Neurophthalmologic and Orthoptic Ambulatory Assessments Reveal Ocular and Visual Changes in Patients With Early Alzheimer and Parkinson's Disease

Alessia Bargagli, Enrica Fontanelli, Dario Zanca, Ilaria Castelli, Francesca Rosini, Silvia Maddii, Ilaria Di Donato, Alessandra Carluccio, Carla Battisti, Gian Marco Tosi, Maria Teresa Dotti, Alessandra RufaFrontiers in Neurology 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD) develop a progressive decline of visual function, which often aggravates cognitive and motor abilities. This study collected neurophthalmologic and orthoptic parameters, including optical coherence tomography (OCT) and facial emotion recognition (FER), in patients with early AD, PD, and healthy controls. Results demonstrate significant retinal thinning and eye alignment issues in patients, alongside deficits in emotion recognition. These findings suggest that visual rehabilitation could improve quality of life and reduce fall risks in these populations.

Introduction

While Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases are primarily characterized by cognitive and motor impairments, visual dysfunction is a frequent, yet often overlooked, early symptom. Patients commonly report blurred vision, reading difficulties, and light sensitivity. However, these symptoms are frequently dismissed as part of "normal aging," leading to an underestimation of their clinical significance. This study addresses the lack of standardized protocols for identifying pathological visual decline in early-stage neurodegenerative diseases, advocating for the use of neuro-ophthalmologic assessments in routine outpatient care.

Methods

The study involved a multi-modal assessment of 6 AD patients, 6 PD patients, and 8 healthy controls. The evaluation included:

  • Standard Neuro-ophthalmologic Exam: Visual acuity (Snellen chart) and color sensitivity (Ishihara testing).
  • Orthoptic Evaluation: Measurement of the Near Point of Convergence (NPC) and the Cover Test for eye deviations (heterophorias).
  • Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT): Measurement of the Retinal Nerve Fiber Layer (RNFL) and Ganglion Cell Layer (GCL) thickness.
  • Facial Emotion Recognition (FER): Patients identified six basic emotions (happiness, sadness, anger, fear, surprise, and disgust) using the Ekman database via custom software.

Results and Discussion

The Retina as a Biomarker

The eye serves as an accessible window into the central nervous system. OCT imaging revealed significant thinning of the retinal layers in both AD and PD patients compared to healthy controls.

RNFL thickness in superior, nasal, temporal, and inferior sectors for each group.

As shown in the RNFL analysis, the average thickness was notably lower in patients (AD: 86.91 µm; PD: 89.67 µm) than in controls (95.63 µm). Similarly, the GCL showed significant reduction, particularly in the superior and nasal sectors.

GCL thickness in various sectors across the three study groups.

Eye Alignment and Functional Vision

Convergence Insufficiency (CI) was pervasive among patients. PD patients, in particular, showed a high prevalence of exophoria at near distances, leading to a "remote" Near Point of Convergence (NPC > 10cm). This misalignment explains the frequent complaints of reading discomfort and spatial disorientation, despite many patients maintaining "normal" visual acuity on standard charts.

Emotion Recognition Deficits

Both AD and PD patients struggled significantly with recognizing negative emotions. AD patients had the most difficulty with sadness, while PD patients struggled with fear. On average, patients made 15-16 errors per test, compared to just 2.9 errors in the control group, suggesting distinct impacts on the brain's ventral affective system.

Conclusion

Despite the small sample size, this study highlights that visual and ocular defects are measurable early markers of AD and PD. Many of these issues, such as convergence insufficiency or glare, are treatable through prismatic lenses, specialized filters, or orthoptic exercises. Implementing these rehabilitative approaches could significantly enhance motor autonomy and reduce the risk of falls, improving the daily lives of patients with neurodegenerative diseases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD) develop a progressive decline of visual function. This condition aggravates overall cognitive and motor abilities, is a risk factor for developing hallucinations, and can have a significant influence on general quality of life. Visual problems are common complaints of patients with PD and AD in the early stages of the disease, but they also occur during normal aging, making it difficult to differentiate between normal and pathological conditions. In this respect, their real incidence has remained largely underestimated, and no rehabilitative approaches have been standardized. With the aim to increase awareness for ocular and visual disorders, we collected the main neurophthalmologic and orthoptic parameters, including optical coherence tomography (OCT), in six patients with a diagnosis of PD, six patients with a diagnosis of early AD, and eight control subjects in an easily assessable outpatient setting. We also evaluated the patient's ability to recognize changes in facial expression. Our study demonstrates that visual problems, including blurred vision, diplopia, reading discomfort, photophobia, and glare, are commonly reported in patients with PD and AD. Moreover, abnormal eye alignment and vergence insufficiency were documented in all patients during examination. Despite the small size of the sample, we demonstrated greater ganglion cell and retinal nerve fibers layer (RNFL) damage and a defect of facial emotion recognition in AD/PD patients with respect to a comparable group of normal elderly persons, with peculiarities depending upon the disease. Ocular defects or visual discomfort could be correctly evaluated in these patients and possibly corrected by means of lens, orthoptic exercises, and visual rehabilitation. Such a practical approach may help to ameliorate motor autonomy, reading ability, and may also reduce the risk of falls, with a positive impact in daily living activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bargagli2020neurophthalmologic,
  author = {Alessia Bargagli and Enrica Fontanelli and Dario Zanca and Ilaria Castelli and Francesca Rosini and Silvia Maddii and Ilaria Di Donato and Alessandra Carluccio and Carla Battisti and Gian Marco Tosi and Maria Teresa Dotti and Alessandra Rufa},
  title = {{Neurophthalmologic and Orthoptic Ambulatory Assessments Reveal Ocular and Visual Changes in Patients With Early Alzheimer and Parkinson's Disease}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2020.577362},
}
Figure