NEO-PGA: Nonvolatile Electro-Optically Programmable Gate Array

Arka Majumdar2023

TL;DR

This paper introduces the NEO-PGA, a nonvolatile electro-optically programmable gate array built using phase-change materials (PCMs) like Sb₂Se₃. This breakthrough offers a highly scalable, low-power, and reconfigurable photonic platform that overcomes the limitations of current thermo-optic approaches, paving the way for general-purpose on-chip photonic systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current programmable photonic integrated circuits (PICs), analogous to electronic FPGAs, face significant hurdles. They predominantly rely on thermo-optic tuning, which is power-hungry, bulky, and suffers from thermal crosstalk. These issues severely limit the density and scalability of these photonic circuits. While phase-change materials (PCMs) offer a promising nonvolatile alternative with substantial optical contrast, challenges like optical loss and precise multi-bit tuning have hindered their widespread adoption in large-scale PICs. This paper addresses these limitations by demonstrating precise, low-loss, and nonvolatile tuning of PCMs for scalable photonic gate arrays.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel "program-and-verify" algorithm with closed-loop feedback to achieve precise, multi-bit tuning of Sb₂Se₃ phase shifters. This method allows for accurate control of optical power transmission by iteratively adjusting voltage pulses based on real-time feedback. They integrated these PCM-based Mach-Zehnder Interferometer (MZI) meshes onto a 300 mm silicon photonic platform. Two key architectures were explored:

  • Circulating MZI meshes: Used for broadband optical switching and high-Q coupled resonators, enabling unprecedented local control of coupling rates.
  • Forward MZI meshes: Implemented as self-configurable MZIs capable of sorting orthogonal optical beams to different ports.

The fabrication process involved a scalable back-end-of-line (BEOL) integration of Sb₂Se₃ onto silicon photonic dies, utilizing electron-beam lithography for patterning.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nonvolatile, Precise Tuning is Achievable: The "program-and-verify" algorithm effectively overcomes the perceived stochasticity of PCMs, enabling highly accurate (within ~0.1% error) and bidirectional tuning of optical power. This is a critical step towards reliable PCM-based photonic devices.
  • Scalability and Low Power: The nonvolatile nature of PCMs eliminates static power consumption, a major advantage over thermo-optic solutions. The demonstrated integration on a 300 mm platform highlights the potential for large-scale integration.
  • Crosstalk Immunity: PCMs offer inherent crosstalk immunity, allowing for dense integration and sequential tuning without affecting adjacent components.
  • Versatile Functionality: The demonstrated circulating and forward MZI meshes showcase the ability to implement diverse functionalities, from optical circuit switching and tunable resonators to self-configurable beam sorters.
  • Challenging Prevalent Notions: The work directly challenges the community's belief that PCMs are unsuitable for high-accuracy tuning in programmable PICs.

Key Results

  • Accurate Tuning: Achieved transmission tuning with less than 0.1% error using the "program-and-verify" algorithm.
  • Low Loss: Demonstrated low insertion loss for PCM phase shifters (~0.03 dB/π) and high intrinsic Q-factors for microring resonators (> 226,000).
  • Optical Circuit Switching (OCS): Implemented a 4x4 OCS fabric with broadband optical signal routing and crosstalk below -25 dB.
  • Programmable Coupled Resonators: Realized tunable coupling rates in microring resonators, enabling transitions from over-coupled to critically coupled regimes.
  • Self-Configurable PICs: Demonstrated sorting of orthogonal optical beams with crosstalk below -12 dB.
  • Nonvolatile Operation: The demonstrated devices maintain their programmed state without continuous power, offering zero static power consumption.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reduced Contrast: The authors acknowledge a gradual loss of contrast with repeated switching cycles, particularly for large transmission changes. This is attributed to material deposition issues and is expected to be addressable with improved material quality and processing.
  • Limited Tuning Range: The reversible phase shift achieved in their experiment (~0.23π) was insufficient to fully switch MZIs between bar and cross states, requiring high-contrast switching in some instances. Future work aims to increase this tuning range.
  • External Feedback: The current "program-and-verify" method relies on external power monitors. Future work suggests incorporating on-chip waveguide taps or transparent in-circuit detectors for a fully self-reconfigurable system.
  • Independent Phase Control: For self-configurable PICs, achieving independent phase control for each arm of an MZI is crucial for minimizing crosstalk. The authors suggest adding external phase shifters to address this.
  • Scalability of OCS: While a 1x2 mesh was demonstrated, achieving non-blocking OCS for larger systems would require larger meshes or different architectures.

The authors envision future studies exploring topological photonics and realizing complex Hamiltonians using these PCM-tunable coupled ring systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this talk, I will discuss different phase change materials that can be used in conjunction with silicon and silicon nitride photonics, to create reconfigurable optical switches for visible and infrared wavelengths Full-text article not available; see video presentation
BibTeX
@misc{majumdar2023neo,
  author = {Arka Majumdar},
  title = {{NEO-PGA: Nonvolatile Electro-Optically Programmable Gate Array}},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure