TL;DR
This paper revisits the long-standing question of time reversal symmetry (TRI) in systems subjected to magnetic fields, a topic crucial for understanding Onsager reciprocal relations. The authors generalize the concept of time reversal operations beyond the standard definition, demonstrating that TRI holds under a much wider set of conditions than previously thought, thereby explaining the lack of observed violations of Onsager relations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The fundamental principle of time reversal invariance (TRI) is central to many physical theories, including statistical mechanics. A key consequence of TRI is the celebrated Onsager reciprocal relations, which govern the relationships between transport coefficients in systems. However, it was long believed that TRI, and consequently the standard Onsager relations, do not hold in the presence of a magnetic field. This led to modifications of the relations, such as those proposed by Casimir. More recently, the strict definition of reversibility has been questioned, and it's been shown that alternative symmetries can preserve the Onsager relations even with magnetic fields. This paper aims to systematically identify all possible time reversal operations for classical Hamiltonian systems in the presence of magnetic fields and establish the necessary and sufficient conditions for TRI to hold, thus broadening the applicability of Onsager's principle.
Methods
The authors approach this problem by first defining a generalized time reversal operation on the phase space of a classical Hamiltonian system. They then derive the most general form of such an operation, which must be an involution (applying it twice returns the system to its original state). This involves exploring permutations of coordinates and momenta, along with sign changes.
Crucially, the paper then focuses on how these generalized time reversal operations interact with a magnetic field. They analyze the conditions under which the Hamiltonian remains invariant under these transformations, even in the presence of a magnetic vector potential. This involves investigating the behavior of the vector potential under these symmetry operations and considering gauge transformations. The analysis leads to specific algebraic conditions on the magnetic field and the potential that ensure TRI.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond the Standard Time Reversal: The paper moves beyond the canonical time reversal operation (reversing momenta and magnetic field) to explore a much larger set of generalized time reversal transformations.
- Magnetic Field is Not Always a "Symmetry Breaker": Contrary to earlier beliefs, the presence of a magnetic field does not universally break time reversal symmetry. Specific conditions on the magnetic field and the system's potential can preserve TRI.
- Gauge Freedom is Key: The authors highlight the importance of gauge freedom in the vector potential. By appropriately choosing a gauge, TRI can be maintained even when the magnetic field itself seems to break it.
- Explaining the Absence of Violations: The broad conditions under which TRI holds provide a theoretical basis for why experimental violations of Onsager reciprocal relations have not been observed, even in systems with magnetic fields.
Key Results
The paper identifies 20 distinct generalized time reversal transformations for a single particle. It then establishes necessary and sufficient algebraic conditions for these transformations to preserve TRI in the presence of a magnetic field. These conditions relate the components of the magnetic field and the vector potential to the specific time reversal operation being considered. For systems with potentials, an additional condition is derived, requiring the potential to be invariant under the generalized time reversal operation. The paper illustrates these findings with examples of common potentials, such as the Coulomb potential, showing how they can satisfy the derived conditions.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the explicit verification of the derived conditions for complex potentials, particularly those involving polarization interactions (like the Polarisable Ion Model), remains challenging and often requires approximations or numerical analysis. They also note that their current work focuses on classical systems and suggest that extending these results to the relativistic case and to interacting quantum particles would be a significant future direction. The paper also hints at investigating the necessary conditions for Onsager reciprocal relations, which could lead to the discovery of non-dissipative currents, a phenomenon yet to be observed.
Summary updated