New Particles Working Group Report of the Snowmass 2013 Community Summer Study

Y. Gershtein, Markus A. Luty, M. Narain, L. T. Wang, D. Whiteson, Kaustubh Agashe, L. Apanasevich, G. Artoni, A. Avetisyan, Howard Baer, Christoph Bartels, Martin Bauer, D. Berge, M. Berggren, S. Bhattacharya, K. Black, T. Bose, J. E. Brau, R. Brock, E. Brownson, M. Cahill-Rowley, Adalet Çakir, A. Chaus, Timothy Cohen, Baradhwaj Coleppa, Randel Cotta, Nathaniel Craig, Keith R. Dienes, Bogdan A. Dobrescu, D. Duggan, Rouven Essig, Jared A. Evans, A. Drlica-Wagner, S. Funk, J. George, F. Goertz, T. Golling, Tao Han, A. Haas, M. Hance, Daniel Hayden, Ulrich Heintz, A. Henrichs, JoAnne L. Hewett, James Hirschauer, Kimberly Howe, Ameen Ismail, K. Kaadze, Yevgeny Kats, Felix Kling, D. Kolchmeyer, D. Krücker, Kimsreng Kong, Abhishek Kumar, Graham D. Kribs, Paul Langacker, A. Lath, Seung J. Lee, Jenny List, Tongyan Lin, L. Linssen, T. Liu, Zhen Liu, A. Lobanov, Joshua Loyal, A. Martin, Isabell Melzer-Pellmann, Mihoko M. Nojiri, S. Padhi, N. Parashar, B. Penning, Maxim Perelstein, Michael E. Peskin, Aaron Pierce, W. Porod, C. T. Potter, Thomas G. Rizzo, G. Sciolla, J. Stupak, Shi-Quan Su, Tim M. P. Tait, T. Tanabe, Bruno Thomas, Scott Thomas, Sumit Kumar Upadhyay, N. Varelas, E. W. Varnes, Luca Vecchi, A. Venturini, B. Vormwald, Jochen Wacker, M. Walker, M. Wood, G. B. Yu, N. ZhouarXiv 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This report summarizes the work of the Energy Frontier New Physics working group of the 2013 Community Summer Study (Snowmass). It outlines the strategic landscape for discovering new particles beyond the Standard Model, evaluating how current and proposed facilities—ranging from the High-Luminosity LHC to a 100 TeV "super-collider" and high-precision lepton colliders—complement each other to solve the universe's biggest mysteries.

Introduction: The Post-Higgs Era

The 2012 discovery of the Higgs boson completed the Standard Model (SM) but left fundamental questions unanswered. The SM fails to account for dark matter, the matter-antimatter asymmetry, and the "naturalness" of the Higgs mass (the Hierarchy Problem). The New Particles Working Group was tasked with defining a roadmap for the next 20–30 years of high-energy physics, identifying where new physics might be hiding—whether at extreme energy scales or within weakly interacting "hidden" sectors.

Mapping theoretical frameworks to fundamental physics questions.

Methodology and Facilities

The report employs a "Discovery Stories" approach, simulating how specific theories like Supersymmetry (SUSY), Composite Higgs, and Extra Dimensions would manifest across future collider benchmarks. Using fast simulation tools like DELPHES, the authors calculated 95% confidence level exclusion limits and 5$\sigma$ discovery reaches.

The analysis considers several proposed facility benchmarks:

  • High-Luminosity LHC (HL-LHC): 14 TeV at 3000 $fb^{-1}$.
  • High-Energy LHC (HE-LHC): A proposed 33 TeV upgrade.
  • Very Large Hadron Collider (VLHC): A 100 TeV proton-proton (pp) collider.
  • Lepton Colliders ($e^+e^-$): ILC, CLIC, and TLEP, ranging from 250 GeV to 3 TeV.

