Natural History of Degenerative Hip Abductor Tendon Lesions

Pascal Schenk, Dimitris Dimitriou, Stefan Rahm, Stefan M. Zimmermann, Michael Finsterwald, Kai Higashigaito, Reto Sutter, Patrick O. ZinggThe American Journal of Sports Medicine 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the natural progression of degenerative hip abductor tendon lesions in patients treated non-operatively. It reveals that while about a third of these lesions show some progression on MRI over several years, partial tears tend to remain stable, and clinical outcomes are comparable to those reported for surgical interventions. This suggests non-operative management may be a viable long-term option, particularly for partial tears.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Greater trochanteric pain syndrome (GTPS) is a common and debilitating condition, often linked to degenerative lesions of the hip abductor tendons (gluteus medius and minimus). While surgical repair is frequently recommended for persistent symptoms or diagnosed tears, the natural course of these degenerative lesions when treated non-operatively has remained largely uncharacterized. This lack of understanding creates uncertainty regarding the optimal treatment strategy. This paper aims to fill that knowledge gap by longitudinally tracking patients with degenerative hip abductor lesions who did not undergo surgery, to understand how these lesions evolve over time and how this progression impacts clinical outcomes.

Methods

This was a prospective, observational study (case series with a prognosis design). The researchers recruited patients diagnosed with GTPS and degenerative changes in their hip abductor tendons via MRI. These patients underwent a clinical examination and bilateral hip MRI at the initial presentation and then again at a minimum follow-up of 36 months.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • MRI Analysis: Standardized MRI sequences were used to assess the type and location of hip abductor lesions. Lesions were classified from least to most severe: trochanteric bursitis, tendinopathy, partial tear, scar, and complete tear. Fatty infiltration (FI) of the gluteus medius (Gmed) and gluteus minimus (Gmin) muscles was graded using a modified Goutallier/Fuchs classification.
  • Definition of Progression: Lesion progression was defined as an increase in severity (e.g., tendinopathy to partial tear) or extension to an initially uninvolved trochanteric facet. Stable lesions were those that did not worsen or extend.
  • Clinical Assessment: At follow-up, patients were assessed for pain using a visual analog scale (VAS), hip abductor function (Trendelenburg gait), and functional outcomes using the Harris Hip Score (HHS) and Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC).
  • Statistical Analysis: Descriptive statistics were used, and comparisons between groups (progressed vs. stable lesions) were made using t-tests, Mann-Whitney tests, and logistic regression to identify potential risk factors for progression.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from patients undergoing clinical examination and MRI at their institution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-operative Management is Viable for Many: The study suggests that non-operative treatment can be a reasonable long-term strategy for degenerative hip abductor lesions, especially for partial tears.
  • Partial Tears Tend to Be Stable: A significant finding is that approximately 90% of partial tears remained stable or transformed into scar tissue over the follow-up period, indicating a low risk of clinically significant worsening.
  • Lesion Progression Occurs, But Not Universally: About one-third of lesions showed progression on MRI over an average of 71 months. This progression could be from bursitis to tendinopathy/partial tear, tendinopathy to partial tear, or partial to complete tear.
  • Pain is Linked to Progression, But Function Isn't Necessarily Worse: Patients with progressing lesions reported significantly more trochanteric pain (VAS) compared to those with stable lesions. However, functional outcomes (HHS, WOMAC) were comparable between the two groups.
  • Fatty Infiltration (FI) is Common, But Not Always Clinically Significant: While many patients showed progression in Gmin FI, particularly in those with partial tears, this often did not translate to significantly worse outcomes compared to the contralateral side. Gmed FI progression was less common and did not differ from the unaffected side.
  • No Clear Risk Factors for Progression Identified: Despite analyzing demographics, radiographic parameters, and initial lesion characteristics, the study did not find any significant predictors for lesion progression.

Key Results

  • Progression Rate: 34% of hip abductor lesions progressed over an average follow-up of 71 months.
  • Types of Progression: Common progressions included bursitis to tendinopathy/partial tear (14% and 8% respectively), tendinopathy to partial tear (6%), and partial to complete tear (4.7%).
  • Partial Tear Stability: 90% of partial tears remained stable or transformed into scar tissue.
  • Pain Differences: Patients with progressed lesions had a significantly higher VAS pain score (4.6) compared to those with stable lesions (2.8) (P = .001).
  • Functional Outcomes: Functional outcomes (HHS, WOMAC) were comparable between progressed and stable lesion groups.
  • Fatty Infiltration: Over two-thirds of hips with partial tears showed Gmin FI progression (from grade 1 to 2), but only one hip progressed to grade 3. Gmed FI progression was less common.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Inability to Measure Tear Size: The study could not accurately assess the size of tendon ruptures (length/width) due to the nature of degenerative tears (delamination without retraction) and MRI limitations.
  • No Serial MRIs: The average 6-year gap between initial and final MRIs meant the dynamics of lesion progression (sudden vs. gradual) could not be assessed.
  • No Control Group: A direct comparison with operatively treated hip abductor lesions was not possible; instead, results were compared to literature data.
  • Patient Selection Bias: 48% of eligible patients declined to participate, raising questions about whether the results fully represent the natural history of all patients.
  • Small Sample Size for Complete Tears: Only 3 patients with complete tears were included, limiting conclusions about their natural history.
  • Limited Functional Assessment: The WOMAC and HHS do not specifically assess sports activity, and VAS/clinical examination were not assessed at baseline, preventing a full picture of pain and functional changes from enrollment.

Future Work:

  • The authors call for prospective randomized controlled trials comparing non-operative and operative treatments for degenerative hip abductor lesions, ideally with serial MRI scans, to further clarify optimal management strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nonoperative treatment might be a valid long-term option for degenerative hip abductor lesions, especially for partial tears, which demonstrated a low risk of clinically relevant progression or muscle FI and similar clinical outcomes to those reported in the literature for operatively treated hip abductor tendon lesions.
BibTeX
@article{schenk2022natural,
  author = {Pascal Schenk and Dimitris Dimitriou and Stefan Rahm and Stefan M. Zimmermann and Michael Finsterwald and Kai Higashigaito and Reto Sutter and Patrick O. Zingg},
  title = {{Natural History of Degenerative Hip Abductor Tendon Lesions}},
  journal = {The American Journal of Sports Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1177/03635465221135759},
}
Figure