anesthesiologists often view themselves as "behind the scenes" players. Moving to the AICU forces them into "visible" roles where they must lead family meetings and manage long-term patient trajectories, leading to both pride and significant social anxiety.
  • The OR vs. ICU Temporal Gap: In the OR, treatment effects are often immediate. In the ICU, "multiple treatment methods [often] do not lead to improvement," which participants described as a source of emotional defeat and "clinical anxiety."
  • Non-Technical Skill Evolution: Interestingly, the transition significantly improved "humanistic care" capabilities. Participants noted that interacting with conscious patients and their families—rare in the OR—made them more empathetic and better communicators.
  • The "Double Burden" of Research and Clinicals: In the Chinese academic hospital context, the pressure to produce research in a new sub-specialty (where the physician feels like a novice) adds a layer of "role stress" that can lead to burnout.

Key Results

The analysis distilled the experiences into four core themes:

  1. Negative Psychological Experiences: Characterized by "cognitive and skill delays" (e.g., unfamiliarity with long-term anticoagulants or antimicrobials) and the stress of juggling multiple complex patients simultaneously.
  2. Positive Psychological Experiences: A burgeoning "sense of duty" for AICU development and a "sense of professional accomplishment" when patients are successfully discharged back to general wards.
  3. Multidimensional Support: Role adaptation was heavily dependent on "team support reinforcement" (senior doctors stepping in to share responsibility) and "family support."
  4. Systemic Needs: Participants explicitly called for structured pre-employment training (rather than "learning by doing"), equitable remuneration that reflects the higher intensity of ICU work, and streamlined management to reduce the frequency of exhausting night shifts.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study was conducted at a single tertiary hospital, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to smaller or regional facilities. The sample size (15) is standard for qualitative research but does not allow for quantitative statistical power.

Future Directions: The authors suggest multi-center studies across different regions of China to generate more robust, generalizable insights. They also recommend that hospital administrators develop "critical care position allowances" and formal mentorship programs to bridge the transition gap and prevent the "attrition of clinical competencies" among anesthesiologists.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background The global population aging continues to accelerate, also posing significant challenges to Chinese society. The growing geriatric population has substantially increased demand for critical care beds, compelling governmental initiatives to expand specialized Intensive Care Unit (ICU) capacity in addressing this deficit. The establishment of an Anesthesia Intensive Care Unit (AICU) in a comprehensive hospital has effectively alleviated the pressure on the general ICU. However, anesthesiologists have historically lacked sustained experience in prolonged critical care management, as their work was mostly limited to intraoperative and postoperative care management. The change in scope, target, content, and mode of work may have an impact on their physical and mental well-being. This qualitative study employs phenomenological interviewing with AICU anesthesiologists to systematically explore their lived clinical experiences and needs. The findings will provide references for managers to develop appropriate intervention measures. Methods This phenomenological qualitative study was conducted at Jiaxing University Affiliated Hospital, a tertiary academic medical center in Zhejiang Province, China. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 anesthesiologists working in the AICU from January 27, 2025, to March 30, 2025. Participants were recruited through purposive sampling. Interviews lasted 45–60 minutes, with data saturation determined when no new information emerged. Interview data were analyzed using Colaizzi's seven-step phenomenological method. Results Four core themes with twelve subthemes emerged from the analysis: (1) Negative psychological experiences, including sub-themes of "Challenges from cognitive and skill delays", "clinical anxiety during patient deterioration management", "stress from changing duties", and "impacts of research, administrative, and family roles";(2) Positive psychological experiences, including sub-themes of " sense of duty for AICU development ", "increased sense of professional accomplishment", "enhanced professional capabilities", and "strengthened non-technical skills"༛(3) Diversified support facilitates role adaptation, including sub-themes of "self-support", " team support reinforcement" ,and " family support engagement"(4) Needs and aspirations, including sub-themes of "improved training", "higher remuneration", and "streamlined management". Conclusion The transition of anesthesiologists to roles in the AICU is a complex and demanding process. This highlights the importance of hospital and departmental management in addressing the psychological challenges and needs faced by healthcare professionals during this shift. Efforts should be made to strengthen training, refine management systems, ensure equitable compensation, and foster a sense of professional identity and belonging. Such measures are essential for improving staff well-being and, ultimately, enhancing the quality of care.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chu2025new,
  author = {Jian-Guo Chu and Gao Lin and Lei Xie and Hanqi Zhang and Lei Wang and Yixuan Chen and Kang Deng},
  title = {{New practices bring new challenges: the psychological experiences and needs of anesthesiologists transitioning to work in the AICU}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-6864401/v1},
}
Figure