Neuronal Avalanches Differ from Wakefulness to Deep Sleep – Evidence from Intracranial Depth Recordings in Humans

Viola Priesemann, Mario Valderrama, Michael Wibral, Michel Le Van QuyenPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Neuronal activity differs between wakefulness and sleep states. In contrast, an attractor state, called self-organized critical (SOC), was proposed to govern brain dynamics because it allows for optimal information coding. But is the human brain SOC for each vigilance state despite the variations in neuronal dynamics? We characterized neuronal avalanches--spatiotemporal waves of enhanced activity--from dense intracranial depth recordings in humans. We showed that avalanche distributions closely follow a power law--the hallmark feature of SOC--for each vigilance state. However, avalanches clearly differ with vigilance states: slow wave sleep (SWS) shows large avalanches, wakefulness intermediate, and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep small ones. Our SOC model, together with the data, suggested first that the differences are mediated by global but tiny changes in synaptic strength, and second, that the changes with vigilance states reflect small deviations from criticality to the subcritical regime, implying that the human brain does not operate at criticality proper but close to SOC. Independent of criticality, the analysis confirms that SWS shows increased correlations between cortical areas, and reveals that REM sleep shows more fragmented cortical dynamics.

Introduction

The "Self-Organized Criticality" (SOC) hypothesis suggests that the brain tunes itself to a state poised between order and chaos to maximize information processing capacity. While SOC has been observed in in vitro brain slices and animal models, its persistence across different states of human consciousness remains a subject of intense debate. Does the brain maintain this "critical" state during deep sleep, or does it drift into different dynamical regimes? This study investigates whether the human brain maintains optimal criticality across wakefulness, slow-wave sleep (SWS), and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep using high-resolution intracranial data.

Methods

The researchers analyzed intracranial depth recordings (Local Field Potentials or LFP) from five epileptic patients. These electrodes, implanted deep within the brain for clinical purposes, provided high-resolution data from up to 61 sites simultaneously across the neocortex, hippocampus, and amygdala.

To quantify brain dynamics, the study identified "neuronal avalanches"—spatiotemporal clusters of activity that ripple across recording sites. An avalanche is defined as a continuous sequence of time bins where at least one electrode exceeds a specific activity threshold.

Detection of neuronal avalanches in human intracranial recordings.

The statistical distribution of these avalanches was analyzed using Maximum Likelihood Estimation to determine if they followed a power law, which is the mathematical signature of a system near a critical point.

Results

Universal Power-Law Dynamics

The analysis revealed that avalanche size distributions followed a power law across all vigilance states, confirming that the brain stays near a critical state regardless of whether the subject is awake or asleep. However, the specific characteristics of these avalanches varied significantly between states.

Power-law distribution of avalanche sizes across models and human data.

State-Dependent Avalanche Hierarchy

A consistent hierarchy emerged in the size and duration of avalanches: SWS > Wakefulness > REM. During SWS, the brain exhibited the largest avalanches and the strongest correlations between distant areas, indicating a highly integrated state closest to the critical tipping point. Conversely, REM sleep—often called "paradoxical sleep"—showed the most fragmented and "subcritical" dynamics.

The Subcritical Safety Margin

The branching parameter (σ), a measure of how activity spreads, was found to be slightly less than 1 (approximately 0.9 to 0.98). This indicates that the human brain operates in a "subcritical" regime rather than at exact criticality. This slight deviation may serve as a "safety margin" to prevent the runaway, explosive activity characteristic of epileptic seizures.

Discussion

The transition between wakefulness and sleep stages appears to be driven by minute neuromodulatory shifts. Modeling results suggest that the observed changes in brain dynamics can be explained by global shifts in synaptic strength of less than 1%. This extreme sensitivity implies that the brain's proximity to criticality is finely tuned.

While the study is limited by subsampling—observing only a fraction of the brain's billions of neurons—the consistency across patients and brain regions suggests that these dynamics are a fundamental property of human neural tissue. Future research into the homeostatic mechanisms that maintain this subcritical tuning could provide vital insights into neurological disorders where this balance is disrupted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neuronal activity differs between wakefulness and sleep states. In contrast, an attractor state, called self-organized critical (SOC), was proposed to govern brain dynamics because it allows for optimal information coding. But is the human brain SOC for each vigilance state despite the variations in neuronal dynamics? We characterized neuronal avalanches--spatiotemporal waves of enhanced activity--from dense intracranial depth recordings in humans. We showed that avalanche distributions closely follow a power law--the hallmark feature of SOC--for each vigilance state. However, avalanches clearly differ with vigilance states: slow wave sleep (SWS) shows large avalanches, wakefulness intermediate, and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep small ones. Our SOC model, together with the data, suggested first that the differences are mediated by global but tiny changes in synaptic strength, and second, that the changes with vigilance states reflect small deviations from criticality to the subcritical regime, implying that the human brain does not operate at criticality proper but close to SOC. Independent of criticality, the analysis confirms that SWS shows increased correlations between cortical areas, and reveals that REM sleep shows more fragmented cortical dynamics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{priesemann2013neuronal,
  author = {Viola Priesemann and Mario Valderrama and Michael Wibral and Michel Le Van Quyen},
  title = {{Neuronal Avalanches Differ from Wakefulness to Deep Sleep – Evidence from Intracranial Depth Recordings in Humans}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002985},
}
Figure