New in situ solid-state NMR strategies for exploring materials formation and adsorption processes: prospects in heterogenous catalysis

Kenneth D. HarrisApplied Petrochemical Research 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Solid-state NMR spectroscopy is a powerful technique for studying structural and dynamic properties of solids and has considerable potential to be exploited for in situ studies of chemical processes. However, adapting solid-state NMR techniques and instrumentation for in situ applications are often associated with technical challenges, and for this reason, the opportunities remain underexploited. This paper highlights two experimental strategies that we have developed in recent years for in situ solid-state NMR investigations of solid-state processes. One technique is focused on probing details of the time evolution of materials formation processes, and the other technique is focused on understanding the time evolution of adsorption processes in microporous and mesoporous solid host materials. Each of these in situ solid-state NMR techniques has significant prospects for applications in areas relating to heterogeneous catalysis.

Introduction

Solid-state NMR (ssNMR) is a premier technique for characterizing the local atomic environments in solid materials. However, performing measurements in situ—while a chemical reaction or physical process is actively occurring—presents significant mechanical challenges. High-resolution ssNMR typically requires Magic Angle Spinning (MAS), where samples are spun at frequencies between 3,000 and 15,000 Hz inside a narrow magnetic bore. Traditionally, this has forced researchers to rely on ex situ "stop-motion" studies, which often miss transient intermediate states critical to understanding materials formation or catalytic cycles.

This paper introduces two innovative strategies to overcome these hurdles, allowing researchers to observe adsorption and crystallization processes in real-time inside the spectrometer.

Experimental Strategies

The "Capillary Trigger" for Adsorption

To study the interaction between liquids and porous solids (such as zeolites), a "capillary trigger" mechanism was developed. In this setup, the porous solid is packed into the NMR rotor. A thin-walled glass capillary containing the liquid reagent is then inserted into the center of the solid matrix.

Schematic of the in situ NMR strategy for studying adsorption processes using a capillary trigger.

As the rotor reaches the required MAS speeds, the centrifugal force shatters the fragile capillary, releasing the liquid. This effectively "starts the clock" for the adsorption process exactly as the NMR measurement begins, providing a clear temporal origin for kinetic studies.

CLASSIC NMR for Crystallization

For studying materials forming from solution, the challenge lies in preventing leaks during high-speed spinning. The authors utilize specialized sealed rotors to keep liquids contained. They employ a technique known as CLASSIC NMR (Combined Liquid- And Solid-State In situ Crystallization NMR). This approach involves alternating between pulse sequences optimized for liquids and those optimized for solids. By doing so, researchers can simultaneously monitor the depletion of the liquid phase and the emergence of specific solid crystalline polymorphs.

Case Studies and Key Insights

The efficacy of these techniques was demonstrated through several molecular systems used to validate the temporal resolution and sensitivity of the methods:

  • Hydration of H-ZSM-5 Zeolite: Using the capillary trigger, the team tracked the hydration of this common industrial catalyst over a 16-hour window. A key finding was that water does not coat the acid sites uniformly. Instead, it forms clusters (averaging 5.4 molecules) at specific Brønsted acid sites, leaving others dry. This non-uniformity is vital for understanding competitive adsorption in catalysis.
  • Glycine Crystallization: The CLASSIC NMR method allowed for the real-time identification of glycine polymorphs (α, β, and γ) based on distinct $^{13}C$ chemical shifts. The researchers observed that even minor isotopic changes (such as 1% deuteration) could significantly shift the preference toward the γ-polymorph.
  • Capturing Transient Phases: In methanol/water mixtures, the team successfully detected the highly unstable β-polymorph of glycine, which exists only briefly before transforming into the stable α-form. Such observations are impossible with traditional ex situ methods.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While these strategies represent a significant leap forward, challenges remain. Current experimental setups are generally limited to temperatures below 120°C, whereas many industrial catalytic processes occur at much higher temperatures. Additionally, there is a constant trade-off between temporal resolution and signal-to-noise ratio, often necessitating isotopic enrichment (e.g., $^{13}C$-labeling). Future work will focus on engineering rotors for higher temperatures and applying these methods to more complex, multi-step heterogeneous catalytic reactions beyond simple adsorption.

Summary updated

Abstract

Solid-state NMR spectroscopy is a powerful technique for studying structural and dynamic properties of solids and has considerable potential to be exploited for in situ studies of chemical processes. However, adapting solid-state NMR techniques and instrumentation for in situ applications are often associated with technical challenges, and for this reason, the opportunities remain underexploited. This paper highlights two experimental strategies that we have developed in recent years for in situ solid-state NMR investigations of solid-state processes. One technique is focused on probing details of the time evolution of materials formation processes, and the other technique is focused on understanding the time evolution of adsorption processes in microporous and mesoporous solid host materials. Each of these in situ solid-state NMR techniques has significant prospects for applications in areas relating to heterogeneous catalysis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{harris2016new,
  author = {Kenneth D. Harris},
  title = {{New in situ solid-state NMR strategies for exploring materials formation and adsorption processes: prospects in heterogenous catalysis}},
  booktitle = {Applied Petrochemical Research},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/s13203-016-0152-3},
}

Loading related content...

Figure