Negative feedback avalanche diodes for near-infrared single-photon detection

Xudong Jiang, Mark A. Itzler, B.m. Nyman, Krystyna SlomkowskiProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Negative Feedback Avalanche Diodes (NFADs) for near-infrared single-photon detection. By integrating a passive negative feedback element directly onto InP-based SPADs, these new devices overcome the limitations of traditional SPADs, offering higher counting rates and the potential for photon number resolution, crucial for advanced applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting single photons in the near-infrared (NIR) spectrum (1.0-1.7 µm) is vital for numerous applications, including quantum cryptography, lidar, and optical communications. InP-based Single Photon Avalanche Diodes (SPADs) are a leading technology for this, operating in "Geiger mode." However, their inherent avalanche process creates a positive feedback loop, leading to two major drawbacks: a limited photon counting rate (typically around 1 MHz) and an inability to distinguish between different numbers of incoming photons. These limitations restrict their use in demanding scenarios. This paper aims to address these issues by introducing a novel device architecture.

Methods

The core innovation presented is the Negative Feedback Avalanche Diode (NFAD). This device is created by monolithically integrating a passive negative feedback element (specifically, a resistor) directly onto a high-performance InP-based SPAD. This integrated resistor serves a dual purpose: it helps to rapidly quench the avalanche process and simultaneously regulates the flow of charge during an avalanche event. The authors describe the design and operation of these NFADs, focusing on their pulse response, quenching dynamics, and how these characteristics are influenced by the excess bias voltage applied and the number of incident photons. They also detail the experimental setup used for characterizing these devices, which involves biasing the NFAD above breakdown, amplifying the avalanche pulses, and recording them with a high-resolution digital scope or data acquisition card.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the characterization of newly fabricated devices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Negative Feedback is Key: The monolithic integration of a resistor directly onto the SPAD is the crucial element that enables the NFAD's improved performance. This is more than just passive quenching; it actively regulates the avalanche.
  • Overcoming SPAD Limitations: NFADs directly tackle the low counting rate and lack of photon number resolution inherent in standard SPADs, opening doors for more sophisticated applications.
  • Reduced Avalanche Charge: The integrated resistor significantly reduces the total charge involved in an avalanche event (from ~10⁷-10⁸ carriers in SPADs to ~10 in NFADs). This is directly linked to reduced afterpulsing.
  • Potential for Photon Number Resolution: By controlling the avalanche charge, NFAD arrays could potentially resolve the number of incident photons, a capability not present in standard SPADs. This is particularly relevant for quantum computing.
  • Persistent Current Phenomena: One of the NFAD devices (D3F7) exhibited a "persistent current" phenomenon at higher overbias voltages, where a steady current flows before quenching. This is not observed in the other NFAD (E4G8) due to its higher resistance, which quenches avalanches more rapidly. This phenomenon offers a unique avenue for studying carrier dynamics within APDs.
  • Device-Specific Behavior: The two NFAD iterations (D3F7 and E4G8) showed distinct behaviors, particularly regarding their sensitivity to overbias voltage. E4G8's pulse amplitude and charge flow were insensitive to overbias, suggesting the integrated resistor plays a role in regulating avalanche generation from the outset, not just quenching.

Key Results

  • Reduced Afterpulsing: The reduced avalanche charge in NFADs leads to significantly reduced afterpulsing, a common issue in SPADs that can lead to false counts.
  • Improved Counting Rate Potential: The fast quenching and reduced charge flow are expected to enable much higher photon counting rates than standard SPADs.
  • Device Characterization: The paper presents detailed characterization of two NFAD devices (D3F7 and E4G8), including their avalanche pulse shapes, pulse height distributions, avalanche charge distributions, and interarrival time distributions.
  • Persistent Current: For device D3F7, a persistent current was observed with typical oscillation amplitudes of ~5 mV and periods of ~11 ns at 72.6 V and 230 K.
  • Photon Detection Efficiency: For D3F7, intrinsic photon detection efficiencies of 3% and 7% were extracted at overbias voltages of 0.2 V and 0.7 V, respectively, showing good agreement with simulations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Afterpulsing at Higher Overbias: While NFADs reduce afterpulsing, it can still become an issue at higher overbias voltages. The authors suggest that current NFAD designs might be constrained to lower overbias operation where afterpulsing is insignificant.
  • Persistent Current Impact: The persistent current phenomenon observed in D3F7, while interesting for study, is detrimental to detector performance as it means the device is not armed for new photon detections.
  • Future Work: The authors imply that further optimization of the integrated resistor value and device design could mitigate the limitations of afterpulsing and persistent current, making NFADs even more robust for a wider range of applications. The potential for photon number resolution in NFAD arrays also warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years significant progress has been made in near-infrared single photon detection using Geiger-mode InP-based single photon avalanche diodes (SPADs). A more detailed understanding of these detectors with regard to device design, material growth and device fabrication has led to continual performance improvements. A variety of circuits for enabling SPAD Geiger-mode operation have been proposed and demonstrated as well. However, due to the inherent positive feedback nature of the avalanche process, Geiger-mode SPADs are constrained by certain performance limitations, particularly with regard to counting rate and the absence of photon number resolution. These limitations hinder the use of SPADs in certain applications. By incorporating a negative feedback mechanism into InP-based SPADs, these SPAD performance limitations can be overcome. In this paper, we present a negative feedback avalanche diode (NFAD), which is formed by monolithically integrating a passive negative feedback element with a high-performance InP-based SPAD. We describe the design and operation of the NFAD device, along with basic characteristics such as pulse response and quenching dynamics, as well as the dependence of these characteristics on excess bias voltage and input photon number. We will also review the results of near-infrared single photon counting performance for fundamental performance parameters such as photon detection efficiency, dark count rate, and afterpulsing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2009negative,
  author = {Xudong Jiang and Mark A. Itzler and B.M. Nyman and Krystyna Slomkowski},
  title = {{Negative feedback avalanche diodes for near-infrared single-photon detection}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1117/12.818681},
}
Figure