Neural coding in barrel cortex during whisker-guided locomotion

Nicholas Sofroniew, Yurii A. Vlasov, Samuel Andrew Hires, Jeremy Freeman, Karel SvobodaeLife 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

Mice use their whiskers to navigate, but how the brain processes this tactile information during natural movement is poorly understood. This study uses a novel virtual reality system to show that the barrel cortex, a key somatosensory area, encodes wall distance with a rich population code, and that activating specific barrel cortex neurons can even guide mouse behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how animals perceive and interact with their environment is fundamental to neuroscience. While much is known about sensory processing during passive or highly constrained tasks, how neural circuits function during natural, active behaviors like exploration remains a significant challenge. Rodents, in particular, rely heavily on their whiskers for navigating complex environments, especially in low light. Previous research has investigated whisker-touch responses and locomotion, but a comprehensive understanding of neural coding in the barrel cortex during active, whisker-guided wall-tracking behavior was missing. This paper aims to bridge that gap by investigating how the barrel cortex represents spatial information during naturalistic wall navigation.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated tactile virtual reality (VR) system. Head-fixed mice ran on a spherical treadmill, and motorized walls were moved in a closed-loop manner to simulate a winding corridor. This allowed for precise control over the tactile environment while simultaneously recording neural activity and observing behavior.

Key techniques included:

  • Optogenetics: To manipulate neural activity, they used Channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) expressed in specific neuron types (VGAT-expressing inhibitory neurons for silencing, and layer 4 excitatory neurons for activation). This allowed them to either inhibit or activate barrel cortex neurons and observe the behavioral consequences.
  • Two-photon calcium imaging: This technique was used to record the activity of large populations of neurons in layer 2/3 of the barrel cortex during wall tracking.
  • Extracellular electrophysiology: This method was used to record from individual neurons across multiple layers (2-5) of the barrel cortex, providing finer temporal resolution than calcium imaging.
  • Behavioral analysis: Mice's trajectories and turning angles were meticulously tracked to quantify their wall-tracking performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study generated its own behavioral and neural data through experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Barrel cortex is essential for wall tracking: Silencing the barrel cortex significantly impaired mice's ability to navigate winding corridors, demonstrating its critical role in this behavior.
  • Artificial corridors can guide behavior: Activating specific layer 4 neurons in the barrel cortex, in a position-dependent manner, was sufficient to guide mice along an "illusory" corridor, even in the absence of physical walls. This suggests a direct mapping between neural activity and behavioral output.
  • Rich representation of wall distance: Neurons in the barrel cortex exhibit diverse tuning to the distance between the mouse's snout and the contralateral wall. This tuning isn't simple; it includes monotonic, unimodal, and even multimodal responses.
  • Beyond simple whisker inputs: The complex tuning observed suggests that barrel cortex processing goes beyond simple stimulus-response relationships from individual whiskers. It likely involves integration within cortical circuits.
  • Encoding of wall motion direction: Beyond static distance, some barrel cortex neurons also encode the direction of wall movement (towards or away from the mouse), suggesting a role in predicting and reacting to dynamic environmental changes.

Key Results

  • Behavioral impairment: Bilateral photoinhibition of the barrel cortex led to a significant increase in angle error during turns in the VR corridor (8.09 ± 2.22° vs. 3.68 ± 0.55°).
  • Behavioral guidance: Optogenetic activation of layer 4 neurons guided wall-tracking behavior with a low angle error (2.30 ± 0.85°), comparable to real wall tracking.
  • Neural tuning: Approximately 28% of layer 2/3 neurons imaged showed significant tuning to wall distance. Electrophysiology revealed a similar proportion of tuned neurons across layers.
  • Tuning diversity: Tuning curves varied widely, with some neurons showing increased activity as the wall approached, others peaking at specific distances, and some exhibiting multimodal responses.
  • Directional coding: 55% of neurons showed significant modulation by the direction of wall movement (towards vs. away).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Head-fixed preparation: While powerful for neural recording, the head-fixed setup is a limitation compared to free-moving behavior. However, the VR system aims to mimic naturalistic exploration as closely as possible.
  • Simplification of VR: The VR environment, while complex, is still a simplification of the real world. Future work could explore more complex environments and tactile stimuli.
  • Causality vs. Representation: While optogenetics demonstrates causality, further work could explore how the diverse tuning properties contribute to the overall representation of space.
  • Interactions with other senses: The study focuses on tactile input. Future research could investigate how whisker-based spatial information is integrated with other sensory modalities (e.g., vision, audition) during navigation.
  • Downstream circuits: The paper speculates that barrel cortex might influence behavior via the superior colliculus and rubrospinal circuits. Investigating these downstream pathways directly would be a logical next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Animals seek out relevant information by moving through a dynamic world, but sensory systems are usually studied under highly constrained and passive conditions that may not probe important dimensions of the neural code. Here, we explored neural coding in the barrel cortex of head-fixed mice that tracked walls with their whiskers in tactile virtual reality. Optogenetic manipulations revealed that barrel cortex plays a role in wall-tracking. Closed-loop optogenetic control of layer 4 neurons can substitute for whisker-object contact to guide behavior resembling wall tracking. We measured neural activity using two-photon calcium imaging and extracellular recordings. Neurons were tuned to the distance between the animal snout and the contralateral wall, with monotonic, unimodal, and multimodal tuning curves. This rich representation of object location in the barrel cortex could not be predicted based on simple stimulus-response relationships involving individual whiskers and likely emerges within cortical circuits.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sofroniew2015neural,
  author = {Nicholas Sofroniew and Yurii A. Vlasov and Samuel Andrew Hires and Jeremy Freeman and Karel Svoboda},
  title = {{Neural coding in barrel cortex during whisker-guided locomotion}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.12559},
}
Figure