National Survey of Hospitalists' Experiences with Incidental Pulmonary Nodules

Craig A. Umscheid, Jonathan Wilen, Matthew Garin, Jenna D Goldstein, Tessa S. Cook, Yulun Liu, Yong Chen, Jennifer S. MyersJournal of Hospital Medicine 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Incidental pulmonary nodules (IPNs) are common and often require follow-up. The Fleischner Society guidelines were created to support IPN management. We developed a 14-item survey to examine hospitalists' exposure to and management of IPNs. The survey targeted attendees of the 2016 Society of Hospital Medicine (SHM) annual conference. We recruited 174 attendees. In total, 82% were identified as hospitalist physicians and 7% as advanced practice providers; 63% practiced for >5 years and 62% supervised trainees. All reported seeing ≥1 IPN case in the past six months, with 39% seeing three to five cases and 39% seeing six or more cases. Notwithstanding, 42% were unfamiliar with the Fleischner Society guidelines. When determining the IPN follow-up, 83% used radiology report recommendations, 64% consulted national or international guidelines, and 34% contacted radiologists; 34% agreed that determining the follow-up was challenging; only 15% reported availability of automated tracking systems. In conclusion, despite frequent IPN exposure, hospitalists are frequently unaware of the Fleischner Society guidelines and rely on radiologists' recommendations.

Introduction

As chest imaging becomes more sensitive and frequent, clinicians are increasingly identifying "incidental" pulmonary nodules (IPNs)—small lesions unrelated to the primary reason for scanning. While most are benign, some represent early-stage malignancies requiring longitudinal monitoring. In the acute hospital setting, managing these nodules is complex. Hospitalists often focus on immediate recovery, and IPNs may "fall through the cracks" during the transition to primary care. This study investigates the national landscape of how hospitalists perceive and manage this safety risk.

Methods and Demographics

A descriptive study was conducted using a 14-item survey administered at the 2016 Society of Hospital Medicine (SHM) annual conference. The target audience included hospitalist physicians and advanced practice providers. Data were collected via tablets and follow-up emails, resulting in 174 responses from approximately 3,954 attendees.

Demographics and practice characteristics of the survey respondents.

The cohort was experienced, with 63% having practiced for over five years and 62% supervising trainees. Respondents represented a broad geographic distribution across the United States, as detailed in the demographic summary above.

Results

Exposure and Guideline Familiarity

All respondents reported encountering at least one IPN in the previous six months, with 78% seeing three or more cases. Despite this high frequency, 42% of hospitalists were unfamiliar with the Fleischner Society guidelines, the clinical standard for IPN management. Interestingly, hospitalists who supervise medical students or residents were significantly more likely to be familiar with these guidelines (OR 1.96), suggesting that academic engagement promotes adherence to evidence-based standards.

Management Strategies and Challenges

When determining follow-up care, 83% of hospitalists rely on recommendations provided within the radiology report. This highlights the critical role of radiologists as the primary guide for inpatient management. Approximately 34% of respondents found determining the correct follow-up challenging.

Survey results detailing IPN exposure, decision-making factors, and perceived barriers to follow-up.

The primary barriers to effective follow-up included patient-related factors (39%), such as insurance or access issues, and scheduling difficulties (30%). Furthermore, only 15% of respondents reported having an automated system at their institution to track these nodules, leaving most clinicians to rely on manual documentation in discharge summaries.

Discussion

The study reveals a significant gap between the frequency of IPN encounters and the systematic infrastructure required to manage them. The heavy reliance on radiology reports suggests that embedding Fleischner Society recommendations directly into structured imaging templates could significantly improve care coordination.

Respondents expressed a strong desire for better systems: 64% wanted automatic notifications for "concerning results" and 47% favored notifications when a nodule is first detected. These findings support the development of dedicated IPN consult teams or automated tracking software to alleviate the administrative burden on hospitalists and ensure patient safety.

Limitations

The study is limited by a low response rate (4.4%), which may introduce selection bias toward clinicians with a specific interest in pulmonary care. Additionally, the results are based on self-reported data rather than direct clinical observation.

Conclusion

Hospitalists frequently encounter IPNs but often lack familiarity with management guidelines and access to robust tracking systems. Improving the integration of guideline-based recommendations into radiology reports and implementing automated tracking systems are essential steps toward closing the loop on incidental findings in the hospital setting.

Summary updated

Abstract

Incidental pulmonary nodules (IPNs) are common and often require follow-up. The Fleischner Society guidelines were created to support IPN management. We developed a 14-item survey to examine hospitalists' exposure to and management of IPNs. The survey targeted attendees of the 2016 Society of Hospital Medicine (SHM) annual conference. We recruited 174 attendees. In total, 82% were identified as hospitalist physicians and 7% as advanced practice providers; 63% practiced for >5 years and 62% supervised trainees. All reported seeing ≥1 IPN case in the past six months, with 39% seeing three to five cases and 39% seeing six or more cases. Notwithstanding, 42% were unfamiliar with the Fleischner Society guidelines. When determining the IPN follow-up, 83% used radiology report recommendations, 64% consulted national or international guidelines, and 34% contacted radiologists; 34% agreed that determining the follow-up was challenging; only 15% reported availability of automated tracking systems. In conclusion, despite frequent IPN exposure, hospitalists are frequently unaware of the Fleischner Society guidelines and rely on radiologists' recommendations.
BibTeX
@article{umscheid2019national,
  author = {Craig A. Umscheid and Jonathan Wilen and Matthew Garin and Jenna D Goldstein and Tessa S. Cook and Yulun Liu and Yong Chen and Jennifer S. Myers},
  title = {{National Survey of Hospitalists' Experiences with Incidental Pulmonary Nodules}},
  journal = {Journal of Hospital Medicine},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.12788/jhm.3115},
}
Figure