Neutralization Line Decoupling Tri-Band Multiple-Input Multiple-Output Antenna Design

Ruipeng Liu, Xing An, Hongxing Zheng, Mengjun Wang, Zhenbin Gao, Erping LiIEEE Access 2020 · OpenReview

Abstract

A pair of tri-band multiple-input-multiple-output (MIMO) antennas with high isolation is investigated in this paper. The proposed antenna consists of two monopole antenna elements with an edge-to-edge spacing of 4 mm ($0.03~\lambda _{0}$ at 2.3 GHz). The monopole antenna element utilizes a bending line structure to operate in three bands while achieving miniaturization. To achieve compact dimensions and high isolation, a symmetrical distribution layout is adopted to decouple the low-frequency band. A U-shaped neutralization line (NL) contacting two microstrip lines improves isolation in the high-frequency band, while an inverted U-shaped NL contacting the radiation patches decouples the middle-frequency band. The design achieves a low envelope correlation coefficient (ECC) and a quasi-omnidirectional radiation pattern, indicating satisfactory diversity performance for portable MIMO applications.

Introduction: The Challenge of Mutual Coupling

Modern wireless communication relies heavily on Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) technology to increase data rates and link reliability. However, as mobile devices continue to shrink, antenna elements must be placed in increasingly close proximity. This proximity leads to mutual coupling—electromagnetic interference between antennas that degrades system performance.

While techniques like defected ground structures or electromagnetic band-gap structures exist to mitigate this, they are often bulky or complex to fabricate. This research addresses the challenge of achieving high isolation across three distinct frequency bands (2.3, 3.5, and 5.7 GHz) within an extremely compact footprint without compromising radiation efficiency or coverage.

Design Methodology

The proposed system uses two symmetric monopole antennas with a "bending line" structure for miniaturization. The core innovation lies in a multi-pronged decoupling strategy targeting three specific bands:

  1. Symmetrical Layout: Placing the antennas in a back-to-back symmetrical arrangement naturally helps decouple the low-frequency band (2.3 GHz).
  2. Dual Neutralization Lines (NLs): Two distinct NLs are employed. A U-shaped NL connects the microstrip feed lines to isolate the high-frequency band (5.7 GHz). An inverted U-shaped NL connects the radiation patches to decouple the middle-frequency band (3.5 GHz).
  3. Phase Cancellation: These lines introduce a current 180 degrees out of phase with the existing coupling current, effectively neutralizing the interference.
The proposed tri-band MIMO antenna structure featuring dual neutralization lines.

By placing NLs at different physical points (feed line vs. radiation patch), the researchers tuned each structure to a specific frequency without disrupting the others. The antennas are separated by only 4mm, a mere 0.03 $\lambda_0$ at the lowest operating frequency.

Performance Evaluation

The design was optimized using HFSS and verified with a prototype on an FR4 substrate. The results demonstrated significant performance gains:

  • Isolation Improvement: The addition of NLs improved isolation by approximately 14 dB. Final isolation values exceeded 18 dB at 2.3 GHz, 32 dB at 3.5 GHz, and 24 dB at 5.7 GHz.
  • Envelope Correlation Coefficient (ECC): The ECC remained below 0.02 across all bands, far exceeding the standard requirement of < 0.5 for MIMO systems.
  • Radiation Characteristics: The system achieved a diversity gain close to the ideal 10 dB, with a quasi-omnidirectional H-plane radiation pattern suitable for portable electronics.
Simulated S11 parameters demonstrating tri-band resonance at 2.3, 3.5, and 5.7 GHz.

Conclusion

This dual-NL technique provides a robust solution for high-isolation, tri-band MIMO systems in compact devices. While the neutralization lines can slightly narrow operating bandwidth due to added inductance, the overall performance meets the rigorous demands of modern wireless standards. Future work may explore scaling this technique for higher-order MIMO arrays within densely packed smartphone chassis.

Summary updated

Abstract

A pair of tri-band multiple-input-multiple-output (MIMO) antennas with high isolation is investigated in this paper. The proposed antenna consists of two monopole antenna elements with an edge to edge spacing of 4 mm ($0.03~\lambda _{0}$ at 2.3 GHz). The monopole antenna element chose the bending line structure that can operate in tri-band and realize miniaturization. To achieve compact dimension and high isolation, symmetrical distribution layout is adopted to decouple the low frequency band, the U-shaped neutralization line (NL) contacting with two microstrip lines, and it can to improve the isolation in high frequency band, and the inverted U-shaped NL contacting with two radiation patch can decoupling in the middle frequency band. And then study the envelope correlation coefficient is lower, and the radiation pattern in operation bands is quasi-omnidirectional. It indicates that the antenna has obtained a satisfactory diversity performance within the whole operation bands which can be a good candidate for some portable MIMO applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020neutralization,
  author = {Ruipeng Liu and Xing An and Hongxing Zheng and Mengjun Wang and Zhenbin Gao and Erping Li},
  title = {{Neutralization Line Decoupling Tri-Band Multiple-Input Multiple-Output Antenna Design}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Nj4tQEt21zW},
}
Figure