Needs and Gaps in Optical Underwater Technologies and Methods for the Investigation of Marine Animal Forest 3D-Structural Complexity

Paolo Rossi, Massimo Ponti, Sara Righi, Cristina Castagnetti, Roberto Simonini, Francesco Mancini, Panagiotis Agrafiotis, Leonardo Bassani, Fabio Bruno, Carlo Cerrano, Paolo Cignoni, Massimiliano Corsini, Pierre Drap, Marco Dubbini, Joaquim Garrabou, Andrea Gori, Nuno Gracias, Jean‐Baptiste Ledoux, Cristina Linares, Torcuato Pulido Mantas, Fabio Menna, Erica Nocerino, Marco Palma, Gaia Pavoni, Alessandro Ridolfi, Sérgio Rossi, Dimitrios Skarlatos, Tali Treibitz, Eva Turicchia, Matan Yuval, Alessandro CapraFrontiers in Marine Science 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Marine animal forests (MAFs) are benthic communities dominated by sessile suspension feeders (such as sponges, corals, and bivalves) able to generate three-dimensional (3D) frameworks with high structural complexity. The biodiversity and functioning of marine animal forests are strictly related to their 3D complexity. The present paper aims at providing new perspectives in underwater optical surveys. Starting from the current gaps in data collection and analysis that critically limit the study and conservation of marine animal forests, we discuss the main technological and methodological needs for the investigation of their 3D structural complexity at different spatial and temporal scales. Despite recent technological advances, several issues in data acquisition and processing need to be solved to properly map benthic habitats, assess health status, and measure structural complexity. Standardized methods and protocols are strictly necessary to meet the FAIR (findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reusability) data principles for the stewardship of habitat mapping and biodiversity data.

Introduction

Marine Animal Forests (MAFs) serve as the underwater equivalent of terrestrial forests, providing essential habitats that support global marine biodiversity. However, while terrestrial surfaces are mapped with high precision, only about 5% of the ocean floor has been accurately mapped at the community level. The core challenge lies in the immense 3D structural complexity of MAFs. Traditional 2D photo-sampling or manual scuba surveys are often insufficient—they are slow, low-resolution, and sometimes destructive. To effectively protect these ecosystems, researchers require non-destructive, high-resolution 3D models that can track growth, health, and structural shifts over time.

Technological Approaches Across Scales

There is no "one-size-fits-all" tool for investigating MAFs. The choice of technology depends heavily on the biological and spatial scale of the investigation, ranging from individual organisms (millimeter scale) to entire ecosystems (kilometer scale).

Figure 3: Integration of biological scales, spatial scales, and depth with corresponding underwater mapping technologies.

Key technologies currently in use include:

  • Underwater Photogrammetry (SfM/MVS): Utilizing "Structure from Motion" and "Multi-View Stereo" algorithms, this is the gold standard for low-cost, high-resolution 3D mapping.
  • Active Optical Imaging: Laser scanners and structured light provide millimeter-level precision for individual organisms.
  • SLAM (Simultaneous Localization and Mapping): These algorithms enable Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs) to navigate and map complex, uncharted environments in real-time.
  • Acoustic 3D Mapping: While lower in resolution than optical methods, acoustic sensors are essential for large-scale mapping (km scale) where light attenuation limits optical tools.

The Data Deluge and AI Integration

The field is currently facing a "data deluge," where millions of underwater images are collected annually, far outpacing manual annotation capabilities. To bridge this gap, researchers are turning to Deep Learning architectures (such as U-Net and PointNet++) for semantic segmentation—automatically identifying and labeling species within 3D point clouds. Tools like TagLab are becoming critical for creating the annotated datasets required to train these AI models. However, a significant lack of standardized benchmark datasets remains a hurdle for developing more accurate, marine-specific AI.

From Data to Knowledge: The Path to Information Systems

For marine data to be truly useful for global conservation, it must transition from raw acquisition to structured knowledge. This requires adherence to the FAIR principles: making data Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable.

Figure 4: Conceptual workflow for transforming raw underwater data into actionable knowledge and integrated information systems.

Currently, much of the data remains siloed in disparate formats. The development of common "ontologies" (standardized naming and classification systems) is essential to combine data from different expeditions into a single, global Information System for the oceans. This workflow involves improving acquisition, standardizing formats, and utilizing machine learning to extract meaningful ecological information from 3D models.

Future Directions and Limitations

Despite progress, several bottlenecks persist. Underwater optical surveys are hindered by light absorption, scattering, and "caustics" (flickering light patterns) that confuse mapping algorithms. Furthermore, 3D reconstruction struggles with "flexible" organisms like sea fans that move with currents, leading to alignment errors.

Future work must focus on:

  1. Human-in-the-loop AI: Developing "assisted" tools where experts can refine AI predictions to ensure high accuracy.
  2. Autonomous Navigation: Enhancing AUV decision-making to navigate the complex crevices and overhangs of MAFs without damaging delicate structures.
  3. Volumetric Analysis: Moving beyond "pretty pictures" to use 3D models for measuring actual volumetric changes, which 2D orthophotos often obscure.

By addressing these technological and methodological gaps, the scientific community can better monitor and conserve the vital 3D frameworks of our global marine animal forests.

Summary updated

Abstract

Marine animal forests are benthic communities dominated by sessile suspension feeders (such as sponges, corals, and bivalves) able to generate three-dimensional (3D) frameworks with high structural complexity. The biodiversity and functioning of marine animal forests are strictly related to their 3D complexity. The present paper aims at providing new perspectives in underwater optical surveys. Starting from the current gaps in data collection and analysis that critically limit the study and conservation of marine animal forests, we discuss the main technological and methodological needs for the investigation of their 3D structural complexity at different spatial and temporal scales. Despite recent technological advances, it seems that several issues in data acquisition and processing need to be solved, to properly map the different benthic habitats in which marine animal forests are present, their health status and to measure structural complexity. Proper precision and accuracy should be chosen and assured in relation to the biological and ecological processes investigated. Besides, standardized methods and protocols are strictly necessary to meet the FAIR (findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reusability) data principles for the stewardship of habitat mapping and biodiversity, biomass, and growth data.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rossi2021needs,
  author = {Paolo Rossi and Massimo Ponti and Sara Righi and Cristina Castagnetti and Roberto Simonini and Francesco Mancini and Panagiotis Agrafiotis and Leonardo Bassani and Fabio Bruno and Carlo Cerrano and Paolo Cignoni and Massimiliano Corsini and Pierre Drap and Marco Dubbini and Joaquim Garrabou and Andrea Gori and Nuno Gracias and Jean‐Baptiste Ledoux and Cristina Linares and Torcuato Pulido Mantas and Fabio Menna and Erica Nocerino and Marco Palma and Gaia Pavoni and Alessandro Ridolfi and Sérgio Rossi and Dimitrios Skarlatos and Tali Treibitz and Eva Turicchia and Matan Yuval and Alessandro Capra},
  title = {{Needs and Gaps in Optical Underwater Technologies and Methods for the Investigation of Marine Animal Forest 3D-Structural Complexity}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2021.591292},
}
Figure