New methodological approaches to surgical treatment of gastroduodenal ulcers

В. А. Кузнецов, B. L. Elyashevich, A. F. Ageev, Igor FedorovKazan 1989 · DOI

Abstract

We analyzed the experience of surgical treatment of 2000 patients with peptic ulcer since 1965. The main result of the study can be reduced to two main statements: 1) the problem of surgical treatment of gastroduodenal ulcers cannot be solved by a single unified surgical technique; 2) further progress in surgical treatment of gastroduodenal ulcers should be expected in the way of objectification of indications for early surgery, intensification of preoperative preparation, improvement of methodical approaches to surgical interventions and their technical solution.

Introduction

Since the mid-1960s, the surgical management of gastroduodenal ulcers has undergone a significant paradigm shift. Historically, radical resections like the Billroth-II procedure were applied as a "unified" solution. However, clinical data from over 2,000 cases treated at the Kazan Institute for Advanced Training of Physicians suggests that this approach often overlooks individual physiological variations, leading to high rates of post-operative complications. This paper outlines a transition toward individualized, organ-preserving interventions designed to mitigate risks such as dumping syndrome and suture line failure.

Addressing Chronic Duodenal Obstruction (CDO)

A primary driver of surgical failure in traditional resections is Chronic Duodenal Obstruction (CDO). When the anatomical and functional state of the duodenum is ignored, poor drainage results in recurring symptoms and internal bleeding (observed in 2.6% of standard cases). To address this, we emphasize the need for surgical techniques that account for the specific clinical form of the disease rather than adhering to a rigid standard.

Methodological Innovations

Pre-operative Endoscopic Preparation

In a subset of 300 patients, local transendoscopic treatments, including novocaine injections, were utilized to stimulate ulcer healing before definitive surgery. This approach successfully increased healing rates of resistant ulcers to 86.6% and reduced average hospital stays by more than 22 days.

The Short-Loop Anastomosis

To prevent the formation of a "blind loop" and ensure optimal drainage, we developed a novel anisoperistaltic gastroenteroanastomosis using a maximally short loop. This technical refinement prevents mechanical kinking and stagnation, which are common precursors to post-operative syndromes.

Technical detail of the short-loop gastroenteroanastomosis designed to improve drainage and prevent stagnation.

The Three-Component Operation

For complex cases, we propose a three-component approach combining suprapyloric exclusion, selective vagotomy, and short-loop anastomosis. Selective vagotomy involves severing specific gastric nerves to reduce acid production while preserving overall organ function, addressing the underlying pathology without the morbidity of total resection.

Schematic of the three-component operation, illustrating the integration of selective vagotomy with gastric resection.

Clinical Results and Discussion

The implementation of these refined techniques between 1972 and 1978 yielded "excellent or good" results in 76% of the patient cohort. Mortality rates remained low at 1.1%. Notably, the incidence of duodenal stump leaks was drastically reduced—occurring in only 4 out of 308 monitored patients—demonstrating the stability of the mechanical suturing and short-loop techniques.

While selective proximal vagotomy (SPV) is a valuable tool, our findings indicate it should often be a component of a broader resection strategy rather than a standalone procedure, particularly in patients with severe hyperchlorhydria.

Conclusion

The future of gastroduodenal surgery lies in the "objectification" of indications. By moving away from a unified surgical model and toward individualized, methodologically sound interventions, surgeons can significantly improve patient outcomes and reduce the long-term burden of post-operative complications.

Summary updated

Abstract

We analyzed the experience of surgical treatment of 2000 patients with peptic ulcer since 1965. The main result of the study can be reduced to two main statements:
 1) the problem of surgical treatment of gastroduodenal ulcers cannot be solved by a single unified surgical technique;
 2) further progress in surgical treatment of gastroduodenal ulcers should be expected in the way of objectification of indications for early surgery, intensification of preoperative preparation, improvement of methodical approaches to surgical interventions and their technical solution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{1989new,
  author = {В. А. Кузнецов and B. L. Elyashevich and A. F. Ageev and Igor Fedorov},
  title = {{New methodological approaches to surgical treatment of gastroduodenal ulcers}},
  booktitle = {Kazan},
  year = {1989},
  doi = {10.17816/kazmj101573},
}
Figure