Natural Capital Evolution and Driving Forces in Energy-Rich and Ecologically Fragile Regions: A Case Study of Ningxia Province, China

Shanshan Guo, Yinghong Wang, Hou Hu-ping, Changyue Wu, Jing Yang, Wei He, Xiang LanSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the sustainability of natural capital utilization in Ningxia Province, China, an energy-rich yet ecologically fragile region. Using an enhanced three-dimensional ecological footprint model, it reveals a growing ecological deficit driven by increasing consumption, particularly of fossil fuels and cropland. The research identifies urbanization, GDP growth, and industrial output as key drivers of this unsustainable trend, offering crucial insights for policy development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical challenge of balancing economic development with the preservation of natural capital, especially in regions characterized by both abundant energy resources and ecological fragility. Ningxia Province, China, exemplifies this dilemma, facing increasing pressure on its environment due to rapid industrialization and urbanization. The core problem is understanding how natural capital is being utilized (both its stocks and flows) and what factors are driving unsustainable consumption patterns, leading to an ecological deficit. This is crucial for developing effective policies that promote sustainable development in such regions.

Methods

The study employs an improved three-dimensional ecological footprint (3D EF) model. This model builds upon existing EF frameworks by incorporating "ecological footprint depth" (EF depth) and "ecological footprint size" (EF size) to more accurately assess the utilization of natural capital stocks and flows, respectively. A key innovation is the adaptation of the 3D EF model to account for the specific contributions of different land use types, including forest land and grassland for carbon sinks, and the inclusion of fossil energy land. To identify the drivers of changes in natural capital stock consumption, the researchers utilized the Partial Least Squares (PLS) method. This statistical technique is well-suited for analyzing complex relationships with potentially multicollinear independent variables, allowing for the quantification of the influence of various socio-economic factors on the ecological footprint.

Datasets

The study utilizes annual data for Ningxia Province from 2004 to 2017. The specific datasets include:

  • Ningxia Statistical Yearbook (2005–2018): This source provided data on agricultural products, land use (cropland, grassland, forest land, water, built-up land), population, economic indicators (GDP, industrial output, retail sales), and resident consumption.
  • National Economy and Society Developed Statistical Bulletin (2004-2017): Used for data on agricultural products, land use, and economic indicators.
  • China Energy Statistical Yearbook (2005-2018): Provided data on energy consumption (coal, oil, natural gas, electricity).
  • Land Resources Data of the Ministry of Natural Resources (2004-2017): Used for land use data.
  • Overall Land Use Planning (2006-2020): Provided context for land use.
  • Working Guidebook to the National Footprint Accounts [31] and calculation of productivity factor for ecological footprints in China [32]: These provided methodological guidance and factors for calculations.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relies on publicly available statistical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Growing Ecological Deficit: Ningxia's ecological footprint is expanding much faster than its ecological capacity, leading to a significant and worsening ecological deficit. This highlights a fundamental imbalance between resource consumption and regeneration.
  • Fossil Fuels Dominate Footprint: The consumption of fossil energy land is the largest contributor to Ningxia's ecological footprint, underscoring the region's reliance on carbon-intensive energy sources.
  • Capital Stock Depletion is the Norm: The study reveals that natural capital stock consumption is not an anomaly but has become the norm in Ningxia, with the consumption of capital stock significantly exceeding capital flows. This is particularly severe for grassland, water, and fossil energy land.
  • Urbanization and Industrialization as Key Drivers: Socio-economic factors like urbanization rate, GDP growth, and the output of the secondary industry are identified as the primary drivers of increased natural capital stock consumption. This points to the direct link between economic expansion and environmental pressure.
  • Restoration Efforts Show Some Promise: Despite the overall negative trend, there are indications that ecological restoration measures (e.g., increased forest coverage) have had a positive effect, leading to a slight easing of the contradiction between resource supply and demand, as evidenced by the narrowing "scissors difference."

Key Results

  • Ecological Footprint Growth: The ecological footprint in Ningxia increased at an average annual rate of 4.52% from 2004 to 2017.
  • Ecological Deficit Growth: The ecological deficit grew even faster, at an annual rate of 6.8%, increasing from 1.64 to 3.85 gha/cap.
  • Capital Stock Overuse: By 2017, Ningxia was overusing its existing natural capital area by 3.41 times, a significant increase from 2.28 times in 2004.
  • Major Deficit Cities: Yinchuan and Shizuishan cities exhibited the largest ecological deficits, while Guyuan city managed to maintain an ecological surplus.
  • Driving Factors: The urbanization rate, GDP, secondary industry output value, and per capita urban consumption expenditure were identified as the most significant positive influences on natural capital stock consumption.
  • Water Scarcity: The stock consumption of water resources was particularly severe, being 233 times greater than its capital flows by 2017, reflecting the region's water scarcity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: While the study uses provincial data, finer-grained data at a sub-city or county level could provide more localized insights.
  • Model Assumptions: The ecological footprint model, even in its improved form, relies on certain assumptions and equivalencies that might not perfectly capture the complex ecological interactions in a region.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further promoting industrial structure transformation to reduce reliance on energy-intensive industries, leveraging renewable energy sources (solar and wind), strengthening economic cooperation along the Silk Road Economic Belt, controlling urban growth boundaries, and continuing ecological restoration projects in southern mountainous areas. They also emphasize the need for sustainable consumption patterns.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ningxia Province is rich in energy but fragile in ecology. How to coordinate sustainable utilization of natural capital and the fragile ecological environment is a significant guarantee for social-economic development. This study uses the improved three-dimensional ecological footprint to characterize the utilization status of natural capital flows and stocks in Ningxia Province from 2004 to 2017. Additionally, the driving factors behind changes in the natural capital stock are revealed by the partial least squares method (PLS). The results are as follows: (1) From 2004 to 2017, ecological footprint increased rapidly in Ningxia Province at an annual rate of 4.52%, resulting in a increase of the ecological deficit from 1.64 to 3.85 gha/cap at an annual rate of 6.8%, among which, Yinchuan city and Shizuishan city had the largest ecological deficit, while Guyuan city basically maintained ecological surplus. The fossil energy land and cropland were the main components of ecological footprint. (2) The consumption of capital stock in Ningxia Province continued to grow at an annual rate of 3.12%, from a value of 2.28 times overusing the existing area in 2004, increasing to 3.41 times in 2017. While the EF size increased slightly with an annual rate of 1.95%. The capital stock consumption was concentrated in Yinchuan and Shizuishan, and the capital flow consumption was concentrated in Wuzhong, Guyuan, and Zhongwei. (3) The capital flows of forest land and built-up land basically meet consumption demand, while the capital stock occupation of grassland, water and fossil energy land was serious. By 2017, the capital flow of cropland could basically satisfy people’s consumption demand. (4) The urbanization rate, GDP, the secondary industry output value and per capita consumption expenditure of urban residents were the main influence factors on the natural capital stock consumption. These findings not only are of real significance in promoting the coordinated development between economy and natural capital utilization in Ningxia Province but also have policy implications in improving the utilization efficiency of natural capital in energy-rich ecologically fragile regions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2020natural,
  author = {Shanshan Guo and Yinghong Wang and Hou Hu-ping and Changyue Wu and Jing Yang and Wei He and Xiang Lan},
  title = {{Natural Capital Evolution and Driving Forces in Energy-Rich and Ecologically Fragile Regions: A Case Study of Ningxia Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12020562},
}
Figure