Natural variation in infection specificity of Caenorhabditis briggsae isolates by two RNA viruses

Cigdem Alkan, Gautier Brésard, Lise Frézal, Aurélien Richaud, Albane Ruaud, Gaotian Zhang, Marie-Anne FélixbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Antagonistic relationships such as host-virus interactions potentially lead to rapid evolution and specificity in interactions. The Orsay virus is so far the only horizontal virus naturally infecting the nematode C. elegans. In contrast, several related RNA viruses infect its congener C. briggsae, including Santeuil (SANTV) and Le Blanc (LEBV) viruses. Here we focus on the host’s intraspecific variation in sensitivity to these two intestinal viruses. Many temperate-origin C. briggsae strains, including JU1264 and JU1498, are sensitive to both, while many tropical strains, such as AF16, are resistant to both. Interestingly, some C. briggsae strains exhibit a specific resistance, such as the HK104 strain, specifically resistant to LEBV. The viral sensitivity pattern matches the strains’ geographic and genomic relationships. The heavily infected strains mount a seemingly normal small RNA response that is insufficient to suppress viral infection, while the resistant strains show no small RNA response, suggesting an early block in viral entry or replication. We use a genetic approach from the host side to map genomic regions participating in viral resistance polymorphisms. Using Advanced Intercrossed Recombinant Inbred Lines (RILs) between virus-resistant AF16 and SANTV-sensitive HK104, we detect Quantitative Trait Loci (QTLs) on chromosomes IV and III. Building RILs between virus-sensitive JU1498 and LEBV-resistant HK104 followed by bulk segregant analysis, we identify a chromosome II QTL. In both cases, further introgressions of the regions confirmed the QTLs. This diversity provides an avenue for studying virus entry, replication, and exit mechanisms, as well as host-virus specificity and the host response to a specific virus infection.

Introduction

In the natural world, hosts and pathogens are locked in a perpetual "arms race," where each side rapidly evolves to overcome the other's defenses. While the model organism Caenorhabditis elegans has only one known natural virus (Orsay virus), its close relative C. briggsae is susceptible to several, including the Santeuil (SANTV) and Le Blanc (LEBV) viruses. This study investigates the genetic basis of host-virus specificity in C. briggsae, exploring why certain strains exhibit resistance to both viruses, sensitivity to both, or specific resistance to only one.

A strong correlation exists between a strain's geographic origin and its viral sensitivity. Tropical strains, such as the reference AF16, tend to be "pan-resistant," whereas temperate strains, like those from France, are often "pan-sensitive." The Japanese strain HK104 presents a unique case: it is sensitive to SANTV but completely resistant to LEBV, suggesting that resistance to these two related viruses is governed by distinct genetic mechanisms.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged genetic and molecular approach to map resistance:

  • Infection Assays: Viruses were introduced via the fecal-oral route. Infection was monitored using Fluorescent In Situ Hybridization (FISH) to visualize viral RNA in intestinal cells and RT-qPCR to quantify viral load.
  • Small RNA Sequencing: To evaluate the host immune response, small RNAs (the primary antiviral defense in nematodes) were sequenced to compare responses across different strains.
  • Genetic Mapping: Advanced Intercrossed Recombinant Inbred Lines (AI-RILs) and Bulk Segregant Analysis (BSA) were used to cross-reference phenotypes with genotypes.
  • Near Isogenic Lines (NILs): Specific genomic regions from resistant strains were introgressed into sensitive ones to confirm the impact of identified loci.
  • CRISPR-Cas9: Targeted gene editing was used to test candidate genes within the identified regions.

Results

The "Early Block" Hypothesis

In resistant strains, researchers observed a total absence of viral small RNAs. This suggests that the virus is blocked at a very early stage—likely entry into the cell or the initiation of replication—preventing the host's RNA interference (RNAi) machinery from detecting the invader. Conversely, sensitive strains (like JU1264) mounted a robust small RNA response that was ultimately insufficient to stop the virus, indicating that sensitivity is not due to a "broken" immune system but a failure to prevent the virus from overwhelming the host.

Mapping Resistance QTLs

The study identified complex genetic architectures for viral resistance. For SANTV, a major locus was found on Chromosome IV and a minor one on Chromosome III. For LEBV, a major locus was identified on the right tip of Chromosome II.

Summary of QTL mapping results for SANTV and LEBV resistance in C. briggsae.

The SANTV resistance locus on Chromosome IV was narrowed to a region between 10.0 and 10.8 Mb. The LEBV resistance locus on Chromosome II was restricted to a 0.55 Mb interval (16.05–16.6 Mb). Despite testing candidate genes like CBG01824 and Cbr-rsd-2 via CRISPR, swapping these alleles did not fully recreate the resistance phenotype, suggesting that the causal variants remain to be identified within these QTL regions.

Discussion and Future Work

While this study successfully mapped major loci for viral resistance, the exact causal genes remain elusive. The identified intervals contain numerous polymorphisms, and the results suggest that resistance may be polygenic or involve complex structural variations.

Future research will focus on refining the QTLs using CRISPR-mediated recombination to shrink the genomic intervals. Additionally, the Chromosome II locus will be investigated to determine if it encodes a specific receptor required for LEBV entry. Comparative genomics using long-read assemblies for non-reference strains may also help identify hidden structural variants driving these resistance phenotypes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Antagonistic relationships such as host-virus interactions potentially lead to rapid evolution and specificity in interactions. The Orsay virus is so far the only horizontal virus naturally infecting the nematode C. elegans . In contrast, several related RNA viruses infect its congener C. briggsae , including Santeuil (SANTV) and Le Blanc (LEBV) viruses. Here we focus on the host’s intraspecific variation in sensitivity to these two intestinal viruses. Many temperate-origin C. briggsae strains, including JU1264 and JU1498, are sensitive to both, while many tropical strains, such as AF16, are resistant to both. Interestingly, some C. briggsae strains exhibit a specific resistance, such as the HK104 strain, specifically resistant to LEBV. The viral sensitivity pattern matches the strains’ geographic and genomic relationships. The heavily infected strains mount a seemingly normal small RNA response that is insufficient to suppress viral infection, while the resistant strains show no small RNA response, suggesting an early block in viral entry or replication. We use a genetic approach from the host side to map genomic regions participating in viral resistance polymorphisms. Using Advanced Intercrossed Recombinant Inbred Lines (RILs) between virus-resistant AF16 and SANTV-sensitive HK104, we detect Quantitative Trait Loci (QTLs) on chromosomes IV and III. Building RILs between virus-sensitive JU1498 and LEBV-resistant HK104 followed by bulk segregant analysis, we identify a chromosome II QTL. In both cases, further introgressions of the regions confirmed the QTLs. This diversity provides an avenue for studying virus entry, replication, and exit mechanisms, as well as host-virus specificity and the host response to a specific virus infection.
BibTeX
@misc{alkan2024natural,
  author = {Cigdem Alkan and Gautier Brésard and Lise Frézal and Aurélien Richaud and Albane Ruaud and Gaotian Zhang and Marie-Anne Félix},
  title = {{Natural variation in infection specificity of <i>Caenorhabditis briggsae</i> isolates by two RNA viruses}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.02.10.579610},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure