Neural processing in the primary auditory cortex following cholinergic lesions of the basal forebrain in ferrets

Fernando R. Nodal, Nicholas D. Leach, Peter Keating, Johannes C Dahmen, Dylan Zhao, Andrew J. King, Victoria M. BajoHearing 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the role of acetylcholine (ACh) in the auditory cortex by selectively depleting cholinergic input in ferrets. They found that while ACh is crucial for adapting to altered sound localization cues, it's not essential for maintaining the basic spectral and spatial tuning of auditory neurons. This suggests ACh's primary role in auditory processing lies in plasticity and learning, rather than fundamental sensory representation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The basal forebrain, a key source of cholinergic input to the cortex, is known to be involved in various cognitive functions, including learning and attention. Previous research has shown that disrupting this cholinergic pathway impairs ferrets' ability to accurately localize sounds and adapt to changes in spatial cues (like covering one ear). However, it remained unclear whether these behavioral deficits were due to fundamental changes in how auditory cortical neurons process basic acoustic information (like frequency and location) or if it was specifically related to the neural mechanisms underlying plasticity and learning. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining the response properties of neurons in the primary auditory cortex (A1) after cholinergic deafferentation.

Methods

The researchers used a well-established method to selectively deplete cholinergic input to the auditory cortex. They injected the immunotoxin ME20.4-SAP into the nucleus basalis (NB) of ferrets, which targets and eliminates cholinergic neurons. These "NB ACh" ferrets were then compared to control ferrets.

Key techniques included:

  • Electrophysiological Recordings: Neural activity in the primary auditory cortex (A1) was recorded from anesthetized ferrets. This involved using multi-electrode probes to capture the firing patterns of individual neurons.
  • Auditory Stimulation: Neurons were stimulated with a variety of sounds, including pure tones (to assess frequency tuning) and broadband noise presented in a virtual acoustic space (VAS). VAS allows for precise control over sound localization cues, mimicking real-world spatial audio.
  • Immunohistochemistry: After recordings, brain tissue was analyzed to confirm the extent of cholinergic cell loss and verify electrode placement.
  • Behavioral Testing (Previous Work): The study builds upon prior behavioral experiments where NB ACh ferrets showed deficits in sound localization and adaptation to monaural occlusion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on in vivo electrophysiological recordings from animal subjects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ACh is for Plasticity, Not Representation: The most striking finding is that the fundamental spectral (frequency tuning) and spatial (interaural level difference sensitivity) properties of auditory cortical neurons are largely preserved even after significant cholinergic depletion. This strongly suggests that ACh's role is not in the basic encoding of sound features but rather in enabling the brain to change how it processes these features during learning.
  • Bursting Behavior is Affected: While overall spontaneous firing rates were similar, ferrets with cholinergic lesions showed a significantly lower proportion of "burst-type" neurons and reduced burst firing frequency. This indicates that ACh might play a role in regulating specific firing patterns related to spontaneous activity.
  • Increased Neural Synchrony: The study observed increased synchrony in the activity of simultaneously recorded neuron pairs in the NB ACh group, particularly during driven activity. This suggests that cholinergic input might normally help to desynchronize neural activity, and its absence leads to more correlated firing.
  • Virtual Earplug Reveals Subtle Differences: When simulating a unilateral earplug (a condition that normally drives adaptation), the NB ACh ferrets showed slightly different changes in spatial sensitivity compared to controls. This hints at a subtle role for ACh in how the brain adapts its spatial processing, even if the baseline spatial tuning is unaffected.

Key Results

  • Spectral Tuning: No significant differences were found in characteristic frequencies (CF), frequency tuning widths (Q10, Q30), or response thresholds between control and NB ACh ferrets.
  • Spontaneous Activity: Median spontaneous firing rates were similar between groups. However, the percentage of burst-type neurons decreased significantly (from 28.01% to 17.91%) in the NB ACh group.
  • Neural Synchrony: Driven activity showed significantly higher maximum normalized correlation values in NB ACh units compared to controls (0.780 vs. 0.742).
  • Spatial Sensitivity (Normal Hearing): Spatial sensitivity, including preferred interaural level differences (ILDs), centroid direction, and modulation index, was remarkably similar between control and NB ACh ferrets.
  • Spatial Sensitivity (Virtual Earplug): While both groups showed changes in spatial tuning with a simulated earplug, the NB ACh group exhibited some differences in how azimuth sensitivity shifted, potentially reflecting their limited behavioral adaptation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Anesthesia: The recordings were performed under general anesthesia (medetomidine and ketamine). The authors acknowledge that anesthesia can influence neuronal activity and that these anesthetic agents have strong effects on arousal. While they argue that the consistent anesthesia across groups minimizes its impact on comparative results, they suggest that future work should include recordings in awake, behaving animals to fully understand the role of ACh during active listening.
  • Previous Surgery: The NB ACh ferrets underwent a prior surgery to implant the immunotoxin, whereas control animals did not. The authors address this by citing previous work showing that sham surgeries do not affect auditory processing, suggesting this is unlikely to be a confounding factor.
  • Subcortical Involvement: The study focused on the primary auditory cortex. However, the authors note that cholinergic inputs also reach subcortical structures like the inferior colliculus, which are known to be involved in auditory spatial learning. Future work could explore plasticity in these subcortical areas.
  • Behavioral Relevance: The paper highlights that the behavioral deficits observed in NB ACh ferrets are linked to behaviorally relevant stimuli and adaptation. Future research could further investigate how ACh mediates plasticity in response to stimuli that are actively being learned or attended to.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cortical acetylcholine (ACh) release has been linked to various cognitive functions, including perceptual learning. We have previously shown that cortical cholinergic innervation is necessary for accurate sound localization in ferrets, as well as for their ability to adapt with training to altered spatial cues. To explore whether these behavioral deficits are associated with changes in the response properties of cortical neurons, we recorded neural activity in the primary auditory cortex (A1) of anesthetized ferrets in which cholinergic inputs had been reduced by making bilateral injections of the immunotoxin ME20.4-SAP in the nucleus basalis (NB) prior to training the animals. The pattern of spontaneous activity of A1 units recorded in the ferrets with cholinergic lesions (NB ACh<sup>-</sup>) was similar to that in controls, although the proportion of burst-type units was significantly lower. Depletion of ACh also resulted in more synchronous activity in A1. No changes in thresholds, frequency tuning or in the distribution of characteristic frequencies were found in these animals. When tested with normal acoustic inputs, the spatial sensitivity of A1 neurons in the NB ACh<sup>-</sup> ferrets and the distribution of their preferred interaural level differences also closely resembled those found in control animals, indicating that these properties had not been altered by sound localization training with one ear occluded. Simulating the animals' previous experience with a virtual earplug in one ear reduced the contralateral preference of A1 units in both groups, but caused azimuth sensitivity to change in slightly different ways, which may reflect the modest adaptation observed in the NB ACh<sup>-</sup> group. These results show that while ACh is required for behavioral adaptation to altered spatial cues, it is not required for maintenance of the spectral and spatial response properties of A1 neurons.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nodal2024neural,
  author = {Fernando R. Nodal and Nicholas D. Leach and Peter Keating and Johannes C Dahmen and Dylan Zhao and Andrew J. King and Victoria M. Bajo},
  title = {{Neural processing in the primary auditory cortex following cholinergic lesions of the basal forebrain in ferrets}},
  booktitle = {Hearing},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.heares.2024.109025},
}
Figure