Key Insights: Complementarity and Robustness

A central theme is the complementarity between hadron and lepton colliders. Hadron colliders are "discovery machines" with massive energy reach but suffer from "blind spots" in "compressed spectra" scenarios where new particles are nearly degenerate in mass with dark matter candidates. Conversely, lepton colliders act as "scalpels," providing a clean environment to detect weakly interacting particles like Higgsinos that are often lost in the noise of proton collisions.

Furthermore, a 100 TeV collider is identified as a "robust" tool. It can push the search for WIMP dark matter into the TeV mass scale, potentially providing a definitive test for several major classes of dark matter theories.

Experimental Reach and Results

The projected mass reach for various new particles varies significantly by facility. For Supersymmetry, the HL-LHC can extend the reach for squarks and gluinos to approximately 2.5 TeV, while a 100 TeV machine could push this to 15–20 TeV. In the search for new gauge bosons ($Z'$), a 100 TeV collider could discover force carriers with masses up to 30 TeV.

Comparison of mass reach for SUSY and non-SUSY particles across different collider scenarios.

Lepton colliders contribute by measuring Higgs couplings to sub-percent precision. This allows for the detection of "fingerprints" of new physics, such as Higgs compositeness, even if the associated new particles are beyond the direct production threshold of the collider.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the roadmap is ambitious, it faces challenges. Most projections are model-dependent; if new physics resides in highly "hidden" sectors, current strategies may need adjustment. Additionally, realizing the HL-LHC's potential requires significant improvements in managing theoretical backgrounds and detector systematics. Ultimately, the choice between the "brute force" of a 100 TeV hadron collider and the "surgical precision" of a high-energy lepton collider will define the next frontier of particle physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

This report summarizes the work of the Energy Frontier New Physics working group of the 2013 Community Summer Study (Snowmass).
BibTeX
@misc{gershtein2013new,
  author = {Y. Gershtein and Markus A. Luty and M. Narain and L. T. Wang and D. Whiteson and Kaustubh Agashe and L. Apanasevich and G. Artoni and A. Avetisyan and Howard Baer and Christoph Bartels and Martin Bauer and D. Berge and M. Berggren and S. Bhattacharya and K. Black and T. Bose and J. E. Brau and R. Brock and E. Brownson and M. Cahill-Rowley and Adalet Çakir and A. Chaus and Timothy Cohen and Baradhwaj Coleppa and Randel Cotta and Nathaniel Craig and Keith R. Dienes and Bogdan A. Dobrescu and D. Duggan and Rouven Essig and Jared A. Evans and A. Drlica-Wagner and S. Funk and J. George and F. Goertz and T. Golling and Tao Han and A. Haas and M. Hance and Daniel Hayden and Ulrich Heintz and A. Henrichs and JoAnne L. Hewett and James Hirschauer and Kimberly Howe and Ameen Ismail and K. Kaadze and Yevgeny Kats and Felix Kling and D. Kolchmeyer and D. Krücker and KIMSRENG KONG and Abhishek Kumar and Graham D. Kribs and Paul Langacker and A. Lath and Seung J. Lee and Jenny List and Tongyan Lin and L. Linssen and T. Liu and Zhen Liu and A. Lobanov and Joshua Loyal and A. Martin and Isabell Melzer-Pellmann and Mihoko M. Nojiri and S. Padhi and N. Parashar and B. Penning and Maxim Perelstein and Michael E. Peskin and Aaron Pierce and W. Porod and C. T. Potter and Thomas G. Rizzo and G. Sciolla and J. Stupak and Shi-Quan Su and Tim M. P. Tait and T. Tanabe and Bruno Thomas and Scott Thomas and Sumit Kumar Upadhyay and N. Varelas and E. W. Varnes and Luca Vecchi and A. Venturini and B. Vormwald and Jochen Wacker and M. Walker and M. Wood and G. B. Yu and N. Zhou},
  title = {{New Particles Working Group Report of the Snowmass 2013 Community Summer Study}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1311.0299},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1311.0299},
}
Figure