New ovulate cupule further informs the relationships among early seed plants and their adaptation to wind pollination

Bingxin Li, Pu Huang, Le Liu, Jia-Shu Wang, Karl J. Niklas, Deming Wang, Jinzhuang XueProceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Zaijunia biloba, a newly discovered fossil seed plant from the Late Devonian, shedding light on the early evolution of seed plants and their adaptation to wind pollination. Computational fluid dynamics simulations reveal how the unique cupule structure of Zaijunia and related species enhanced airborne pollen capture, suggesting wind pollination efficiency was a key driver of early seed plant diversification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid diversification of early seed plants during the Late Devonian (Famennian) remains a significant evolutionary puzzle. While the emergence of the seed habit itself was a major innovation, the specific mechanisms driving this diversification are not fully understood. One hypothesis is that adaptations related to reproduction, particularly pollination, played a crucial role. However, direct evidence for how these early plants captured pollen, especially in the absence of widespread insect pollinators, has been limited. This paper tackles this gap by describing a new fossil species with unique reproductive structures and using advanced simulations to explore its pollination strategy.

Methods

The study employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • Paleontological Description: A new genus and species, Zaijunia biloba, is described based on a substantial collection of fossil specimens. This involves detailed morphological analysis of its vegetative and reproductive structures, including the cupulate ovules.
  • Micro-X-ray Fluorescence (µ-XRF) Spectroscopy: This technique was used to analyze the elemental composition of ovules, helping to differentiate between nucellus traces and integumentary tissues, providing insights into ovule structure.
  • Morphometric Analysis: Quantitative measurements of cupules and ovules were taken, and statistical analyses (e.g., Principal Component Analysis) were used to study shape variation and growth patterns.
  • Three-Dimensional (3D) Virtual Modeling and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Simulation: Digital models of Zaijunia, Pseudosporogonites, and Elkinsia ovules were created. CFD simulations were then performed to model airflow patterns around these structures, specifically to assess their efficiency in capturing airborne pollen. This method allows for a dynamic understanding of how the morphology influenced aerodynamic interactions.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: Existing phylogenetic data was utilized and modified to determine the evolutionary placement of Zaijunia within the broader context of early seed plants.

Datasets

  • Fossil Specimens: Approximately 250 specimens of Zaijunia biloba were collected from the Leigutai Member of the Wutong Formation in South China. These specimens form the basis for the morphological descriptions and 3D modeling.
  • Existing Phylogenetic Data: A data matrix from Rothwell & Stockey [25] was used and modified for phylogenetic analysis, incorporating 111 characters and 40 taxa, including progymnosperms, hydrasperman seed plants, and other early seed ferns.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Novel Evolutionary Pathway: The paired, bilobed cupule structure of Zaijunia is proposed as a potential precursor to more complex cupulate ovules found in later seed plants like Elkinsia. The duplication of a bi-ovulate fertile unit in Zaijunia could have been a key step in the early diversification of seed plants.
  • Aerodynamic Advantage of Cupules: The study provides strong evidence that cupules and lobed integuments were not merely protective structures but actively influenced airflow. This aerodynamic modification created low-velocity regions that enhanced the capture of airborne pollen.
  • Wind Pollination as a Driver of Diversification: The findings strongly suggest that efficient wind pollination was a significant factor contributing to the rapid radiation of early seed plants. This adaptation allowed them to colonize a wider range of habitats.
  • Morphological Diversity Driven by Function: The paper highlights how variations in cupule and integument morphology among different early seed plant groups (e.g., Zaijunia, Pseudosporogonites, Elkinsia) led to distinct aerodynamic profiles, each with varying degrees of pollen capture efficiency.

Key Results

  • Discovery of Zaijunia biloba: A new genus and species of hydrasperman seed plant with unique ovulate cupules was described, dating back to the Late Devonian (Famennian).
  • CFD Simulation Outcomes:
    • Simulations showed that Zaijunia's paired ovules, particularly when one was upwind of the other, created significant airflow disturbances that reduced air velocity by up to 91% for the downwind ovule, greatly enhancing pollen capture.
  • Elkinsia, with its more complex cupule structure, demonstrated even greater aerodynamic efficiency, reducing air velocity by 80-99% and being less sensitive to wind direction.
  • Pseudosporogonites, with a simpler cupule, showed less pronounced effects on airflow.
  • Phylogenetic Placement: Zaijunia was resolved as a sister group to Elkinsia, reinforcing their close evolutionary relationship and supporting the idea of Zaijunia's structure as a foundational element for more derived forms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reconstruction of the Entire Plant: The study acknowledges that the complete plant architecture of Zaijunia is not fully reconstructed, which could influence assumptions about ovule orientation relative to gravity. However, they argue this has minimal impact on airflow patterns at high speeds.
  • Mechanical Properties of Stems: The CFD simulations did not account for the potential mechanical behavior (e.g., oscillations) of the long, slender stems that bore the ovulate structures. Future work could incorporate these factors for a more comprehensive aerodynamic model.
  • Pollination Droplets: The absence of evidence for pollination droplets in these early seed plants means that the potential role of such mechanisms in pollen capture remains unclear and could be a subject for future investigation.
  • Further Validation of CFD: While the CFD parameters were validated against wind tunnel experiments, further experimental validation with physical models of these specific fossil structures would strengthen the findings.
  • Evolutionary Scenarios: The paper proposes scenarios for cupule evolution (e.g., duplication of fertile units, fusion of pre-existing systems). Further fossil discoveries and detailed anatomical studies could help refine these hypotheses.

Summary updated

Abstract

The earliest seed plants occurred in the Late Devonian (Famennian). However, why and how they rapidly diversified remain long-standing mysteries. We investigated the early evolution of seed plants based on a new ovule and evaluated wind pollination performance of the earliest cupulate ovules by using computational fluid dynamics simulations. <i>Zaijunia biloba</i> gen. et sp. nov. is described from the Upper Devonian (Famennian) of South China and shows canonical hydrasperman-type ovules with lobed integuments and a complex nucellar apex. <i>Zaijunia</i> bears ovules in pairs, each ovule within a lateral bilobed cupule. We propose that duplication of the bi-ovulate fertile unit of <i>Zaijunia</i> could produce more complex derivative cupulate ovules, as an evolutionary pathway leading to the early diversification of seeds. We performed computational fluid dynamics simulations of <i>Zaijunia</i> and two other early seed plants (i.e. <i>Pseudosporogonites</i> and <i>Elkinsia</i>), demonstrating that their fertile units improve airborne (pre)pollen capture efficiency. This study sheds additional light on the evolution of cupulate ovules and their potential adaptations to anemophily, as one of the factors driving the earliest radiation of seed plants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025new,
  author = {Bingxin Li and Pu Huang and Le Liu and Jia-Shu Wang and Karl J. Niklas and Deming Wang and Jinzhuang Xue},
  title = {{New ovulate cupule further informs the relationships among early seed plants and their adaptation to wind pollination}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1098/rspb.2024.2940},
}
Figure