Neutron-induced nuclear recoil background in the PandaX-4T experiment*

Zhou Huang, Guofang Shen, Qiuhong Wang, Abdusalam Abdukerim, Zihao Bo, Wei Chen, Xun Chen, Yunhua Chen, C. H. Cheng, Yunshan Cheng, Xiangyi Cui, Yingjie 英杰 Fan 樊, Deqing Fang, Changbo Fu, Mengting Fu, Li‐Sheng Geng, Karl Giboni, Linhui Gu, Xuyuan Guo, Chencheng Han, K. Han, Changda He, Jinrong He, Di Huang, Yanlin Huang, Ruquan Hou, Xiangdong Ji, Yonglin Ju, Chenxiang Li, Mingchuan Li, S. Li, Q. Lin, Jianglai Liu, Xiaoying Lu, Lingyin Luo, Wenbo Ma, Y. G., Yajun Mao, Yue Meng, Xuyang Ning, Ningchun Qi, Zhicheng Qian, Xiangxiang Ren, Nasir Shaheed, Changsong Shang, Lin Si, Wenliang Sun, Andi Tan, Yi Tao, Anqing Wang, Meng Wang, Shaobo Wang, Siguang Wang, Wei Wang, Xiuli Wang, Zhou Wang, Mengmeng Wu, Weihao Wu, Jingkai Xia, M. Xiao, Xiang Xiao, Pengwei Xie, Binbin Yan, Xiyu Yan, Jijun Yang, Yong Yang, Chunxu Yu, Jumin Yuan, Ying Yuan, Dan Zhang, Minzhen Zhang, Peng Zhang, Tao Zhang, Li Zhao, Qibin Zheng, Jifang Zhou, N. Zhou, Xiaopeng Zhou, Yong ZhouChinese 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the crucial challenge of identifying and quantifying neutron-induced backgrounds in the PandaX-4T dark matter detector. By employing a combination of Monte Carlo simulations and novel data-driven techniques, the researchers provide a robust estimate of this background, crucial for interpreting future dark matter search results.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The PandaX-4T experiment, like other dark matter detectors, relies on identifying faint signals from potential Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs) scattering off xenon nuclei. However, neutrons, which can be produced by radioactive decays within the detector materials, can mimic these WIMP signals by causing similar nuclear recoils. Accurately estimating and subtracting this "neutron background" is paramount to distinguishing a true WIMP signal from background noise and setting meaningful limits on WIMP properties. This paper aims to provide such an estimate for the PandaX-4T experiment.

Methods

The researchers employed three distinct methods to estimate the neutron-induced nuclear recoil (NR) background:

  • Monte Carlo (MC) Simulation: This is a conventional approach where the detector geometry and known radioactive sources are modeled. The MC simulation predicts the number and energy of neutrons produced, their interactions within the liquid xenon, and the resulting NR signals. The accuracy of this method relies heavily on precise measurements of material radioactivities and the simulation's ability to accurately model neutron interactions.
  • Data-Driven Method 1: Multi-Scatter (MSNR) Events: Neutrons can scatter multiple times within the detector. While a single scatter mimics a WIMP signal, multiple scatters (MSNR) are a distinct signature of neutrons. By identifying and counting these MSNR events in the data and comparing their ratio to single scatter events (SSNR) from MC simulations, the neutron background can be estimated.
  • Data-Driven Method 2: High Energy Gamma (HEG) Events: Neutron capture by xenon nuclei can lead to the emission of high-energy gamma rays. These HEG events are another characteristic signature of neutron interactions. Similar to the MSNR method, the number of HEG events observed in the data, when compared to their simulated ratio with SSNR events, provides an independent estimate of the neutron background.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in this study are:

