TL;DR
This paper presents a comprehensive study of Y(1S) decays into charmonium final states, utilizing a significantly larger dataset than previous experiments. The findings offer crucial insights into the production mechanisms of charmonium, particularly highlighting a softer-than-expected momentum spectrum for J/ψ mesons and revealing unexpectedly large feed-down contributions from excited states. These results challenge existing theoretical models and pave the way for more refined understanding of quantum chromodynamics (QCD) in glue-rich environments.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding how charmonium (bound states of a charm quark and a charm antiquark, like J/ψ and ψ(2S)) is produced in high-energy particle collisions has been a long-standing challenge in particle physics. While theoretical frameworks like Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) describe these interactions, discrepancies arise, especially in "glue-rich" environments where gluons (the force carriers of the strong interaction) play a dominant role. Early experiments observed charmonium production rates that were much higher than theoretical predictions, leading to the development of the "color-octet mechanism." This mechanism suggests that charmonium can be produced indirectly through a color-octet intermediate state, which then evolves into a color-singlet state.
However, this mechanism, while explaining production rates, has faced challenges in accurately predicting other properties, such as the momentum distribution and polarization of the produced charmonium particles. Furthermore, the Y(1S) meson, a bound state of a bottom quark and antiquark, is a particularly interesting "factory" for studying charmonium production because its decay is rich in gluons. This paper aims to provide much-needed precise measurements of Y(1S) decays into charmonium states to test and refine these theoretical models, particularly by examining the momentum spectrum, production angles, and branching fractions of various charmonium decay products.
Methods
The CLEO III detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring (CESR) was used to collect data. The analysis focuses on a large sample of Y(1S) decays, approximately 35 times larger than previous CLEO datasets. Key methods include:
- Event Selection: Rigorous criteria were applied to identify J/ψ candidates (decaying into either muon or electron pairs) and other charmonium states like ψ(2S) and XcJ. This involved filtering out background events from various sources, such as radiative Bhabha scattering and continuum production.
- Invariant Mass Reconstruction: The invariant mass of dilepton pairs (for J/ψ) and dilepton-photon combinations (for XcJ) was reconstructed to identify the desired particles.
- Momentum Spectrum Analysis: The momentum of the J/ψ mesons was analyzed using a scaled momentum variable, $x = P_{J/\psi}/P_{max}$, to remove beam-energy dependence and facilitate comparisons.
- Angular Distribution Analysis: The polar production angle of the J/ψ and its helicity angle were studied to probe the underlying production mechanisms.
- Branching Fraction Measurement: Branching fractions for various decay modes were measured, often relative to the Y(1S) → J/ψ + X branching fraction, to reduce systematic uncertainties.
- Feed-down Analysis: Contributions from the decay of excited charmonium states (like ψ(2S) and XcJ) into J/ψ were quantified.
- Cross-checks: Measurements were cross-checked using data from B-meson decays to validate the analysis procedures and detector simulation.
Datasets
- Primary Dataset: 21.2 × 10⁶ Y(1S) decays collected by the CLEO III detector.
- Background Determination Datasets:
- 5.0 fb⁻¹ of data on the Y(4S) resonance (approximately 10.4 million B-meson decays).
- 2.3 fb⁻¹ of data just below the Y(4S) resonance (around 10.56 GeV).
- Simulation Data: PYTHIA Monte Carlo simulations were used for detector acceptance, analysis requirements, and background modeling.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Softer J/ψ Momentum Spectrum: The measured momentum spectrum of J/ψ mesons from Y(1S) decays is significantly softer than predicted by the color-octet model, which expects a peak near the kinematic limit. This suggests that current theoretical descriptions of charmonium production in Y(1S) decays may be incomplete.
- Unexpectedly Large Feed-down Contributions: The observed feed-down contributions from ψ(2S) and XcJ states to J/ψ are considerably larger than predicted by both color-octet and color-singlet models. This indicates that these higher-mass charmonium states play a more significant role in populating the J/ψ state than previously thought.
- Potential for Color-Singlet Dominance: While the color-octet mechanism was initially invoked to explain high production rates, the softer momentum spectrum observed here aligns better with some aspects of color-singlet predictions, particularly when considering parton-level calculations and hadronization effects.
- New Observations: The paper reports the first observation of Y(1S) → ψ(2S) + X and provides evidence for Y(1S) → XcJ + X decays, offering new channels to probe charmonium production.
Key Results
- Y(1S) → J/ψ + X Branching Fraction: The averaged branching fraction is measured to be (6.4 ± 0.4(stat) ± 0.6(syst)) × 10⁻⁴. This is consistent with both color-octet and color-singlet theoretical predictions.
- Y(1S) → ψ(2S) + X Branching Fraction: Measured relative to B(Y(1S) → J/ψ + X), this ratio is 0.41 ± 0.11(stat) ± 0.08(syst). The feed-down contribution of ψ(2S) to J/ψ is (24±6±5)%.
- Y(1S) → XcJ + X Branching Fractions:
- X c1: 0.35 ± 0.08(stat) ± 0.06(syst) relative to B(Y(1S) → J/ψ + X). Feed-down to J/ψ is (11±3±2)%.
- X c2: 0.52 ± 0.12(stat) ± 0.09(syst) relative to B(Y(1S) → J/ψ + X). Feed-down to J/ψ is (10±2±2)%.
- X c0: An upper limit of <7.4 at 90% confidence level.
- J/ψ Momentum Spectrum: The spectrum peaks around $x \approx 0.3$, significantly softer than the color-octet prediction.
- Angular Distributions: The J/ψ mesons exhibit a significant longitudinal polarization component.
Limitations and Future Work
- Theoretical Model Discrepancies: The observed softer momentum spectrum and larger feed-down contributions highlight limitations in current theoretical models, particularly the color-octet mechanism. The authors suggest that incorporating non-perturbative effects like Soft-Collinear Effective Theory (SCET) might help reconcile these discrepancies.
- Limited Statistics for Xc0: The lack of a significant signal for Y(1S) → Xc0 + X means only an upper limit could be placed, limiting detailed studies of this state.
- Future Directions: The paper suggests that further theoretical work on color-octet and color-singlet mechanisms, especially incorporating non-perturbative effects and hadronization, is needed. Experimental efforts could focus on measuring similar ratios in proton-proton collisions and exploring the production of open charm in Y(1S) decays. The findings also motivate further investigation into the unexpectedly large open charm production observed by other experiments.
Summary updated