Network Construction with Ordered Constraints

Yi Huang, Mano Vikash Janardhanan, Lev ReyzinarXiv 2017 · arXiv

Abstract

This paper investigates the Network Construction problem under a novel model of "ordered connectivity constraints." This model captures the dynamics of information diffusion or viral spread, where the sequence of infection is known but the underlying transmission network is hidden. The authors provide a comprehensive analysis of both offline and online settings, establishing tight complexity bounds and significantly improved competitive ratios for online algorithms, including near-optimal results for specific topologies like stars and paths.

Introduction

In many real-world scenarios—such as tracking a viral tweet or mapping an epidemiological outbreak—we observe the order in which individuals are affected but not the specific transmission vectors. We know when someone was infected, and we know they must have been infected by someone who already carried the virus, but the exact source remains latent.

Mathematically, this is framed as the Network Construction problem. While previous literature focused on subgraph connectivity (where sets of nodes must be connected) or path constraints (where nodes form a specific sequence), this research introduces Ordered Constraints. An ordered constraint $O = (v_1, v_2, \dots, v_s)$ stipulates that for every node $v_i$ (where $i > 1$), there must exist an edge connecting it to at least one node $v_j$ that appeared earlier in the sequence ($j < i$). The objective is to construct the minimum-cost network (minimizing the number of edges) that satisfies a given set of these constraints.

Problem Settings

The authors evaluate the problem across two primary computational environments:

  1. Offline Setting: The algorithm is provided with the entire set of propagation chains simultaneously and must determine the minimal graph required to satisfy all constraints.
  2. Online Setting: Constraints arrive sequentially. The algorithm must add edges to satisfy each new constraint immediately, with the restriction that previously added edges cannot be removed.

Methodology

Offline Analysis

To establish the complexity of the offline problem, the authors utilize a reduction from the Hitting Set problem. This demonstrates that reconstructing the network is NP-Hard and establishes that the problem is difficult to approximate within a factor of $\Omega(\log n)$.

Online Algorithms for General Graphs

For general online graphs, the authors propose a Fractional Network Construction approach. This involves solving a linear relaxation of the problem by assigning weights to potential edges. These weights are then processed through a probabilistic rounding scheme to determine which physical edges should be constructed. This method bridges the gap between continuous optimization and discrete graph construction.

Structural Specialization: PQ-Trees

When the underlying network is known to be a path, the authors employ PQ-trees. These specialized data structures represent all possible linear orderings of a set that satisfy specific contiguity constraints. By applying a potential function analysis to the PQ-tree transitions, the authors derive tight bounds for path reconstruction.

Key Insights and Results

The Power of Order

A critical observation of this work is that an ordered constraint of size $s$ is mathematically equivalent to $s-1$ specific subgraph connectivity constraints. This structural insight allows the authors to achieve an exponential improvement in competitive ratios for the online setting. While previous work on unordered constraints yielded a competitive ratio of $O(n^{2/3})$, this paper achieves $O(\log^2 n)$ for a polynomial number of constraints.

Performance Metrics

  • General Graphs: The online algorithm achieves a competitive ratio of $O((\log r + \log n) \log n)$, where $r$ is the number of constraints and $n$ is the number of nodes.
  • Star Topologies: If the optimal network is a star (a central hub), the algorithm achieves a competitive ratio of 1.5.
  • Path Topologies: If the optimal network is a path, the algorithm achieves a competitive ratio of 2. This result is particularly significant as it matches the known lower bound, proving the algorithm is optimal in the worst case.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a robust framework for reconstructing networks from propagation data. However, a logarithmic gap remains between the general online upper bound ($O(\log^2 n)$) and the lower bound ($\Omega(\log n)$).

Future work may address this gap or explore adaptive adversaries, where constraints are chosen dynamically based on the algorithm's prior edge selections. Additionally, extending these techniques to more complex graph classes, such as those with low treewidth, presents a promising avenue for further study.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we study the problem of constructing a network by observing ordered connectivity constraints, which we define herein. These ordered constraints are made to capture realistic properties of real-world problems that are not reflected in previous, more general models. We give hardness of approximation results and nearly-matching upper bounds for the offline problem, and we study the online problem in both general graphs and restricted sub-classes. In the online problem, for general graphs, we give exponentially better upper bounds than exist for algorithms for general connectivity problems. For the restricted classes of stars and paths we are able to find algorithms with optimal competitive ratios, the latter of which involve analysis using a potential function defined over pq-trees.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2017network,
  author = {Yi Huang and Mano Vikash Janardhanan and Lev Reyzin},
  title = {{Network Construction with Ordered Constraints}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1702.07292},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.07292},
}
Figure