  • PandaX-4T Commissioning Data: This dataset, with an exposure of 0.63 tonne-year, forms the basis for the data-driven analyses.
  • Neutron Calibration Data: AmBe (Americium-Beryllium) and DD (deuteron-deuteron) neutron sources were used to calibrate the detector's response to neutrons and validate the simulation models.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing calibration data and the commissioning run data were utilized.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complementarity of Methods: The fact that three distinct methods (MC simulation, MSNR events, and HEG events) yield consistent results for the neutron background is a significant validation of the overall analysis. This consistency increases confidence in the final background estimate.
  • MSNR and HEG as Powerful Neutrino Signatures: The paper highlights how events with multiple neutron scatters (MSNR) and high-energy gamma rays from neutron capture (HEG) are not just backgrounds but also valuable tools for estimating the single-scatter neutron background. This turns a challenge into an opportunity for better background characterization.
  • Data-Driven Methods Enhance Reliability: While MC simulations are essential, relying solely on them can be limited by uncertainties in material properties and simulation accuracy. The data-driven approaches, by directly using observed event features, provide a crucial cross-check and reduce reliance on potentially uncertain simulation parameters.

Key Results

The study found a consistent result across all three methods for the neutron-induced background in the dark matter signal region (5-100 keV nuclear recoil energy). The estimated background is 1.15 ± 0.57 events. This indicates that the neutron background in PandaX-4T is well-controlled and subdominant compared to other potential backgrounds, which is a positive sign for future dark matter searches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainties in MC: The MC simulation method is subject to uncertainties stemming from radioactivity measurements of detector components and the simulation's fidelity in modeling neutron interactions. The paper quantifies this uncertainty.
  • Statistical Fluctuations in Data-Driven Methods: While data-driven methods are powerful, they can be limited by the statistics of observed MSNR and HEG events, especially in shorter data runs. The paper notes the statistical uncertainties associated with these counts.
  • Future Work: The paper implies that this detailed background characterization is a crucial step for the ongoing PandaX-4T experiment. Future work will likely involve applying these refined background models to larger datasets to improve the sensitivity of dark matter searches. The consistent results also pave the way for more precise WIMP cross-section limits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Neutron-induced nuclear recoil background is critical to dark matter searches in the PandaX-4T liquid xenon experiment. In this study, we investigate the features of neutron background in liquid xenon and evaluate its contribution in single scattering nuclear recoil events using three methods. The first method is fully based on Monte Carlo simulations. The last two are data-driven methods that also use multiple scattering signals and high energy signals in the data. In the PandaX-4T commissioning data with an exposure of 0.63 tonne-year, all these methods give a consistent result, i.e., there are neutron-induced backgrounds in the dark matter signal region within an approximated nuclear recoil energy window between 5 and 100 keV.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2022neutron,
  author = {Zhou Huang and Guofang Shen and Qiuhong Wang and Abdusalam Abdukerim and Zihao Bo and Wei Chen and Xun Chen and Yunhua Chen and C. H. Cheng and Yunshan Cheng and Xiangyi Cui and Yingjie 英杰 Fan 樊 and Deqing Fang and Changbo Fu and Mengting Fu and Li‐Sheng Geng and Karl Giboni and Linhui Gu and Xuyuan Guo and Chencheng Han and K. Han and Changda He and Jinrong He and Di Huang and Yanlin Huang and Ruquan Hou and Xiangdong Ji and Yonglin Ju and Chenxiang Li and Mingchuan Li and S. Li and Shuaijie Li and Q. Lin and Jianglai Liu and Xiaoying Lu and Lingyin Luo and Wenbo Ma and Y. G. and Yajun Mao and Yue Meng and Xuyang Ning and Ningchun Qi and Zhicheng Qian and Xiangxiang Ren and Nasir Shaheed and Changsong Shang and Lin Si and Wenliang Sun and Andi Tan and Yi Tao and Anqing Wang and Meng Wang and Shaobo Wang and Siguang Wang and Wei Wang and Xiuli Wang and Zhou Wang and Mengmeng Wu and Weihao Wu and Jingkai Xia and M. Xiao and Xiang Xiao and Pengwei Xie and Binbin Yan and Xiyu Yan and Jijun Yang and Yong Yang and Chunxu Yu and Jumin Yuan and Ying Yuan and Dan Zhang and Minzhen Zhang and Peng Zhang and Tao Zhang and Li Zhao and Qibin Zheng and Jifang Zhou and N. Zhou and Xiaopeng Zhou and Yong Zhou},
  title = {{Neutron-induced nuclear recoil background in the PandaX-4T experiment*}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1088/1674-1137/ac8539},
}
Figure