Networked Control of Electric Vehicles for Power System Frequency Regulation with Random Communication Time Delay

Guo Yun-peng, Liyan Zhang, Junhua Zhao, Fushuan Wen, Md. Abdus Salam, Jianwei Mao, Liang LiEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel networked control system framework that allows electric vehicles (EVs) to actively participate in power grid frequency regulation, even with unpredictable communication delays. The authors developed two advanced controllers using Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMI) theory that ensure system stability and robustness, outperforming traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of electric vehicles (EVs) into the power grid presents a significant opportunity for grid stabilization, particularly in frequency regulation. EVs, with their large battery capacity, can act as distributed energy storage systems to help balance supply and demand, thus assisting conventional power plants and accommodating renewable energy sources like wind power. However, controlling a vast number of distributed EVs in real-time poses a challenge, especially when communication between the control center and EVs is not instantaneous or perfectly reliable. This paper specifically addresses the issue of random communication time delays, which can significantly degrade control system performance and even lead to instability. The authors aim to design controllers that can effectively manage EV participation in frequency regulation despite these communication uncertainties.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in the development of two novel control strategies: an optimal H∞-PID full-state feedback controller and a suboptimal H∞-PID output feedback controller. These controllers are designed using Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMI) theory, a powerful mathematical framework for robust control design.

Here's a breakdown of the approach:

  • Networked Control System (NCS) Framework: The paper first establishes a framework for a networked control system where sensors, controllers, and actuators (EVs) are connected via a communication network. This acknowledges the reality of using general-purpose networks for EV control, which introduces delays.
  • Hierarchical Control with EV Aggregators: To manage the large number of EVs, a hierarchical approach is proposed, utilizing EV aggregators. These aggregators manage clusters of EVs, reporting their status to the control center and implementing control signals.
  • Two-Area LFC Model: A detailed block diagram of a two-area Load Frequency Control (LFC) system is developed, incorporating both conventional generators and EV modules, along with wind power disturbances and network-induced time delays.
  • H∞-PID Control Design:
    • Full-State Feedback: For situations where all system states are measurable, an optimal H∞-PID full-state feedback controller is designed. This controller aims to minimize the impact of disturbances and ensure robust stability.
  • Output Feedback: Recognizing that not all states might be measurable (e.g., due to cost or practicality), a suboptimal H∞-PID output feedback controller is also developed. This controller uses a subset of measurable states to achieve robust stability.
  • PID Module Addition: To address steady-state errors and improve dynamic performance, a PID control module is added to the H∞ controllers.
  • LMI Theory: The design of these controllers heavily relies on LMI theory, which provides a systematic way to solve robust control problems, especially those involving uncertainties like time delays.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses a simulated two-area LFC system derived from the IEEE 39-bus test system, with parameters provided in Table 2.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • EVs as a Viable Frequency Regulator: The paper strongly demonstrates that EVs can be effectively utilized for frequency regulation, offering significant advantages over traditional methods, especially in enhancing grid stability and accommodating renewables.
  • Robustness to Communication Delays: The developed H∞-PID controllers are shown to be robust to random communication time delays, a critical factor for real-world implementation of networked control systems for EVs. This robustness is a key differentiator from previous works that often assumed ideal communication.
  • LMI Theory's Power in Control Design: The successful application of LMI theory for designing complex controllers for systems with uncertainties highlights its practical utility in modern control engineering.
  • Full-State vs. Output Feedback Trade-offs: The paper presents both full-state and output feedback controllers, illustrating the trade-offs between performance and the need for complete state measurement.

Key Results

  • Stability Under Delay: The proposed H∞-PID controllers (both full-state and output feedback) maintain system stability even with significant communication delays (e.g., 0.5 seconds), whereas traditional PI control loses stability under such conditions.
  • Performance Improvement: The H∞-PID controllers generally outperform traditional PI control in terms of overshoot and stabilization time, even without delays.
  • Impact of Delay: Increasing communication delay degrades system performance (overshoot and stabilization time), but the proposed controllers mitigate this impact significantly. For instance, a delay of 0.4s increased frequency deviation overshoot by 130.1% compared to no delay, but the controllers kept the system stable.
  • EV Contribution: The simulations show that EVs can effectively contribute to load balancing, reducing the burden on conventional generators and improving the overall dynamic response of the system. For example, with EVs, the fluctuation interval of system frequency deviation was reduced by 66.6% during wind power fluctuations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Practical Implementation Challenges: The paper notes that the optimal H∞-PID full-state feedback method might not be fully practical due to the need for advanced PMU, WAM, and state estimation methods. Further development in these areas is suggested.
  • EV Aggregator Optimization: While the paper uses a basic proportional allocation method for EVs, it acknowledges that optimizing power allocation for EV aggregators to maximize their profit is an important problem for future research.
  • Advanced Control Techniques: The paper focuses on LMI-based H∞ control. Future work could explore other advanced control techniques for even more sophisticated management of EV fleets and grid dynamics.
  • Real-World Data: The study relies on simulated data. Future work could involve validation with real-world data from actual power grids and EV charging infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electric vehicles (EVs) can have noteworthy impact on power system dynamic performance. This paper develops two novel controllers which can take into account the random time delay in the communication channel of the control system. With the designed robust controller, the system can utilize EVs to participate in automatic generation control (AGC) processes so as to assist conventional thermal power units to respond rapidly and accurately to load fluctuations, as well as to enhance the capability of a power system to accommodate renewable energy forms such as wind power. Owing to the distributed nature of EVs, a networked control scheme for EVs’ participation in frequency regulation is first proposed in the paper. A closed-loop block diagram, which incorporates EVs and wind power, is then developed. Two controllers are then designed based on rigorous linear matrix inequalities (LMI) theory to ensure the robustness and stability of the system. Finally, comprehensive case studies based on a two-area equivalent of the IEEE 39-bus test system are performed to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yunpeng2017networked,
  author = {Guo Yun-peng and Liyan Zhang and Junhua Zhao and Fushuan Wen and Md. Abdus Salam and Jianwei Mao and Liang Li},
  title = {{Networked Control of Electric Vehicles for Power System Frequency Regulation with Random Communication Time Delay}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10050621},
}
Figure