Abstract
How to optimize entrepreneurial behavior and thus improve the quality of entrepreneurship is of central interest for both academics and practitioners. As a salient characteristic of entrepreneurial behavior is its dynamic match with external environment, research attention shifting from a focus on static entrepreneurial behavior to tracking dynamic changes in entrepreneurial behavior is warranted. In this study, we posit that behavior is simultaneously influenced by personality, cognition, and environment, and explore how an entrepreneur’s narcissism affects his/her behavioral change and following performance. Further, we investigate how narcissism interacts with experience in affecting behavioral change and its performance implications across different cognitive contexts and business environments. Our findings contribute to the research on entrepreneurial behavior and entrepreneurial psychology, as well as accumulate knowledge on how to help entrepreneurs understand themselves and improve their ability of decision making.
Introduction: The Dynamics of Serial Entrepreneurship
Most entrepreneurship research treats behavior as a static snapshot—you either have "entrepreneurial orientation" or you don't. However, real-world entrepreneurship is a dynamic process of trial, error, and adjustment. Serial entrepreneurs aren't just repeating the same playbook; they are constantly adjusting their strategies.
A critical gap remains: why do some serial entrepreneurs learn from their past ventures while others repeat the same mistakes? This paper focuses on narcissism—a trait characterized by grandiosity, a need for admiration, and a lack of empathy—as a primary driver of how entrepreneurs interpret feedback and decide whether to pivot or persevere.
Theoretical Framework: The Narcissist's Paradox
The core of this research is a conceptual framework that deconstructs "behavioral change" into two distinct dimensions:
- Content Change: Changes in the "what" (e.g., switching industries, targeting new customer segments, or launching different products).
- Logic Change: Changes in the "how" (e.g., shifting decision-making styles, resource acquisition strategies, or internal management logic).
Narcissists are often "attention seekers" but "ego defenders." This leads to a specific behavioral pattern: they are highly likely to change the content of their business to appear bold and innovative, but unlikely to change their underlying logic, as admitting their previous logic was flawed would damage their self-image.
The Role of Experience and Feedback
When a venture fails, a narcissist is likely to attribute the failure to external factors. To protect their self-image, they might pivot to a completely new industry (high content change) while doubling down on their original, flawed decision-making process (low logic change) to prove they were "right all along." Conversely, success may reinforce their existing logic, potentially leading to stagnation in strategic evolution.
Moderating Factors: Cognition and Environment
The impact of these behavioral changes on re-entrepreneurship performance is not direct; it is moderated by cognitive and environmental factors as shown in the theoretical model:
- Cognitive Monitoring: The ability to self-reflect and adjust strategies based on feedback can buffer the negative effects of narcissism. High-performing narcissistic entrepreneurs are likely those who have developed meta-cognitive skills to override ego-driven biases.
- Environmental Fit: Narcissistic behavioral changes are more effective in dynamic environments, where rapid pivots are rewarded, and munificent environments, where abundant resources can cushion the blow of risky "flashy" changes.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This paper provides a novel theoretical model for understanding how personality traits like narcissism drive the evolution of entrepreneurial behavior. While the model offers testable propositions, empirical validation using longitudinal data is needed. Future research should also explore other "Dark Triad" traits, such as Machiavellianism and Psychopathy, and develop robust scales for measuring "logic change." Practically, this work can inform entrepreneurial education, helping founders recognize their own biases to improve decision-making quality.
Summary updated