Network changes associated with transdiagnostic depressive symptom improvement following cognitive behavioral therapy in MDD and PTSD

Zhen Yang, Shi Gu, Nicolas Honnorat, Kristin A. Linn, Russell T. Shinohara, Irem Aselcioglu, Steven E. Bruce, Desmond J. Oathes, Christos Davatzikos, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Danielle S. Bassett, Yvette I. ShelineMolecular 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Despite widespread use of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) in clinical practice, its mechanisms with respect to brain networks remain sparsely described. In this study, we applied tools from graph theory and network science to better understand the transdiagnostic neural mechanisms of this treatment for depression. A sample of 64 subjects was included in a study of network dynamics: 33 patients (15 MDD, 18 PTSD) received longitudinal fMRI resting state scans before and after 12 weeks of CBT. Depression severity was rated on the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS). Thirty-one healthy controls were included to determine baseline network roles. Univariate and multivariate regression analyses were conducted on the normalized change scores of within- and between-system connectivity and normalized change score of the MADRS. Penalized regression was used to select a sparse set of predictors in a data-driven manner. Univariate analyses showed greater symptom reduction was associated with an increased functional role of the Ventral Attention (VA) system as an incohesive provincial system (decreased between- and decreased within-system connectivity). Multivariate analyses selected between-system connectivity of the VA system as the most prominent feature associated with depression improvement. Observed VA system changes are interesting in light of brain controllability descriptions: attentional control systems, including the VA system, fall on the boundary between-network communities, and facilitate integration or segregation of diverse cognitive systems. Thus, increasing segregation of the VA system following CBT (decreased between-network connectivity) may result in less contribution of emotional attention to cognitive processes, thereby potentially improving cognitive control.

Introduction

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is a cornerstone of treatment for mood and anxiety disorders, yet the large-scale neural network reconfigurations that underlie its clinical efficacy remain largely uncharacterized. Traditional neuroimaging often focuses on localized brain regions or single diagnostic categories. However, many psychiatric conditions share transdiagnostic symptoms, such as the depressive symptoms common to both Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). This study utilizes graph theory and network science to identify common neural mechanisms of symptom improvement following CBT across these diagnostic boundaries.

Methods

The study involved 64 female participants, including 33 patients (15 MDD, 18 PTSD) and 31 healthy controls. Patients underwent 12 weeks of manualized CBT, with resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI) scans conducted before and after treatment. Depressive symptoms were assessed using the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS).

The brain was modeled as a network of 220 nodes. Functional connectivity was estimated using wavelet coherence, a robust method for capturing frequency-specific neural signals while minimizing noise. To characterize the organizational changes, the researchers calculated within-system and between-system connectivity for various functional networks.

The network analysis pipeline: (A) mapping 220 nodes to functional systems, (B) extracting time series for wavelet coherence, and (C) generating the regional connectivity matrix.

Results

Following 12 weeks of CBT, patients experienced a significant 64.15% mean reduction in MADRS scores. Univariate analyses revealed that greater symptom reduction was specifically associated with changes in the Ventral Attention (VA) system. Specifically, the VA system shifted toward an "incohesive provincial" role, characterized by decreased within-system and decreased between-system connectivity.

Multivariate Elastic Net regression confirmed the importance of the VA system, selecting its between-system connectivity as the most prominent predictor of clinical improvement among 21 potential network predictors. A strong correlation (partial $r = 0.71$, $p < 0.001$) was observed between decreased VA between-system connectivity and symptom reduction.

Classification of brain system roles based on connectivity metrics. Symptom improvement was linked to the VA system becoming an 'incohesive provincial' system.

Discussion

The Ventral Attention (VA) system is primarily responsible for detecting salient environmental stimuli. In the context of depression, an overactive or overly integrated VA system may allow emotional "noise" to interfere with higher-order cognitive processes. The findings suggest that CBT facilitates the segregation of the VA system. By reducing its connectivity with other networks, the brain may become better at "shielding" cognitive control systems from emotional distractions. This increased segregation likely enhances cognitive control, providing a transdiagnostic neural mechanism for the therapeutic effects of CBT.

Limitations

The study's focus on a female-only sample limits generalizability to male populations. Additionally, the lack of an active control group (e.g., a waitlist group) makes it difficult to isolate the effects of CBT from the passage of time. Future research with larger, more diverse cohorts is needed to validate the VA system as a robust biomarker for treatment response.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite widespread use of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) in clinical practice, its mechanisms with respect to brain networks remain sparsely described. In this study, we applied tools from graph theory and network science to better understand the transdiagnostic neural mechanisms of this treatment for depression. A sample of 64 subjects was included in a study of network dynamics: 33 patients (15 MDD, 18 PTSD) received longitudinal fMRI resting state scans before and after 12 weeks of CBT. Depression severity was rated on the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS). Thirty-one healthy controls were included to determine baseline network roles. Univariate and multivariate regression analyses were conducted on the normalized change scores of within- and between-system connectivity and normalized change score of the MADRS. Penalized regression was used to select a sparse set of predictors in a data-driven manner. Univariate analyses showed greater symptom reduction was associated with an increased functional role of the Ventral Attention (VA) system as an incohesive provincial system (decreased between- and decreased within-system connectivity). Multivariate analyses selected between-system connectivity of the VA system as the most prominent feature associated with depression improvement. Observed VA system changes are interesting in light of brain controllability descriptions: attentional control systems, including the VA system, fall on the boundary between-network communities, and facilitate integration or segregation of diverse cognitive systems. Thus, increasing segregation of the VA system following CBT (decreased between-network connectivity) may result in less contribution of emotional attention to cognitive processes, thereby potentially improving cognitive control.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2018network,
  author = {Zhen Yang and Shi Gu and Nicolas Honnorat and Kristin A. Linn and Russell T. Shinohara and Irem Aselcioglu and Steven E. Bruce and Desmond J. Oathes and Christos Davatzikos and Theodore D. Satterthwaite and Danielle S. Bassett and Yvette I. Sheline},
  title = {{Network changes associated with transdiagnostic depressive symptom improvement following cognitive behavioral therapy in MDD and PTSD}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41380-018-0201-7},
}
Figure