Neuronal integration in the adult mouse olfactory bulb is a non-selective addition process

Jean‐Claude Platel, Alexandra Angelova, Stéphane Bugeon, Jenelle L. Wallace, Thibault Ganay, Ilona Chudotvorova, Jean‐Christophe Deloulme, Christophe Béclin, Marie-Catherine Tiveron, Nathalie Coré, Venkatesh N. Murthy, Harold CremereLife 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Contrary to established models, this study demonstrates that new neurons are continuously added to the adult mouse olfactory bulb (OB) throughout life, rather than replacing older neurons. This lifelong addition leads to the growth of the OB, challenging the long-held view of OB neurogenesis as a competitive selection process for maintaining a stable neuron population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the prevailing model of adult neurogenesis in the olfactory bulb (OB) proposed a "competition" scenario. Newborn neurons were thought to vie for integration into existing circuits, with many being eliminated during a critical "selection period." Furthermore, the OB was considered a "turnover system," where new neurons replaced those that died, maintaining a relatively constant total neuron number. However, direct, long-term in vivo observations to rigorously test these hypotheses were scarce. This paper aims to resolve this by systematically observing the integration and survival of newly born neurons in the adult OB over extended periods using advanced imaging techniques.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining cutting-edge techniques:

  • Two-photon In Vivo Imaging: This allowed for high-resolution, real-time observation of individual neurons within the living brain of awake mice. They used genetic labeling (CRE-lox system with Rosa-RFP reporter mice) to track both perinatally and adult-born neurons.
  • Reinforced Thin Skull Preparation: This surgical technique enabled repeated access to the OB for imaging over several months without causing significant inflammation or tissue damage.
  • Lineage Tracing with Thymidine Analogs (BrdU and EdU): While standard doses of these analogs are known to induce cell death, the study specifically investigated the dose-dependent effects of EdU. They found that low doses of EdU did not cause significant cell loss, allowing for more reliable assessment of neuronal survival.
  • Light-Sheet Microscopy on Cleared Tissues: This technique allowed for whole-brain imaging and 3D reconstruction of the OB, enabling precise volumetric measurements and cell density analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from live animal imaging and fixed tissue analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OB Growth, Not Turnover: The most striking finding is that the adult OB doesn't maintain a stable size through neuron replacement. Instead, it continuously grows throughout adulthood due to the addition of new neurons.
  • Low Neuronal Death: Contrary to the "competitive selection" model, the study found very little cell death among newly integrated neurons in the OB, even during the proposed critical period.
  • Thymidine Analog Toxicity: Standard doses of thymidine analogs like BrdU and EdU can induce cell death, potentially confounding previous studies on neuronal survival and selection. Low doses of EdU, however, proved to be a more reliable tool.
  • Non-Selective Addition: The integration of new neurons appears to be a non-selective process, with new cells being added without significant elimination of existing ones.

Key Results

  • Minimal Cell Loss: Over 8 weeks, only 5.1% of periglomerular neurons (PGNs) and no granule cells (GCs) were lost in the OB under physiological conditions. Adult-born neurons also showed low loss rates (1.5% for PGNs, 5.9% for GCs).
  • OB Growth: In vivo imaging and light-sheet microscopy revealed a significant increase in OB volume, with a 44% enlargement from 2 to 12 months of age. This growth occurred without changes in cell density, indicating an increase in the number of neurons.
  • EdU Dose-Dependency: High doses of EdU (50 mg/kg) led to ~40% cell loss, similar to BrdU. However, low doses (1 or 5 mg/kg) showed no significant cell loss, validating the in vivo imaging findings.
  • Sensory Deprivation Induces Death: Blocking olfactory input (naris occlusion) led to a significant increase in cell loss, demonstrating that cell death can be detected under non-physiological conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Thymidine Analog Discrepancy: The study notes a discrepancy between their findings and previous studies using high-dose thymidine analogs, suggesting that the toxicity of these analogs may have led to overestimations of cell death and selection. Future work could involve further investigation into the mechanisms behind this discrepancy.
  • Olfactory Enrichment and Learning: While the study found low cell death, it acknowledges that olfactory enrichment and learning have been shown to increase neuron survival. The authors suggest repeating their in vivo observations and low-dose EdU studies in the context of olfactory stimulation to clarify how neurons are "saved" when death is already rare.
  • Selection at the RMS Level: The high density of apoptotic cells in the rostral migratory stream (RMS) compared to the OB suggests that neuronal selection might occur earlier, at the precursor recruitment stage, rather than during integration into the OB. Further research could explore this "early selection" hypothesis.
  • OB Growth Mechanisms: While OB growth is demonstrated, the precise mechanisms driving this continuous expansion and how it is regulated require further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Adult neurogenesis in the olfactory bulb (OB) is considered as a competition in which neurons scramble during a critical selection period for integration and survival. Moreover, newborn neurons are thought to replace pre-existing ones that die. Despite indirect evidence supporting this model, systematic in vivo observations are still scarce. We used two-photon in vivo imaging to study neuronal integration and survival. We show that loss of new neurons in the OB after arrival at terminal positions occurs only at low levels. Moreover, long-term observations showed that no substantial cell death occurred at later stages. Neuronal death was induced by standard doses of thymidine analogs, but disappeared when low doses were used. Finally, we demonstrate that the OB grows throughout life. This shows that neuronal selection during OB-neurogenesis does not occur after neurons reached stable positions. Moreover, this suggests that OB neurogenesis does not represent neuronal turnover but lifelong neuronal addition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{platel2019neuronal,
  author = {Jean‐Claude Platel and Alexandra Angelova and Stéphane Bugeon and Jenelle L. Wallace and Thibault Ganay and Ilona Chudotvorova and Jean‐Christophe Deloulme and Christophe Béclin and Marie-Catherine Tiveron and Nathalie Coré and Venkatesh N. Murthy and Harold Cremer},
  title = {{Neuronal integration in the adult mouse olfactory bulb is a non-selective addition process}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.44830},
}
Figure