National Variation in EMS Response and Antiepileptic Medication Administration for Children with Seizures in the Prehospital Setting

Maytal Firnberg, E. Brooke Lerner, Nan Nan, Chang‐Xing Ma, Manish I. Shah, N. Clay Mann, Peter DayanWestern 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The majority of children in the US receive ALS responses for seizures. Although medications are infrequently administered, the majority who received medications had midazolam given, which is the current standard of care. Further research should determine the proportion of children who are continuing to seize upon EMS arrival and would most benefit from immediate treatment.

Introduction

Status epilepticus, or a prolonged seizure, is a critical medical emergency where time is the most significant factor in patient outcomes. Delays in treatment are directly linked to increased morbidity, permanent neurological deficits, and higher mortality rates. Clinical guidelines emphasize the importance of administering antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) within five minutes of seizure onset to maximize efficacy.

In the United States, prehospital care is delivered through a tiered Emergency Medical Services (EMS) system. Basic Life Support (BLS) providers are generally restricted from administering controlled AEDs or performing advanced airway management. In contrast, Advanced Life Support (ALS) providers, such as paramedics, possess the training and scope of practice to deliver these life-saving interventions. Despite the importance of this distinction, there has historically been a lack of national-level data regarding whether pediatric patients across diverse geographies and demographics receive equitable access to ALS care and timely medication. This study sought to identify if factors such as a child’s zip code or gender influenced their access to prehospital seizure interventions.

Methods and Data

The researchers conducted a retrospective, cross-sectional analysis using the 2019 National Emergency Medical Services Information System (NEMSIS) Public Release Dataset (version 3). This massive repository contains over 22.5 million EMS activations from 9,599 agencies across 43 states and territories.

The study cohort was narrowed to 147,821 eligible pediatric patients (under 19 years old) who accessed 9-1-1 for seizures or convulsions. A unique aspect of this methodology was the analysis of both the dispatch reason (the initial report from the caller) and the provider impression (the assessment made by the medic on the scene) to capture a more comprehensive picture of field decision-making.

Figure 1: Patient selection flowchart from the 2019 NEMSIS database, illustrating the funnel from total encounters to medication administration.

The primary outcomes measured were the receipt of an ALS response—defined as the dispatch of a paramedic, Advanced EMT, or ALS-intermediate responder—and the actual administration of seizure-abortive medications (such as midazolam or lorazepam). The team utilized multivariable logistic regression to control for covariates including age, gender, U.S. census region, and "urbanicity" (categorized via USDA Urban Influence Codes into urban, suburban, rural, and wilderness).

Results

The Rural-Urban Divide

Geography emerged as a primary determinant of the level of care provided. While 88% of pediatric seizure calls overall received an ALS response, there was a significant drop-off in remote areas. Children in "wilderness" areas were 56% less likely (adjusted Odds Ratio [aOR] 0.44) to receive an ALS response compared to those in urban environments. Rural locations also showed a lower likelihood of ALS dispatch (aOR 0.79).

Figure 3: Adjusted odds ratios for receiving an ALS response based on demographic and geographic factors, highlighting the significant disparity for wilderness and rural areas.

Medication Administration and Timing

Only 9% of children with a provider impression of seizure actually received antiepileptic medication. While many seizures resolve spontaneously before EMS arrival, this low percentage suggests potential windows for improved intervention. When medication was administered, midazolam was used in 83% of cases, indicating a successful national shift toward it as the standard of care due to its versatile administration routes (intramuscular or intranasal).

The median time from the initial 9-1-1 dispatch to medication administration was 16.75 minutes. Once EMS arrived on the scene, the median time to administration was 9.63 minutes. Notably, medication administration was significantly faster in urban settings and tended to slow as the patient's age increased.

Demographic Findings

An interesting gender disparity was observed: females were significantly more likely to receive antiepileptic medications than males (aOR 1.22). While the study identifies this trend, the authors suggest that further research is required to determine if this stems from clinical differences or underlying provider bias.

Discussion and Limitations

The primary limitation of this study is the retrospective nature of the NEMSIS database. The data does not explicitly state whether a child was actively seizing upon the arrival of EMS, which is the critical clinical indicator for medication. Furthermore, significant missing data regarding race, ethnicity, and insurance status prevented a thorough analysis of socioeconomic disparities.

Future research should focus on capturing "on-scene" clinical status to determine if the 9% medication rate represents appropriate clinical restraint or systemic undertreatment. Additionally, the findings highlight a clear need for policy interventions to bolster ALS availability in rural and wilderness regions, ensuring that a child's survival and neurological outcome are not dictated by their zip code.

Summary updated

Abstract

The majority of children in the US receive ALS responses for seizures. Although medications are infrequently administered, the majority who received medications had midazolam given, which is the current standard of care. Further research should determine the proportion of children who are continuing to seize upon EMS arrival and would most benefit from immediate treatment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{firnberg2023national,
  author = {Maytal Firnberg and E. Brooke Lerner and Nan Nan and Chang‐Xing Ma and Manish I. Shah and N. Clay Mann and Peter Dayan},
  title = {{National Variation in EMS Response and Antiepileptic Medication Administration for Children with Seizures in the Prehospital Setting}},
  booktitle = {Western},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5811/westjem.59396},
}
Figure