Natural History of Quantitative Fatty Infiltration and 3D Muscle Volume After Nonoperative Treatment of Symptomatic Rotator Cuff Tears

Bettina Hochreiter, Christoph Germann, Georg C. Feuerriegel, Reto Sutter, Farah Selman, Maximilian Gressl, Eugene T. Ek, Karl WieserJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantitatively tracks changes in rotator cuff muscle health (fatty infiltration and volume) over time in patients treated non-operatively. It identifies specific MRI-detectable thresholds for tear size and initial fatty infiltration that predict significant muscle degeneration, offering valuable insights for guiding treatment decisions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rotator cuff tears are common, and while surgical repair is an option, nonoperative management is often attempted first. A key concern with nonoperative treatment is the potential for rotator cuff muscles to degenerate over time, specifically through increased fatty infiltration (FI) and muscle atrophy. This degeneration can negatively impact shoulder function and the success of future surgical repairs. Previous methods for assessing FI, like the Goutallier classification, were qualitative and single-slice, limiting their precision. This paper addresses the need for a more quantitative understanding of how rotator cuff muscles change naturally over time without surgery, and crucially, to identify early predictors of this degeneration. This knowledge is vital for counseling patients on the optimal timing for surgical intervention.

Methods

The researchers prospectively enrolled 79 patients with symptomatic full-thickness rotator cuff tears who underwent nonoperative treatment and had at least two MRI scans. They utilized advanced MRI techniques:

  • Quantitative Fatty Infiltration (FI) Measurement: Instead of qualitative grading, they used 6-point Dixon MRI sequences to measure the fat fraction (FF) within the supraspinatus (SSP) muscle. This was done by manually placing a region of interest on three specific sagittal slices and calculating the arithmetic mean (FISSP). This approach provides a precise, quantitative measure of muscle fat content.
  • 3D Muscle Volume Measurement: They also measured the 3D volume of the SSP muscle.
  • Tear Characterization: Standard MRI parameters like tear location, size (mediolateral and anteroposterior), and Goutallier grade were also evaluated.

The study compared initial MRI findings with follow-up scans (after a minimum of 3 months of nonoperative management) to track changes in FISSP and muscle volume. They then used statistical analyses, including logistic regression, to identify predictors of relevant FI progression.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 79 patients who underwent two MRI scans at the Department of Orthopaedics, Balgrist University Hospital, University of Zurich, between July 2016 and February 2023. This dataset was collected prospectively for the study. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quantitative FI is Crucial: Moving beyond qualitative assessments like the Goutallier classification is essential for accurately tracking muscle degeneration. The FISSP measurement provides a more precise and reliable metric.
  • Predictors of Degeneration Exist: The study identified specific, measurable thresholds on the initial MRI that strongly predict future fatty infiltration progression. This is a significant step towards personalized risk assessment.
  • Tear Size Matters: Larger tears, particularly in the mediolateral dimension (≥20 mm), are associated with a higher risk of FI progression. This suggests that the mechanical disruption and subsequent healing response (or lack thereof) play a critical role.
  • Initial Muscle Health is Key: A higher initial FISSP (≥9.9%) is also a strong predictor, indicating that muscles already showing some fat infiltration are more prone to further degeneration.
  • Combined Risk Factors are Powerful: Combining multiple risk factors (large tear size, high initial FISSP) significantly increases the predictive power for future degeneration, reaching an impressive AUC of 0.913.

Key Results

  • Progression Rates: Approximately 14% of tears showed relevant FI progression (≥4.5%) over a mean follow-up of 19.5 months.
  • Muscle Volume Loss: 21.5% of shoulders showed a loss of ≥5 mm³ in SSP muscle volume.
  • Tear Enlargement: 21.5% of shoulders showed an increase in tear size (≥5 mm).
  • Risk Factor Thresholds:
    • A mediolateral tear size of ≥20 mm was associated with an 81.8% progression rate (OR 19.0).
  • An initial FISSP of ≥9.9% was associated with a 72.7% progression rate (OR 17.5).
  • An anteroposterior tear size of ≥17 mm was associated with a 72.7% progression rate (OR 8.0).
  • Combined Predictive Model: A model combining these three factors predicted a 91% chance of ≥4.5% FISSP progression within a mean of 19.5 months.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Lack of Clinical Correlation: The study focused on radiographic factors and did not directly correlate FI progression with clinical outcomes like strength or functional scores. This is a crucial next step.
  • Selection Bias: The study might have a selection bias, as patients with very large tears or those deemed at high risk for progression might have been more likely to receive surgical treatment and thus excluded.
  • Influence of Conservative Treatment: Treatments like corticosteroid injections could potentially influence FI, and this was not controlled for.
  • Variability in Follow-up: The time between MRI scans was surgeon-dependent, introducing some variability.

Future work should focus on correlating these quantitative MRI findings with clinical outcomes, investigating the impact of different nonoperative treatment modalities, and validating these predictive thresholds in larger, more diverse patient populations. The authors suggest that tears not meeting these established cutoff values might be managed non-operatively for at least 12 months with a high degree of assurance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diagnostic Level II . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
BibTeX
@article{hochreiter2024natural,
  author = {Bettina Hochreiter and Christoph Germann and Georg C. Feuerriegel and Reto Sutter and Farah Selman and Maximilian Gressl and Eugene T. Ek and Karl Wieser},
  title = {{Natural History of Quantitative Fatty Infiltration and 3D Muscle Volume After Nonoperative Treatment of Symptomatic Rotator Cuff Tears}},
  journal = {Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2106/jbjs.23.01083},
}
Figure