New Measurements of Cabibbo-Suppressed Decays of<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>D</mml:mi></mml:math>Mesons with the CLEO-c Detector

P. Rubin, C. Cawlfield, B. I. Eisenstein, I. Karliner, D. Kim, N. Lowrey, P. Naik, C. Sedlack, M. Selen, E. J. White, J. Wiss, M. R. Shepherd, D. Besson, T. K. Pedlar, D. Cronin-Hennessy, K. Y. Gao, D. T. Gong, J. Hietala, Y. Kubota, T. Klein, B. W. Lang, R. Poling, A. W. Scott, A. Smith, S. Dobbs, Z. Metreveli, K. K. Seth, A. Tomaradze, P. Zweber, J. Ernst, H. Severini, S. A. Dytman, W. A. Love, S. Mehrabyan, V. Savinov, O. Aquines Gutierrez, Z. Li, A. Lopez, H. Méndez, J. E. Ramirez Vargas, B. Xin, G. S. Huang, D. H. Miller, V. Pavlunin, B. Sanghi, I. P. J. Shipsey, G. S. Adams, Mark Anderson, J. P. Cummings, I. Danko, J. Napolitano, Q. He, J. Insler, H. Muramatsu, C. S. Park, E. H. Thorndike, T. E. Coan, Y. S. Gao, F. Liu, R. Stroynowski, M. Artuso, S. Blusk, J. Butt, J. Li, N. Menaa, R. Mountain, S. Nisar, K. Randrianarivony, R. Redjimi, R. Sia, T. Skwarnicki, S. Stone, J. C. Wang, K. Zhang, S. E. Csorna, G. Bonvicini, D. Cinabro, M. Dubrovin, A. Lincoln, D. M. Asner, K. W. Edwards, R. A. Briere, I. Brock, J. Chen, T. Ferguson, G. Tatishvili, H. Vogel, M. E. Watkins, J. L. Rosner, N. E. Adam, J. Alexander, K. Berkelman, D. G. Cassel, J. E. Duboscq, K. M. Ecklund, R. Ehrlich, L. Fields, L. Gibbons, R. Gray, S. W. GrayPhysical 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Using data collected with the CLEO-c detector, we report on first observations and measurements of Cabibbo-suppressed decays of $D$ mesons in six decay modes: $\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\pi^0$, $\pi^+\pi^+\pi^-\pi^-\pi^0$, $\pi^+\pi^0\pi^0$, $\pi^+\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0$, $\eta\pi^0$, and $\omega\pi^+\pi^-$. Improved branching fraction measurements in eight other multipion decay modes are also presented. The measured $D \to \pi\pi$ rates allow us to extract the ratio of isospin amplitudes $A(\Delta I = 3/2) / A(\Delta I = 1/2) = 0.420 \pm 0.014(\text{stat}) \pm 0.016(\text{syst})$ and the strong phase shift of $\delta_I = (86.4 \pm 2.8 \pm 3.3)^\circ$, which is quite large and now more precisely determined.

Introduction: Probing the Weak Force via $D$ Mesons

In the Standard Model of particle physics, quarks change flavor through the weak interaction. However, calculating these processes is notoriously difficult because the strong force (QCD) creates a complex environment where particles interact with each other after the initial decay—a phenomenon called Final State Interactions (FSI).

This study focuses on Cabibbo-suppressed decays of $D$ mesons. These specific decay paths are statistically less likely to occur than "favored" decays, making them sensitive probes for testing our understanding of the weak force and CP violation (the difference between matter and antimatter). Before this study, data on multi-pion decays of $D$ mesons was either non-existent or lacked the precision needed to constrain theoretical models.

Experimental Methods and Datasets

The analysis utilized 281 pb⁻¹ of data collected by the CLEO-c detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring (CESR). The experiment collided electrons and positrons at the $\psi(3770)$ resonance, which acts as a "$D$ factory," producing pairs of $D$ and $\bar{D}$ mesons in a clean, coherent state.

To separate signal from background, researchers used two primary kinematic variables:

  • $\Delta E$: The difference between the measured energy of the $D$ candidate and the beam energy.
  • $M_{bc}$ (Beam-constrained mass): The mass calculated using the beam energy and the measured momentum of the $D$ candidate.

A major challenge was filtering out "Cabibbo-favored" decays involving $K_S^0$ mesons, which look similar to target pion decays but occur 5–10 times more often. The team implemented a strict invariant mass veto to mitigate this background. Additionally, they looked for intermediate resonances like $\eta$ and $\omega$ mesons to understand the internal dynamics of the decay.

Key Results and Physical Insights

The paper reports the first-ever observations of six specific decay modes. The beam-constrained mass distributions for various $D^0$ modes are shown below, demonstrating clear signal peaks at the $D^0$ mass (~1.86 GeV/$c^2$).

Beam-constrained mass distributions for various $D^0$ decay modes showing clear signal peaks.

Isospin and Strong Phase Shifts

By comparing the rates of different $D \to \pi\pi$ decays, the authors could separate the decay into different isospin components ($I=1/2$ and $I=3/2$). This technique helps peel back the layers of the strong force. A major finding was the measurement of a strong phase shift ($\delta_I$) of approximately 86.4°. In a world without final-state interactions, this number would be near zero. A value so close to 90° indicates that the pions are interacting very strongly with each other as they fly away from the decay point.

Branching Fraction Summary

The study provides a wealth of new branching fractions ($\mathcal{B}$), which represent the probability of a specific decay occurring. For instance, the branching fraction for $D^0 \to \pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\pi^0$ was measured at $(9.9 \pm 0.6 \pm 0.7 \pm 0.2 \pm 0.1) \times 10^{-3}$.

Summary of measured branching fractions for $D^0$ and $D^+$ modes compared with PDG values.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While this paper significantly improves the precision of $D$ meson data, some submodes (particularly those involving $\eta$ and $\omega$ mesons) still suffer from limited statistics. These results are a foundational stepping stone; precise measurements of these Cabibbo-suppressed modes are essential for extracting the CKM angle $\gamma$ in $B$ meson decays, a key to understanding why our universe is made of matter instead of antimatter. Future runs with larger datasets from experiments like BESIII or Belle II will build directly on this work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using of data collected with the CLEO-c detector, we report on first observations and measurements of Cabibbo-suppressed decays of D mesons in the following six decay modes: pi+ pi- pi0 pi0, pi+ pi+ pi- pi- pi0, pi+ pi0 pi0, pi+ pi+ pi- pi0, eta pi0, and omega pi+ pi-. Improved branching fraction measurements in eight other multipion decay modes are also presented. The measured D --> pi pi rates allow us to extract the ratio of isospin amplitudes A(DeltaI = (3/2) / A(DeltaI = (1/2)) = 0.420 +/- 0.014(stat) +/- 0.016(syst) and the strong phase shift of delta1 = (86.4 +/- 2.8 +/- 3.3) degrees, which is quite large and now more precisely determined.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rubin2006new,
  author = {P. Rubin and C. Cawlfield and B. I. Eisenstein and I. Karliner and D. Kim and N. Lowrey and P. Naik and C. Sedlack and M. Selen and E. J. White and J. Wiss and M. R. Shepherd and D. Besson and T. K. Pedlar and D. Cronin-Hennessy and K. Y. Gao and D. T. Gong and J. Hietala and Y. Kubota and T. Klein and B. W. Lang and R. Poling and A. W. Scott and A. Smith and S. Dobbs and Z. Metreveli and K. K. Seth and A. Tomaradze and P. Zweber and J. Ernst and H. Severini and S. A. Dytman and W. A. Love and S. Mehrabyan and V. Savinov and O. Aquines Gutierrez and Z. Li and A. Lopez and H. Méndez and J. E. Ramirez Vargas and B. Xin and G. S. Huang and D. H. Miller and V. Pavlunin and B. Sanghi and I. P. J. Shipsey and G. S. Adams and Mark Anderson and J. P. Cummings and I. Danko and J. Napolitano and Q. He and J. Insler and H. Muramatsu and C. S. Park and E. H. Thorndike and T. E. Coan and Y. S. Gao and F. Liu and R. Stroynowski and M. Artuso and S. Blusk and J. Butt and J. Li and N. Menaa and R. Mountain and S. Nisar and K. Randrianarivony and R. Redjimi and R. Sia and T. Skwarnicki and S. Stone and J. C. Wang and K. Zhang and S. E. Csorna and G. Bonvicini and D. Cinabro and M. Dubrovin and A. Lincoln and D. M. Asner and K. W. Edwards and R. A. Briere and I. Brock and J. Chen and T. Ferguson and G. Tatishvili and H. Vogel and M. E. Watkins and J. L. Rosner and N. E. Adam and J. Alexander and K. Berkelman and D. G. Cassel and J. E. Duboscq and K. M. Ecklund and R. Ehrlich and L. Fields and L. Gibbons and R. Gray and S. W. Gray},
  title = {{New Measurements of Cabibbo-Suppressed Decays of<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>D</mml:mi></mml:math>Mesons with the CLEO-c Detector}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.96.081802},
}
Figure